17 responses to Amish Markets
  • *
    Comment on Glenn's Bulk Food - Pleasantview, KS (January 4th, 2014 at 19:15)

    Glenn's Bulk Food - Pleasantview, KS

    Glenn’s Bulk Food in Pleasantview, KS

  • *
    Debe Yoder Hooley
    Comment on Amish store located in Central Alabama (May 10th, 2014 at 22:18)

    Amish store located in Central Alabama

    Established in December 2007 a unique gift and craft shop opened in memory of my parents Bill & Edna Yoder (formally of the Amish faith).
    Amish food, cheese, baked goods. Plus many handcrafted items.
    Phone 256 245-7345
    Email yodersgifts@hotmail.com
    10 West 1st Street, Sylacauga, AL 35150

  • *
    Philip & Darlene Moberg
    Comment on Missed Wisconsin Amish grocery store (May 12th, 2014 at 19:26)

    Missed Wisconsin Amish grocery store

    Mishler’s Country Store, southwest of Dalton, Wisconsin, on Barry Road (Highway HH), East of Kiefer Road and West of Grouse Road. Also, the Amish-run “Salemville Cheese Factory”, W4481 County Road GG, Cambria, WI 53923; 920-394-3431; M-F, 8 to 5 and Sat, 8 to 4.

  • *
    Comment on Amish Markets (July 5th, 2014 at 18:25)

    Erik, I don’t know if this is of any significance to you, but there there are a couple of items that are not / no longer correct. I’m pretty sure that the three Jamesport businesses of Country Acres, Graber Nursery, and Homestead Creamery are all owned by German Baptists. At least the first two are listed above as Amish.

    • *
      Comment on Jamesport MO area businesses (July 5th, 2014 at 20:39)

      Jamesport MO area businesses

      Thanks Don, updated them with that info. I found 2 of them described as German Baptist-owned online. Graber’s Nursery didn’t have the same description, but if you can confirm that I’ll change it too. Thanks for pointing that out. http://jamesport.net/country/country_002.htm

      • *
        Rita Toussaint
        Comment on Graber Farm (November 22nd, 2015 at 01:34)

        Graber Farm

        Mary Graber ia a friend of mine & she is Old Order Amish.

  • *
    Catherine Segal
    Comment on amish markets (January 27th, 2015 at 20:34)

    amish markets

    Fyi, by no stretch of imagination could Western Market in Ferndale, Michigan be construed as an Amish Market. It is a typical produce/meat/deli. I wouldn’t say anything except I would hate for anyone to take a longish ride there only to be disappointed. It is a nice produce market, but probably 150+ miles from anything Amish.

    • *
      Comment on Amish Markets (January 28th, 2015 at 12:59)

      Thanks, Catherine. Would you say our description of that location is accurate?

      “Carries some Amish products including fresh meats, cheeses and produce.”

      If so, I hope people who visit this page will read our description at the top (copied below), and not travel far expecting to find Amish people at a given market where they might not be (or, call first to be sure). Likewise we try to describe those places known to be Amish-run as “Amish store” or “Amish business”:

      “Amish Market” can mean different things. This directory includes:

      1.Venues commonly described as “Farmer’s Markets” or “PA Dutch Markets”, where Amish vendors sell goods a few days each week, such as those near cities like Baltimore and Washington, D.C.
      2.Non-Amish vendors selling Amish foods and other Amish goods
      3.Produce markets offering Amish-raised fruits and vegetables
      4.Amish-run shops located in Amish communities, typically selling food and related products

  • *
    Catherine Segal
    Comment on Amish Markets (January 28th, 2015 at 23:35)

    Amish Markets

    Before I reply to your question, please know that I love this site, the good info and leads about Amish activities and bits and pieces of Amish news and info on new books on Amish Life. I enjoy seeing a site like yours where honest/real info is shared about Amish life. That being said, I found this list with its inclusion of “carries some Amish products including fresh meats, cheeses and produce” inaccurate. I guess it all goes to the definition of the word “some”. I may be able to find limited packages of chicken prepackaged as Millers, and a pint of cottage cheese using the name Yoder. But I could go to many stores, even big box, and see that.

    I just feel like listing a store such as Western Market as selling Amish goods, whatever catagory it’s put in is misleading. My concern was about product only, not “…….traveling far to expect Amish people.”

    I guess to me it is like the Amish Space heaters, not made by the Amish. Or Amish toys with a made in China tag.

    Just my thoughts, feel free to delete. Cathie Catsegal@gmail.com

    • *
      Comment on Amish Markets (January 29th, 2015 at 08:53)

      Sure, then I’ve just removed it as it sounds like you’re confirming they don’t sell any Amish-made products. There’s no intent to mislead (and I don’t know how we would even gain from that, it’s not like anyone on this free list pays for inclusion, it’s just meant to be a service for people looking for Amish products).

      We use a variety of sources to create these including online sources and what can be found on websites, and whenever this was created there was probably enough information to suggest that they carried “some Amish products” as we described it, so it fit in one of the 4 categories we describe at the top. We put all 4 groups in one list here because when creating it it didn’t really make sense to have 4 different lists.

      I hope people understand that they should check a place out before traveling a long way, I usually just assume that is understood (that’s why we give the website and phone info too). Additionally, the character of a business and its product line can change over time, which could also be a factor (so this can’t be an up to the minute account of what a place is selling). Basically we rely on reader feedback to adjust these lists over time, so thanks for the info and helping with the list. And thanks for your kind comments on the site!

  • *
    Comment on Apple Creek Amish Market in Utah (February 5th, 2015 at 17:38)

    Apple Creek Amish Market in Utah

    A new store has opened in Utah, selling Troyer deli meats and cheese, bulk food, Lebanon bologna, jarred jams, pickled foods, and Amish roll butter, according to the article, “Amish market store opens in southeast Provo.” The owner has Amish friends in St. Ignatius, Montana.

    Apple Creek Amish Market
    1331 S. State St., Provo, Utah
    Info: (801) 866-4988.

    http://www.heraldextra.com/news/local/amish-market-store-opens-in-southeast-provo/article_a21af45f-2804-5050-a2d8-085e1d9b1518.html (with 9 photos)

  • *
    Deborah Rinehart
    Comment on Bulk Foods Store (September 20th, 2015 at 20:10)

    Bulk Foods Store

    I go to a bulk foods store regularly in Shipshewana called

    E & S Sales
    1265 N. State Road 5
    Shipshewana, IN

    They sell bulk food and regular can foods, cereals, coffee, frozen food, etc. They do sell a variety of cheese, Amish baked goods, and fresh produce. They do have a small deli and their ice cream is a big hit.
    The Amish community shop there so one must be mindful of all the buggies parked alongside the building. A young Amish boy will take your groceries to the car so remember to give him a little something. Both Amish and English shop here.

    Another store I go to regularly is
    Yoder Meat and Cheese
    435 S. Van Buren Street (SR5)
    Shipshewana, Indiana 46565

    This is a family run business. They have 80 different kind of cheese. They have every kind of meat you would want-chicken, beef, and pork. The meat is individually wrapped in white paper like in the old days. I like to buy the meat frozen. They have a wide variety of jerky too. If you get there at the right time, you will see the young Amish girls bringing in fresh eggs and produce.

    Hope this helps some folks. These stores are not tourist attraction, but real Amish places to shop.

  • *
    Steve Cooper
    Comment on BB's Grocery Outlets (October 26th, 2015 at 11:02)

    BB's Grocery Outlets

    BB’s Grocery Outlets is one of the largest group of Amish owned grocery stores in Pennsylvania. They sell fresh meats, bulk foods and dairy items as well as “closeout and salvage” grocery “deals”
    The website is http://www.bbsgrocery.com/
    They have been is business since the 1980’s

  • *
    Margie Funke
    Comment on Amish Businesses (December 1st, 2015 at 17:34)

    Amish Businesses

    Hi Eric,
    I love all the posts of Amish America and the Business Directory. Some time ago, I asked you if you would compile of list of stores that actually cater to the Amish. I am a sales rep for a Christian Publishing House and I have found stores with Amish customers actually do quite well with our children’s books. You replied with the names of some stores and I contacted all that were not already customers of ours. Will you be listing these businesses any time in the near future? Also, would it be possible to list stores that you visit while touring areas with Amish communities.

  • *
    Dorothy. M. Jackson
    Comment on Looking For ...Pumpkin CreamCheese Spread/ (January 26th, 2017 at 13:46)

    Looking For ...Pumpkin CreamCheese Spread/

    I live in Monroe,La. Is there a market near us to purchase some….my husband is a OTR-trucker he brought some home, and it was Delicious…I gotta have some more!! I think there’s one in Ark,that’s probably the closest to me I think….let me know what you find not far away..Piz!!
    Thxs in advance. Mrs D.Jackson

  • *
    Beuna Tomalino
    Comment on Amish Markets (September 7th, 2018 at 07:18)

    Another for your list: Applecreek Amish Market, Willard, Utah http://applecreek.squarespace.com/

Leave a reply to Amish Markets


Resource List

Reliable information from one of the largest Amish sites on the web.

Join over 15,000 email subscribers to get:
Amish Community Info | Book Giveaways | Amish Writers & non-Amish Experts | More

Get email updates

100% Free | No Spam | Unsubscribe Anytime