Find an Amish Market in the Buckeye State

OH Amish MarketWith over 60,000 Amish living within its borders, Ohio is home to numerous Amish markets.  Many can be found in the state’s two largest Amish communities, at Holmes County and Geauga County.

Markets selling Amish products can also be found in the vicinity of Ohio cities including Cleveland, Cincinnati, and Columbus, and elsewhere in the state.

Find an Amish market near you using the guide below.

Amish Markets in OH

Know of a good OH Amish market? Let us know in the comments section.

Amish Heritage Country Market
728 North Main Street
Marysville, OH
Finest Amish cheeses and meats, as well as baked goods from an authentic Amish bakery available every Saturday morning.

Walnut Creek Amish Flea Market
1900 Ohio 39
Sugarcreek, OH
330-852 – 0181
Walnut Creek Amish Flea Market is one of many popular tourist destination in Ohio Amish Country. Among a ragne of products from both by Amish and non Amish vendors, you can find the Amish Country Bakery providing a broad choice of Amish-baked breads, cookies, bars, cakes and pies.

Dutch Valley Market
1411 Old Route 39
Sugarcreek, OH
330 852 2631
Dutch Valley Market is part of a complex including Dutch Valley Restaurant and the Carlisle Inn. The market features a range of homemade Amish products such as all-natural meats, traditional foods, cheeses, canned goods, jams and jellies.

Keim Family Amish Market

Hutches and other outdoor products for sale outside Keim Family Market in southern Ohio

Keim Family Market
2621 Burnt Cabin Road
Seaman, OH
Amish-owned and operated business, features Amish baked pies, breads, cookies, pastries, meats, cheeses, canned goods, jams and jellies among handcrafted indoor and outdoor furniture, playhouses, play sets, barns, sheds and more.

Miller’s Furniture, Bakery & Bulk Foods
960 Wheat Ridge Road
West Union, OH
This is an Amish owned business operated by the Miller brothers, in business for over 30 years. They carry a wide array of Amish-baked goods, bulk foods, cheeses, meats and much more.

The Valley Marketplace
6121 South Ave
Boardman, OH 44512
Broad selection of Amish made foods, fresh produce, cheeses, and meats.

Walnut Creek Cheeses
2641 State Route 39
Walnut Creek, OH
Locally made foods and goods by Amish and Mennonite vendors.

Friendly Meadows Country Store
30341A Coshocton Rd
Walhonding, OH 43843
Provides a variety of Amish groceries including bulk foods, cheeses, dairy.

Mary Yoder’s Amish Kitchen
14743 North State Street
Middlefield, OH
Amish operated restaurant, bakery and gift shop, located in Geauga County in northeast Ohio.

Amish Country Deli & More
112 S Front St
Fremont, OH
Family owned business, the only one in the area of Fremont, OH. Carries a broad choice of Amish made meats, cheeses, canned and baked goods and more.

Troyers A Country Market
5201 CR 77
Millersburg, OH
Troyers Country Market was established by Jonas Troyer in 1961. Features a large selection of foods, meats, fresh produce and grocery items made both by Amish and non Amish vendors. Special line of Amish wedding foods available.

A Taste of Amish Deli
133 E Wooster St
Bowling Green, OH
Meats, cheeses, jams, pies, jellies, candy made by Amish from Ohio communities.

Krieger’s Health Foods Market
615 Graham Rd,
Cuyahoga Falls, OH
Broad choice of products both made by Amish and non Amish suppliers.

Shisler’s Cheese House
55 Kidron Rd
Orrville, OH
Carries a wide selection of products including cheeses, meats, bulk foods, jams, jellies and more. Cheeses are locally made using milk from hormone-free cows. Some Amish-made cheese available as well.

Millers Amish Bakery Gifts Adams Co OH

Outside Miller’s Bakery & Gifts, Adams County, OH

Conines Country Market
21727 Ohio 12
Fostoria, OH
Family owned and operated business, features fresh fruits, vegetables, flowers, bedding plants, fresh cheeses, meats and Amish baked goods.

Lynd Fruit Farm
9090 Morse Rd SW
Pataskala, OH
Offers a vast array of products supplied by different vendors including Amish ones. Some Amish made products including baked and canned goods, butter and milk.

Ashery Farms
659 S 30th St
Heath, OH
Fresh local items provided by Amish and Mennonite farmers.

Medbery MarketPlace
403 N Whitewoman St
Coshocton, OH
Features a range of cheeses selected by hand from Ohio vendors including Pearl Valley Swiss, Walnut Creek Swiss, Guggisberg Swiss, Ementaeler Swiss and Heini’s Swiss Cheese.

Wayne’s Country Market
2440 Lexington Ave
Mansfield, OH
Wayne’s Country Market is a family owned and operated business, established in 1993 by Wayne and Gayle Meadows. Carries a broad selection of local Ohio products including Amish baked goods from Troyer’s Bakery
Hershberger Bakery and Miller’s Bakery.

Holmes County Flea Market
4568 Ohio 39
Millersburg, OH
An extensive selection of products from foods to crafts and furniture. Some Amish homemade goods available as well.

White Feather Farms of Ohio
13231 Refugee Rd SW
Pataskala, OH
Carries eggs from Amish farms.

Romano’s Farmers Market & Deli
8875 Ridge Rd
Cleveland, OH
Amish pies, cheeses and grocery items available.

Brown’s Deli
740 NW Washington Blvd
Hamilton, OH
Offers some Amish made products including jams and jellies, relishes and more.

Kirwen’s Super Market
104 W Madison St
Gibsonburg, OH
Amish baked goods available every Thursday including pies, rolls, cookies and breads.

Homer Village Market
964 Homer Rd NE
Utica, OH
Amish cheeses.

Covered Wagon Farm Market
607 N Main St
Union, OH
A broad choice of Amish made products such as baked goods, bulk foods, jam and jellies, pickles, candy, honey and more.

Ebbert Farm Market 
68101 Ebbert North Rd
St Clairsville, OH
Family owned market, specializes in fresh picked sweet corn, tomatoes, peaches, apples and more. They provide some Amish jams, jellies and candies as well.

Holmes Co Flea Market photo: CarbonNYC/flickr; Keim Family Market & Miller’s Bakery photos: J. Stephen Conn/flickr

You might also like:

Get the Amish in your inbox

    Question on the Amish? Get answers to 300+ questions in 41 categories at the Amish FAQ.