Amish Controversies

“Legal War on the Amish”: Attorney Fights For Breeder Who Killed 4 Unsold Puppies

“Legal War on the Amish”: Attorney Fights For Breeder Who Killed 4 Unsold Puppies

After last week’s animal cruelty case, I really wasn’t looking to write more on Amish-owned dogs coming to harm. But here we are. Today we see a report on an Amish dog breeder named John S. Stoltzfus Jr. The Lancaster County resident got himself into trouble after it was learned that, in late 2023, he had killed four Sheepadoodle puppies which weren’t selling. From the…

Vaccine Mandate After All? Amish School Parents Lose 2nd Round — Court Finds Case “Without Merit”

Vaccine Mandate After All? Amish School Parents Lose 2nd Round — Court Finds Case “Without Merit”

Amish parents in New York face a setback in the latest of a back-and-forth series of court decisions. In news released Tuesday, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled against the Amish parents and schools in the long-running case over vaccine requirements in New York schools. As a reminder, the current NY law requires vaccines not only in public schools, but in privately-operated ones…

Amish Father: County Threatened To Take My Children Over Outhouse Permits

Amish Father: County Threatened To Take My Children Over Outhouse Permits

The county, for its part, “vehemently den[ies]” that claim, according to new reporting at Cowboy State Daily. The issue is one we looked at last week in the Amish community at Hulett, Wyoming. A non-Amish rancher claimed that Crook County officials were driving Amish families away due to how it was handling a dispute over Amish use of outhouses. The man in question claimed that…

Amish Owner Planned to Breed His Injured Dog, Then Put Her Down. A Shelter Got Her First

Amish Owner Planned to Breed His Injured Dog, Then Put Her Down. A Shelter Got Her First

A really sad, and maddening, story was reported last week out of upstate New York. Some of this is hard to read. Via WWNY: POTSDAM, New York (WWNY) – Warning: the photos and description of the dog’s injury may be upsetting The St. Lawrence County Sheriff’s Office is investigating a suspected case of animal cruelty after a severely injured dog was brought to the Potsdam…

$30,000 Daily Fines? Rancher Claims “Stupid” Outhouse Crackdown Is Forcing Amish Out Of Wyoming Community

$30,000 Daily Fines? Rancher Claims “Stupid” Outhouse Crackdown Is Forcing Amish Out Of Wyoming Community

Another conflict over outhouses has roiled an Amish community in America’s least-populated state, with a rancher claiming threats of massive fines have caused local Amish families to start leaving. Hulett in Crook County is the site of Wyoming’s largest and oldest Amish settlement – about 190 people according to Young Center estimates, or roughly 40 families according to the report by Kate Meadows at Cowboy…

School Board Member: The Amish Weren’t “Used” To Vote Down School Budget – They Simply “Did the Math”

School Board Member: The Amish Weren’t “Used” To Vote Down School Budget – They Simply “Did the Math”

Last week we heard from the school superintendent of Randolph Central Schools in Cattaraugus County, New York, who placed blame for a local budget’s failure to pass on both the Amish, and those he claimed “used” the Amish to “flood the vote”. In that post I noted that those Amish living in the district, and thus having every right to vote, were likely motivated by…

Superintendent Claims Hundreds of Amish Were “Trucked In” To Vote Down a School Budget

Superintendent Claims Hundreds of Amish Were “Trucked In” To Vote Down a School Budget

You’re probably aware that the Amish vote much less often than non-Amish do. But a notable minority still do vote in general elections, and on local matters. So it’s not that odd to hear of Amish people voting. But I’d never seen a story quite like this before. In a new report, a school superintendent in New York is complaining about Amish participation in a…

Amish Fishermen Caught & Kept a Giant 40-Pound Muskie and Some Are Not Happy About It

Amish Fishermen Caught & Kept a Giant 40-Pound Muskie and Some Are Not Happy About It

A pair of videos have been making the rounds showing an Amish fisherman and a boy – who I would guess is his son – hauling away a giant fish after a successful catch. The fish is a muskellunge, better known as a “muskie” – and you can tell by the way the man is lugging it on his back that it is a hefty…

County Spent Hundreds of Thousands on Roads — Amish Traffic Is Damaging Them “Almost Immediately”

County Spent Hundreds of Thousands on Roads — Amish Traffic Is Damaging Them “Almost Immediately”

According to local officials,Amish traffic in Branch County, Michigan has been destroying roads – despite the county spending hundreds of thousands of dollars to maintain them. And unlike in other cases, this goes beyond standard buggy traffic. From the Coldwater Daily Reporter: [Manager Jay] Miller said that despite hundreds of thousands of dollars spent on Ray-Quincy, Copeland, and Hamman Roads over the last three years,…

This State Could Seize Homeowners’ Land to Build An Amish Buggy Lane – and Residents Say They’re Being Ignored

This State Could Seize Homeowners’ Land to Build An Amish Buggy Lane – and Residents Say They’re Being Ignored

There is a plan to build a buggy lane on U.S. 6, a highway in the Nappanee, Indiana settlement. But residents of Bremen, a town in the community, say their concerns are being ignored as the plan moves forward, seemingly full speed ahead. The Indiana Department of Transportation apparently promised residents “open houses” to discuss the topic – which reportedly never happened. It’s described as…