Amish Markets – New Jersey

NJ Amish Market Directory

NJ Amish MarketDespite not having any Amish population, New Jersey is home to quite a few Amish markets. Amish vendors, typically from Lancaster County, PA, travel to locations throughout the Garden State to operate market stands selling a variety of foods, crafts, and furniture.

Find an NJ Amish market near you in the listings below.

Amish Markets in New Jersey

Know of a good NJ Amish market? Let us know in the comments section.

Amish Farmers Market in Mullica Hill
108 Swedesboro Road
Mullica Hill, NJ
Amish homemade fresh foods, meats, cheeses, jellies, candy, produce, sandwiches. Amish vendors include Beiler’s Bakery, Dutch Country Deli, Dutch Family Fresh Meats, Yoder’s BBQ, Ellie’s Cheese Barn and many more.

Pennsylvania Dutch Farmers Market
4437 Route 27
Princeton, NJ
Home to Beiler’s dairy, Smoker’s deli, Stoltzfus’ poultry and soft pretzels, Fisher’s bakery, K & R lunch counter, fresh produce, juices and more.

The Greater Bridgeton Amish Market
760 Shiloh Pike
Bridgeton, NJ
An extensive selection of Amish homemade foods such as baked goods, pretzels, country deli, cheeses, meats, bulk foods, candy, salads, and more. The Greater Bridgeton Market also holds some social event like concerts, cruise nights, and peach festivals.

Williamstown Farmers & Village Shoppes
701 North Black House Pike
Williamstown, NJ
Features Amish homemade meats, pretzels, deli, cheeses, fresh produce. Amish restaurant also on the premises.

Columbus Farmers Market
2919 Route 206
Columbus, NJ
Provides a broad selection of Amish made products including fresh meats, eggs, poultry, soft pretzels, ice-cream, baked goods, doughnuts, pies, cold cuts, cheeses, salads, candy and more.

Dutch Country Farmers Market
19 Commerce Street
Flemington, NJ
Wide selection of fresh Amish produce, baked goods, sweet treats and home-style Amish foods from Lancaster County, PA.

Covered Wagon Amish Farmer’s Market
101 NJ-70
Medford, NJ 08055
A small but highly-reviewed market east of Philadelphia.

Berlin Farmer’s Market
41 Clementon Rd
Berlin, NJ 08009
Home of the Country Hill Amish Bakery featuring cakes, breads, donuts, cupcakes, cookies, pastries, rice cakes, chicken & beef pot pies, and more.

Trenton Farmers’ Market
960 Spruce St
Lawrence Township, NJ 08648
Amish-run King Foods “comfort food” establishment offers breakfast sandwiches, fried chicken, ribs, and more.

Updated Jan 20222

Get the Amish in your inbox

Join 15,000 email subscribers. No spam. 100% free

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


    1. Need Amish made Jellys and jams

      I have a small business in Red bank,NJ and I would really like to carry Amish made Jellys and Jams.
      And possibility other Amish made products.
      I would really appreciate if someone could help me find a supplier for such products.

      Thank you Very much
      In advance
      Ralph Citarella
      Citarellas Market

      1. Linda

        Amish-made Jams

        Hello, Ralph,
        Amish America had a post about Amish Jams:

        Miller’s Country Crafts, Homestyle Jams and Jellies, of Ava, Illinois, was pictured in:

        Kuntry Kettle makes jams and jellies. Amish.
        166 Gordon Road
        Ava, IL 62907
        Phone: (618) 426-1600

        Ozark Country Kitchen has Jams, jellies, bakery. Amish.
        3601 HIGHWAY 123, Dunnegan, Missouri, 65640,
        Business Phone Number (417) 754-2523

        Amish Wedding Foods is a brand from Ohio with jams and jellies.

        Mrs. Miller’s Homemade Jams of Ohio:

        Several owners who have an Amish background, but are now Beachy Amish:
        Yoder’s Fine Foods, Gambier, Ohio. They make jams, jellies, and butters:

        Byler’s Relish House Product, Amish Style Jams, Pennsylvania:

        (Retailers of Byler’s Relish House Products, list of stores with map at the bottom)

        Das Jam Haus, Tennessee:

        Kauffmans Fruit Farm, Apple Butter, Pennsylvania:

        Kauffmans Fruit Farm has a vendor locator, by zip code:

      2. Linda

        Amish food vendors and suppliers

        Troyer’s Country Market, Troyer Meat, Troyer Cheese, Amish Wedding Foods, Ohio:

        Walnut Creek Foods, Ohio, Roll Butter:

        Bulk Foods by Dutch Valley, Pennsylvania:

        Northern Lights Wholesale, Lena, Wisconsin:

        Yoder Popcorn, Indiana:

        Mrs. Miller’s Homemade Noodles, of Ohio, store finder:

        Little Barn Noodles Retailers by State:

        Tried and True Granola, Ohio, vendor page:

        Where to buy Kutztown Soda. Many plain places, may not be up to date:

        Where to buy wooden Play Mor Swing Sets, Dealers:

        Herbal book Saving Tristan, Herbal Compounds, Store Locator, may not be up to date:

    2. Poor n. broke

      In need of Bulk Rice/Beans and/or Water

      Is there any way to buy Bulk (50 – 100 lbs)Rice/Dried Beans/oats … etc…etc from Amish Markets ?

    3. EILEEN L

      Wrong info for Bridgeton Amish Market

      We have received telephone calls, so I am providing this info.
      You have the wrong address and telephone number listed for the Greater Bridgeton Amish Market

      The information you provided is for the location and tele # for South Jersey Water Conditioning, which is 2 doors down from the Amish Market

      Online listing shows their address/tel #
      2 Cassidy Court, Bridgeton, NJ 08302
      Phone: (856) 497-9810

      Eileen Leathern
      Employee at South Jersey Water Conditioning Service