The peculiar ‘White’ Jonas Stutzman

Sitting on the lawn around the firepit last week with some Amish friends, talk turned to ‘White’ Jonas Stutzman, who once lived just a few miles away.  Stutzman was one of the first Amish settlers in Holmes County.  He was also one of the oddest.



‘White’ Jonas is portrayed in a local attraction, Behalt–a huge cycloramic painting of Anabaptist history, done about fifteen years ago by a Catholic German artist.  The pioneer Amishman got his nickname from a habit of only wearing white clothing, a result of one of his visions.

Stutzman had some odd ideas.

One of them was his prophecy of Christ’s return.  Steven Nolt in A History of the Amish explains that Stutzman published a booklet announcing his revelations and warning all to repent, for church leaders to stop observing communion, and to purify themselves for the Lord’s arrival, which Stutzman claimed would occur in 1853.

The booklet was published in English rather than German.  Nolt speculates that this was done in order to communicate with a wider audience.

Stutzman even prepared a wooden chair for Christ’s return.  It sits in the center of the cyclorama room.  Since we should always ‘hold Christ above us’, Stutzman made the chair larger than an ordinary one.  As picture-taking is not allowed inside the cyclorama, the friendly folks at Behalt removed it to the lobby so that I could get a photo.

My Amish friend also claimed that Stutzman had an aversion to wheels.  Checking with the helpful people at Behalt seemed to confirm this.  A Mennonite lady who’s worked there many years felt that it may have had something to do with a Biblical connection of wheeled travel with chariots of war.

Wherever he got the idea, apparently it held even after his passing.  Upon death, Stutzman was carried miles rather than being carted to his final resting place.

She also wanted me to understand that besides being an eccentric, Stutzman played a part in easing differences among the Amish.  When local progressives wanted a meetinghouse, Stutzman donated land for them to build one.  The land is still in this particular church’s possession, though the old building has been torn down and a new one built.
Nolt summarizes:  ‘Although the Amish rejected Stutzman’s apocalyptic teaching, he remained a member of his church all his life, and most of his children joined the Old Order Amish…Said one Amish historian, “His peculiar views and dress were not seen as a threat to anyone, for he never had any followers.”  His unusual life grew out of honest conviction, not a spirit of rebellion.’

(Source:  Steven M. Nolt’s A History of the Amish, Revised and Updated).

Get the Amish in your inbox

Join 15,000 email subscribers. No spam. 100% free

    Similar Posts

    Leave a Reply to diane Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


    1. That was very interesting. I enjoyed reading it. Thanks

    2. Thanks Michelle, glad to hear it.

    3. I don’t know if you are familiar with what they call “The Amish Library” near Kline Lumber on rt 39 just east of Berlin, but they also have one or two chairs there from “Der Weiss” (at least when I was in there a year or so ago). Stop in a Kline Lumber and they will let you have access to their little library, which has a nice selection of Anabaptist books, as well as other materials. It is not a huge place, and they do not advertise the library, but it may be worth a visit for you.

      1. Dave Dayton

        Correct name of lumbe company

        The correct name of the lumber company Mike refers to in his Jan. 19, 2009 comment above is Keim Lumber in Charm, OH — a magnificent business. My wife and I visited there in the spring of this year.

        1. James Williamson

          FYI – Kline Lumber on rt 39 just east of Berlin is a few miles north of Keim Lumber in Charm Ohio.

    4. Gregory Stutzman

      I am directly descended from Jonas and I proudly carry on the tradition of eccentricity and out-of-the-box thinking that has permeated our gene pool throughout the generations.

    5. dawn ella stutzman

      i too eccentrically am!
      dawn ella stutzman

    6. Welcome Stutzmans! Looks like there are a few of you out there!

    7. Ruth Weaver

      I, too, am a descendant of Jonas Stutzman, though I am not Amish, my parents grew up Amish. I believe he was my great, great, great grandfather. Seems he had some strange ideas.
      Ruth Stutzman Weaver

    8. Loved reading this, thanks for sharing. How fun that some of his “family” have seen this too. I just had an Amish fella named Weaver build a table and hutch for me. He is in northern In and a wonderful person.

    9. Tom Rice

      do you sell Buggy wheel’s ?
      we need a 42 in.
      Thank you
      Tom Rice

    10. Wow i was learning about him in school and its about the same thing but it’s very interesting!!!! :~D

    11. jean


      Is Jonas Stutzman’s booklet still available somewhere online or as a reprint ? thank you

    12. Nancy Consolo

      Jonas Stuckman Booklet

      I too, would like a copy of the booklet if is available. Jonas Stutzman is in my genealogy tree.

    13. mary barrett


      I’ve always had a fascination for the Amish. This was interesting. I live in an amish community and this would be odd to see. 🙂

    14. diane

      First, Second, and Third Appeals to All Men

      I have a copy of Jonas’ “First, Second, and Third Appeals to All Men …” If you’d like a copy, please send me $5.00 and I’ll mail it to you.

    15. Mary Stutzman burlingame

      Interesting kin

      Just found out in the last year that I have blood connection to Holmes county. Leaves me with far more questions! The eccentric bend in Jonas certainly explains many in my family, self included. How fun! More interesting is the lineage to faith in Christ.