Amish Maple Syrup

Tom continues his New York Amish coverage with some photos of an Amish maple syrup operation in the Randolph, NY area (Conewango Valley Amish community).

Amish Maple Syrup


Maple Syrup Evaporator

Says Tom: “I have been in the sugar shack when Eli’s kids and grands are watching and the women are making pancakes and drawing hot syrup out of the pan to pour on the pancakes.  The hard work does have a sweet reward.”

Amish Maple Syrup Production


Tapping Trees Maple Syrup

Tapping trees.  Tom notes that “The maple season is going to be strange this year due to our not having a normal cold winter.  The sap is already starting to rise.”

Maple Syrup Sap

A couple days ago Richard introduced the “art of canning”.  Maple syrup has always seemed to have something of an art about it.  So how about an ode to sugaring season?

Maple Syrup Poem Amish

Tom says he is not sure who wrote this poem, but believe’s it is his friend’s wife’s work.

Come We're Making Maple Syrup

I’m pretty experienced at pouring maple syrup on my pancakes, but not at making it.  Anyone ever made it?

And do you have any maple syrup favorites?  Or any unusual uses (hot dog condiment, skin cleanser, etc ;))?

Get the Amish in your inbox

Join 15,000 email subscribers. No spam. 100% free

    Similar Posts

    Leave a Reply to Erik/Amish America Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


    1. Oh, yes, we sure did make it. My father used to compete with my maternal grandfather for the lightest syrup from the first run.

      I would encourage you to visit one of your Amish friends during sugaring season and help gather sap as well as how they boil it. Mmmmm, I can just smell it now as we’d come in with a tank full… the steam rising from the sugarhouse and sweetening up the woods. For more about that, you can visit my blog:

      You might call it a bit unusual to use maple syrup (of the darker variety for making pickled beets, but my mother did. I still make them that way, except I have to pay a lot more for the syrup!

      You’ve posted about Amish peanut butter — we also mixed it with peanut butter and sometimes marshmallow cream. That one makes me gag to this day, especially when I think of a “church” sandwich: sweet peanut butter, baloney, cheese, and pickles on white bread… you can read my about my thoughts on this one here:

      Most of the time we used maple syrup for what it was intended… pancakes or french toast. And we sometimes made popcorn balls as a treat. We were never without it. Okay, maybe we ran out a few times, just weeks before sugaring season started. Sugaring and maple syrup bring back sweet memories for me.

    2. Maple syrup poem

      Here are the words:

      Come! We’re Making Maple Syrup

      Spring is coming! We must hurry to the bush to gather sap.

      Grab your hatchet, spiles and buckets; skip that dinner nap.

      Crows are calling! Snow is melting! Patches in the field are bare.

      Spring is just around the corner, you can feel it in the air.

      To the bush we head with laughter, trudging through the mud and snow.

      Swing the brace and bit with vigor, tap the spile and watch it flow!

      Sap is trickling in the bucket! Oh! Tis music to my ears.

      Joy is surging through each muscle spring is really very near!

      As we move across the woodlot, stop and visit every tree.

      They become as friends we treasure in a grip of mystery.

      Overhead, the tree tops swaying, whisper “welcome back again.”

      What a tonic for the spirit, just to hear their sweet refrain.

      Now it’s time to gather buckets grab your pail and hurry out.

      See! They’re full and running over!

      Sap is dripping from each spout!

      To the sugar camp, triumphant, with a load of sap we go.

      Light the match and hear the crackle; soon we’ll see the fire glow.

      Now the pan begins to simmer and the steam begins to rise.

      Pouring out the ventilators, heading upward to the skies.

      Sweet aroma fills the shanty; oh tis sweeter every year;

      Catch a whiff of boiling syrup in this steaming atmosphere.

      Soon the family all assemble and the children gather round.

      Little ones just point in wonder at the steam and fire grand.

      Watch! The temperature is creeping higher!

      Soon the syrup will be done!

      Grab your spoon and join the tasters!

      Maple season has begun!

      Grandpa has his kettle steaming, stirring batter merrily;

      Frying golden apple fritters, this is grandpa’s specialty!

      Come; at last the syrup’s ready

      Oh that fresh, delicious taste!

      Pour some more upon your fritters, not a drop will go to waste.

      Soon forgotten all the labor, knee deep in snow and mud so vast.

      Now the hard work is rewarded, and it’s really spring at last!

    3. Roberta Klooster

      Maple syrup

      I’m so enjoying your posts, Saloma. They add so much to the pictures this site creates for us because you lived “among them”. I’m sure there are things you miss.

      The pictures are wonderful too! How I wish we were close enough to visit where the activity. I am copying the poem to send to my granddaughter who is a very good writer at 12 yrs. That one could be published as I can feel the joy through the verse.

      Delighting in the joy of the simple things,

    4. sarah

      Funny story… the amish in our area were just getting their dairies going last winter. One of my amish friends had asked me to buy her some maple extract at walmart while I was in town. I assumed it was for baking. I had never heard of maple extract before that … a few weeks later, she gave me a tub of maple cream. I was amazed that they had time to do syrup… turns out they hadn’t. It was marshmallow fluff and maple extract… hopefully this year they’ll have more time…

    5. Roberta Klooster

      LOL at that story, Sarah! Love it. Guess all women would like to spend a little less time in the kitchen if possible. I do imagine the Amish have much more work that us “English” though – I doubt I could keep up. We weren’t Amish, but living in the country with spring fed water (which necessitated a wringer washer), etc. with very limited funds my mother had a huge garden, cleared land, and many things the Amish and Mennonites still do today. And she did it all with joy. Maybe this is why I feel they are kindred spirits of mine. Roberta

      1. Time in the kitchen

        I am one woman who would love to spend more time in the kitchen … and the garden.

    6. Maple syrup

      Unusual uses? Maybe…I have put it on ice cream and oatmeal and used it in place of other sugars in recipes, including pecan pie, popcorn balls and most recently English Toffee. A little bit of maple syrup adds a new dimension to spicy dishes such as red beans or barbecue sauce. And yes, maple syrup is a must for apple fritters.
      That was a wonderful poem! Makes me want to slosh through some mud in pursuit of a sweet treasure.

    7. Alice Mary

      M-m-m-m! Maple!

      In the county where I live, the conservation district (we’re very into purchasing/conserving what space is left) does maple tree tapping, boiling, the works, as a demo every year. I’ve never attended, but I think my kids did when they were younger, via school field trips.

      Growing up in Chicago, Mom (a maple lover) bought “Mapleine” (sp?)extract, adding it to cooked sugar/water and made “homemade” syrup that way. I still buy Mapleine, but use it in baking and cooking hot cereal (oatmeal, cream of wheat).

      We had a small maple tree in our yard a few years back (we had planted it about 5 years prior) and one late winter day, I noticed it “weeping” through a crack in the bark. The tree was already under stress (dropped its leaves early) and died the following year. I had hopes I’d be able to tap it someday, but mother nature had other plans, I guess.

      I loved that “epic” poem! That, and viewing the photos of the sugar shack in operation, I could almost smell the aroma of maple syrup…m-m-m-m-m! I’m craving pancakes (not a good thing for a diabetic!).

      Alice Mary

      1. Lee Ann

        Alice Mary, My Mom did the same as yours with mapleline. We always had homemade syrup for our pancakes or waffles that way. I use maple in my baked beans and it taste better. I miss the maple harvest from Wisconsin. Used to go to the park and watch them harvest the sap and we could take containers to get some maple syrup to take home.

        With you being a diabetic use Agave syrup. Simular and better for you. Use it to replace sugar in most recipes.

    8. Richard from Amish Stories

      Another "art form" that i hope continues!

      Thanks for the ” The art” reference from me on this post Erik, and i would again consider this to be an art form. While some folks are designing city’s and building bridges for me anyway its always the very simple things like making maple syrup or canning that seems to interest me more, and as long as the Amish and the English continue to perform these old way traditions we should see “art forms” like this for a very long time, and not become something of a lost art. And for me that would be very sad to see, great post again my friend. Richard

    9. Natural vs. Artificial Maple Syrup

      I happened to have pancakes for breakfast this morning (coincidence). I used the artificial syrup though. I even think it was “Lite”.

    10. Lois Morgan

      Non Amish Maple Syrup

      I remember two things about “sugaring” very well. First, not realizing that the sap that ran from the tree wasn’t good AT ALL, and second that all that sap didn’t make very much syrup. We had to keep the fire going all night and New York in the winter isn’t very nice weather.
      This year, maybe!

    11. Roberta Klooster

      We’ve switched to real maple syrup for pancakes now that there are just two of us. Couldn’t afford it when we had all of the children at home!

    12. VTAnabaptist


      Tapped two weeks early here in VT, not sure what to make of this winter. Have had some good years sugaring with no snow on the ground though, time will tell.

    13. Memories of Randolph, and....

      Goodness gracious! I lived in Randolph many years ago! I now live in the Finger Lakes Region and last year, I tapped a few maples near the house and made up about a gallon and a half of syrup.

      One of my very favorite things to do with my syrup is to make barbeque sauce. I use a recipe that is a bit spicy, and the syrup adds a sweetness that throws it over the edge!

      I have recently discovered my ancestors who came here from Germany were Mennonites. I have always been interested in the Amish and Mennonite lifestyles, and perhaps now I know why!

      I have just discovered this site and am so happy I did!

      1. Glad you found us Katya! I would try maple syrup barbecue sauce 🙂

    14. Eli

      Oh No!

      Not lite artificial syrup! So wrong. The real thing is expensive, though. Times is hard for pancake/waffle aficionados. Wages – down, grocery prices – up, made from scratch waffles – suffer. 🙁

      1. Lite syrup

        Yep Eli, biting the bullet here 😉 Actually we never ate much of the real kind growing up, so I am kind of used to the more artificial version. I could do without the “Lite” though it didn’t taste as “Lite” as I thought it would.

    15. Al in Ky.

      I enjoyed the pictures, the poem and everyone’s comments. I’m
      going to give a copy of the poem to an Amish family I know who
      make lots of maple syrup.

      I am so fortunate to live not far from Orange County, Indiana where there are lots of Old Order Amish and Swartzentruber Amish who make maple syrup and sell it from their farms. The price is very reasonable compared to what you pay for it in town at one of the stores. For a few years, I was on a tangent to try to find the best Amish-made maple syrup in Orange County. I think I found it — and it was at an Amish farm that had no sign out “Syrup for Sale”. An Amish friend “Amos” told me to “go down the road and see if “Joe” might have some syrup”. When I drove in the driveway, “Joe” came out and acted like he didn’t know what I was talking about in terms of syrup for sale, until I told him that his friend “Amos” had told me to stop by. Then “Joe” gladly sold me two quarts of syrup and invited me to come back when I needed more. Another example of the great informal network amongst Amish people, that sometimes they will let their English friends be part of.

    16. Tom

      If you go to the Conewango settlement all the bake shops make maple syrup glazed donuts..could teach Dunkin and Tim Horton a thing or two.

    17. Slightly-handled-Order-man

      When I was in elementary school maple syrup season was one of my favorites because of the field trip to a local park that produced maple syrup. Of course the trips always involved more than just the process, it provided a nice winter time nature hike and got us out of conventional classes.
      Everyone bought maple syrup / sugar cookies (apparently almost pure maple syrup/sugar rather a person liked it or not.