Inside A Plain But Not-Quite-Finished Amish Home (16 Photos)

Returning to the Inside Amish Homes series, let’s have a look inside a very plain Amish home (and a little bit unfinished, at least on the outside).

This one is in Fultonville, New York and it generally has the look of a Swartzentruber home…but some details don’t seem quite right (the floor and a few other items in the home as I’ll show below).

There are no bathrooms in this home, which is a sort of dividing line between the plainest Amish homes and those that veer closer to English country homes.

Here’s the extensive description of this seven-bedroom home & property via Zillow:

There are about 98 acres here, of which up to 62 can be cropped and another 12 pastured. The remainder, 25 is wooded. Streams flow through that area. There are 2 farm ponds as well as 3 dug wells and a 225′ drilled well (no pump running on this) – plenty of good water. It has over 2000′ of road frontage and another 1450′ on an abandoned road. The home is 3 years old and the main barns just a bit older. All are exceptionally well- built.

The home sits just behind a small stand of sugar maple and large white pines, and has 2304 ft2 of living apace, with a full attic and a 4 room dry basement. Real hardwood floors are throughout. It looks nice.

Downstairs is an open floor plan with large common rooms, K-DR, living room, foyer, and a pantry plus woodshed and master bedroom. There is also the “bake room” used occasionally for large-scale baking.

Above are 7 bedrooms. In the front is a broad porch. The dairy barn has a series of 4 large pens, a milkhouse and a 12 stall parlor for dairy goats.It is 38×80″ and has a large drive-in loft. The horse barn is 38×64′, with a partial loft, 7 box stalls, 1 single and3 double stalls, plus tack room & watering and grooming area. These buildings are outstanding and anyone should be proud to own them. In addition is a 12×20′ shed used to house buggies, which could be used for small machinery, 2 ice houses, a 12×20′ chicken coop and a 2 story shop, ~30×44′. The price was just drastically lowered to $392500 and taxes are around $4750.

Adjoining it is a 14 acre property, with home and barn that will be offered for sale at a reasonable figure, giving you the chance for a family compound or housing for your help.

A word on Old Order Amish homesteads. Their religion does not permit Sunday showings. Please take this into account. Also, there is no electricity, even though it runs right by. No bathrooms, septic, central heat or modern kitchens. The home is being comfortably lived in but the siding has not been installed over the Tyvek wrap. Also much of the trim is unfinished. Nevertheless, it presents a very welcoming appearance, both inside and out..

Let’s do this backwards and start outside with a look at the buggies parked outside – you can see the open fronts and lanterns. There are some strips of reflective tape around the edges of the buggy frame. Can’t see the back to see what kind of material it might have on it.

Inside the barn.

And a collection of goats. I don’t believe I’ve seen goats in stalls like this before. They’re usually  a bit more out and about. Looks like that’s where they’d prefer to be, at least at the moment.

Now a view of the home. The exterior is unfinished as you can see.

Now looking inside. The stove, rockers, and plain furnishings feel very Swartzentruber. But on the other hand, the floor appears varnished to me (caveat: I’m no expert in wood floor coatings). It has a much glossier and fresh look to it than floors in most other Swartzentruber homes I’ve seen.

While the overall look fits, a couple of the chairs here also don’t feel too “Swartzentruber”.

For comparison here are a couple of floors in Swartzentruber homes. This group coats their floors in linseed oil. Look how dull it appears in comparison:


Another thing that caught my eye is this exercise equipment. I’ve certainly seen it often enough in Amish homes before, but can’t recall ever seeing it in Swartzentruber homes.

One other thing, a pretty comfy looking chair. This home also has some pretty nice-looking clocks.

So those are the main things that stood out to me. This might be another very plain group. I thought about Troyer Amish. They are known to have unvarnished hardwood flooring, however.

Back to the home, an abundance of colorful quilts in these bedrooms.

Except for this one. Walls also not finished in these rooms.

A good store of canned goods will keep this family well-fed through the winter months.

Even though this home is not quite finished, it still feels very cozy. And, it sits on a lot of land. I don’t think the canned goods come with the property, but if they did that would be quite a sweetener. I find myself craving canned peaches on looking at the above photo.

So, what’s the price on this seven-bedroom, zero-bathroom home on a 98-acre property?

At the time of posting, this seven-bedroom home on around 98 acres is listed at $392,500. The listing agent is Roland Vinyard of Vinyards Choice.

Get the Amish in your inbox

Join 15,000 email subscribers. No spam. 100% free

    Similar Posts

    Leave a Reply to Jean Alicea Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


    1. Lisa M

      Close by

      I live close by to this community and visit it often for eggs etc. They are not Schwartzentruber Amish but a conservative Old Order group that is in fellowship with the Cobleskill community where I live. The Cobleskill community refers to this group as the “Glen Community”. From what I’ve heard is that the Glen community has 4 church districts and I’ve also heard recently that a few families from the Glen community are moving to Kentucky.

      1. Sara B


        I live in Glen, I really hope the Amish don’t leave . With Governor Hochul pushing 3000 acres of Mega Solar in the town of Glen alone I can see why they would leave. All the farm land covered in solar panels .. that’s Governor Hochuls plan .

        1. Lisa M


          I’m not sure who else the Glen community is in fellowship with. It’s interesting comparing and contrasting the differences between the Glen and Cobleskill communities.

          There is a large solar “farm” proposed right near the Cobleskill community and they are not happy.

          It also is interesting/frustrating to see how the Amish nearby were not necessarily welcomed by the town. They were given such a hard time as they tried to settle. It felt like they were being given a different set of rules to comply with compared to us “English”.

          This weekend I visited Maine and drove through the Whitefield Community. I read about them Erik’s site here. They were so embraced by the state of Maine and the local community that it makes me embarrassed to live in NY!

          1. Sara B


            That’s really sad, I didn’t know this.. but I agree. I am embarrassed also. These people are such good people and neighbors.. some people here complain of horse manure on the roads but yet the garbage and trash that the English throw out of their cars is disgusting and no one says anything.

          2. This rang a bell; there was another story out of NY a couple years back about a wind farm that both Amish and non-Amish residents were fighting. That was in Cattaraugus County.

            Lisa it is interesting to see how in some places Amish get the proverbial red carpet rolled out for them, and others not so much. I don’t know exactly what this depends upon. I might say it could have something to do with how conservative the group is. That said the Whitefield group is a Swartzentruber community. Anyway neat to hear you were able to visit there!

      2. Thanks for this info Lisa, as noted some quite plain elements but some “tells” that this is not Swartzentruber though they seem quite plain by these photos. I wonder which other groups they fellowship with

    2. Jeremiah


      Glen/Fultonville started out of Ashland, Ohio. They kept the Ordnung the same except that they allowed belt-driven push mowers (if what I heard is correct). G/F fellowships with Smicksburg (PA) and a handful of other communities. Their circle had been much larger — the entirety of the Andy Weaver fellowship — but they split over the question of whether a home community is permitted to disfellowship a new daughter settlement that allows things that the mother settlement is unhappy about. A related question is the issue of whether a member may move outside the Andy Weaver churches without being put in the Ban. That question arises, at least in part, because some large Old Order Amish communities now have computers, internet, and smartphones and many are not comfortable releasing ex-members to those church settings.

      1. Thanks for the additional details on this one Jeremiah. I assume you mean the Ashland Co. community of the unusual SMV triangle markings:

    3. Amish Computer

      Hi Eric,
      When I went to your contact info, you recommended posting questions in a comment field, so here I am. 🙂
      I am in need of a non-internet-capable word processor, and I did find the classic computer online, but due to health issues, I am looking for a laptop if that’s at all possible.
      I searched through the business listings on your really helpful and thorough website, but of course, computers aren’t a big Amish category, and I couldn’t find anything.
      Anyway, I don’t know that I could find my way back to this exact spot for your answer, so in addition to answering here, if you do know of someone who makes a non-internet word processor, would you mind emailing me that info?
      Thank you so much for your time and trouble on my behalf.

      1. Jean Alicea

        Amish Computer

        Like Pam Bickell, that would be a wonderful thing to get my hands on.
        I am not the world’s greatest computer person, and so when the Internet is interconnected, it makes things more confusing.
        To get a laptop or any computer without an Internet connection is hard to locate. I did about 10:15 years ago, but since then,I have not been able to locate one.
        Thank you for all you do.You do your best to bring out information that is accurate about a community of people who are very different than the rest.