A Directory of Amish & PA Dutch Restaurants

Amish RestaurantAmish are well-known for their traditional dishes. The popularity of Amish and related food has led to a host of restaurants providing PA Dutch, Mennonite, and Amish-style cuisine.

Jump to: AL CA FL GA IL IN KS  MD MI MN MO NC NJ NY OH OK PA SC TN VA WI Canada

Amish and PA Dutch food establishments are often located in larger Amish settlements, but can be found in off-the-beaten path places as well as in locations where no Amish live (ie, Amish markets in states like New Jersey).

Some eateries are operated by Amish, while most are non-Amish owned, though may have Amish employees.  Some Amish also operate in-home meals businesses. Find an Amish restaurant near you using the directory below.

Know of a good Amish, Mennonite, or PA Dutch restaurant?  Let us know about it in the comments section below. 

Amish & Pennsylvania Dutch Eateries

Alabama

The Old Cook Stove
89 Reeder Rd
Danville, AL
256 462 1151
oldcookstove.com
Owned and operated by a Mennonite family, Millard and Mary Yoder. They specialize in old-fashioned cooking, with dishes including fried chicken, meat loaf, fried fish, smoked ham, fresh vegetables, home-baked breads, mashed potatoes, fresh made desserts such as carrot pie, banana pudding, homemade ice cream and more.




California

Jantz Cafe & Bakery
987 Bellevue Road
Atwater, CA
209 356 0782

5067 California 140
Mariposa, CA
209 742-4545
jantzcafe.com‎
Family owned and operated business, carries Mennonite style home-cooked and baked goods. Jantz Cafe and Bakery has 2 central California locations.

Florida

Yoder’s Restaurant
3434 Bahia Vista Street
Sarasota, FL
941 955 7771
yodersrestaurant.com‎
Features a big selection of Amish pies and home style meals made from scratch. Providing daily specials, breakfast, lunch and dinner menu. Yoder’s Restaurant has been serving the local Pinecraft community since 1975.

 Der Dutchman (formerly Troyer’s Dutch Heritage Restaurant)
3713 Bahia Vista Street
Sarasota, FL
941 955 8007
Amish style restaurant, features homemade meals and fresh baked goods, located in the Amish/Mennonite Pinecraft neighborhood of Sarasota. 

Dutch Valley Restaurant
6721 Tamiami Trail South
Sarasota, FL
941 924 1770
dutchvalleyrestaurant.net
Quality home cooking with a wide choice of Amish style meals and desserts.

Miller’s Dutch Kitchen‎
3401 14th Street West
Bradenton, FL
941 746 8253
millersdutchkitchen.com‎
Well known locally for their Amish-style breakfast, lunch and dinner buffet. Restaurant and bakery in one place.

Georgia

Yoder’s Deitsch Haus
5252 Georgia Highway 26 East
Montezuma, GA
478 472 2024
Family owned and operated business, serving PA Dutch style food such as beef with gravy, broccoli and cheese casserole, country fried steak with vegetables and mashed potatoes, Shoofly pie and more.

Dutch House Restaurant and Bakery
14455 Us Highway 1 S
Wrens, GA
706 547 3261
lildutchhouse.com‎
Dutch House has been in business since 1990. They specialize in PA Dutch home-style cooking. Some of the meals include roast beef, fried chicken, meat loaf, mashed potatoes with gravy, sweet potatoes, sweet potato casserole, homemade rolls, bread and more.

Oil Lamp Restaurant
401 General Courtney Hodges Boulevard
Perry, GA
478 988-2643
theoillamp.com‎
Restaurant owned and operated by a former Mennonite. Carries Southern style cuisine mixed with Mennonite culinary traditions.

Illinois

Yoder’s Kitchen
1195 East Columbia Street
Arthur, IL
217 543-2714
yoderskitchen.net‎
Amish style restaurant, bakery and gift shop in the heart of Arthur’s Amish Country. Family owned and operated. Restaurant owner was raised Amish. They serve traditional home style food and fresh baked goods.

Dutch Kitchen
127 East Main Street
Arcola, IL
217 268 3518
Dutch Kitchen serves traditional Amish meals.

The Kitchen of Doris Yoder
2060 CR 1700 East
Arthur, IL
217 543 3409
Amish home style cooking.

Indiana

View the full Indiana Amish Restaurant directory.

Kansas

Dutch Kitchen Restaurant
6803 Kansas 61
Hutchinson, KS
620 662 2554
dutchkitchenrestaurant.com‎
Dutch Kitchen Restaurant carries a broad choice of menu items from breakfast to dinner specials. In Dutch Kitchen you will find common PA Dutch dishes such as soups, gravy, breads, pies, pastries and more.  Serving food to the local community for over 40 years.

The Breadbasket
219 North Main Street
Newton, KS
316 283 3811
newtonbreadbasket.com‎
Mennonite/German style buffet. Dishes include Verenika with ham gravy, fried potatoes, baked ham, Yoder German sausage, hot German potato salad and sauerkraut, chicken Borscht and more.

Maryland

View the full Maryland Amish Restaurant directory.

Michigan

Middleton Diner
125 North Newton Street
Middleton, MI
989 236 7794
Mennonite owned and operated restaurant, serving a home style dinner buffet. Some of the traditional dishes include gravy, mashed potatoes, fried chicken and roast beef with a range of sides and salads to choose from.

Minnesota

Amish Market Square
2850 Whitewater Avenue
St. Charles, MN
507 932 5907
amishmarketsquare.com
Amish style meals served daily such as Amish ovens breakfasts, old-fashioned pancakes, Amish omelets with ham and cheese, traditional Amish style chicken soup, biscuit pie, and a broad choice of desserts including pecan and fruit pies.

Missouri

Lehman’s Restaurant
15830 Missouri 5
Versailles, MO
573 378 4010
Traditional Mennonite homestyle cooking.

Gingerich Dutch Pantry
Broadway Street
Jamesport, MO
660 684 6212
gingerichdutchpantry.com‎
Amish old-fashioned style dining. An extensive menu including Amish dinner (mashed potatoes, homemade brown gravy, Amish dressing, schnitzel beans, dutch pepper slaw, dinner rolls), Amish style soups, salads, sandwiches and desserts such as homemade ice-cream, cinnamon rolls, pies.

New Jersey

Dienner’s Country Restaurant
Amish Farmers Market in Mullica Hill
108 Swedesboro Road
Mullica Hill, NJ
856 478 4300
amishmarketmullicahill.com
Features Amish style home made dishes such as soups, award-winning chili, chicken croquettes, desserts and much more.

K & R Lunch Counter
Pennsylvania Dutch Farmers Market
4437 Route 27
Princeton, NJ
609 683 1338
padutchfarmersmarket.com
Amish operated business, serving breakfast and daily lunch specials such as pulled pork, homemade sausage, Philly cheese steaks and more.

Dutch Family Restaurant
The Greater Bridgeton Amish Market
760 Shiloh Pike
Bridgeton, NJ
856 451 3008
bridgetonamishmarket.com
Traditional Amish style dining, family owned and operated. Restaurant carries breakfast, lunch and dinner menu using PA Dutch old-fashioned recipes.

Fisher’s Salads & Desserts
Landis Market Place
631 East Landis Ave
Vineland, NJ
856 213 5761
landismarketplace.com
Amish style salads, soups, sides, entrees and desserts. All made from scratch.

Riehl’s Deli & Subs
Columbus Farmers Market
2919 Route 206
Columbus, NJ
717 598 2344
columbusfarmersmarket.com
Amish made soups, salads and pies.

Lancaster County Restaurant
Dutch Country Farmers Market
19 Commerce Street
Flemington, NJ
908 806 7182
dutchfarmersmarket.com
Lancaster Country home style menu including roast beef, meatloaf, chicken pot pie, pork and sauerkraut and much more.

Amish Market Of North Wildwood
700 New Jersey Ave
North Wildwood, NJ
amishmarketofnw.com
Broad selection of Amish style foods including the family chicken and ribs meal with a variety side dishes to choose from. Sandwiches and salad menu available as well.

New York

Amish Market (Tribeca)
53 Park Place,
(btwn W. Broadway & Church St
New York, NY
212-608-3863
orderamishmarkettribeca.com

Amish Market (East)
240 East 45th St.
(btwn 2nd Ave & 3rd Ave
New York, NY
212-370-1761
amishmarketeast.com

Amish Market (West)
731 9th Ave.
(btwn 49th St & 50th St)
New York, NY
212-245-2360
amishmarketwest.com
Amish style catering and restaurant. Market has 3 different locations.

North Carolina

The Korner Kitchen
3501 Buck Shoals Road
Union Grove, NC
704 539 5393
atthekorner.com‎
Restaurant located in the heart of the Amish Community in Union Grove, NC. They providing southern style home cooking along with Amish and American flavors.

Dutch Cupboard
6500 Brevard Road
Etowah, NC 28729
828 891 9050
thedutchcupboard.com
Home style cooking using Amish and Mennonite recipes. Features a breakfast, lunch and dinner menu and daily specials.

Ohio

View the full Ohio Amish Restaurant directory.

Oklahoma

Fanny’s Country Cookin
15842 S 428
Chouteau, OK
918 476 7891
Fanny’s Country Cookin is an Amish owned and operated business, located in the heart of the Chouteau Amish community, Oklahoma’s largest.  They provide a family-style breakfast, lunch and dinner menu full of traditional old-fashioned meals including gravy, mashed potatoes, veggies, chicken noodle soup and fresh baked desserts.

Dutch Pantry
10 West Main St
P.O. Box 1176
Chouteau, OK
918 476 6441
dutchpantryok.com
Dutch Pantry features old fashioned home-cooked meals using Mennonite recipes. Their specials include country fried chicken, pan-fried catfish, homemade rolls, creamy mashed potatoes, a variety of salads, meats and desserts.

Amish Country Store and Restaurant
2410 N.32nd, HWY 69 North
Muskogee, OK
918 686 0243
Traditional Amish-style meals and desserts.  Amish food products for sale in the store. 

Pennsylvania

View the full Pennsylvania Amish Restaurant directory.

South Carolina

Amish Oven
803 U.S. 25
Greenwood, SC
864 227 1420
Amish and southern style home cooking.

Dutch Plate
206 South Main Street
Campobello, SC
864 468 4584
dutchplate.com‎
This is a family restaurant located in Campobello, at the foot of the Blue Ridge mountains. Specializes in home made meals using old-fashioned Amish and Mennonite recipes. Authentic PA Dutch cuisine along with Southern style food.

Tennessee

Kuntry Kitchen
2007 North Locust Avenue
Lawrenceburg, TN
931 766 0260
Restaurant located in the heart of a Tennessee Amish community, serving traditional home style meals as well as American cooking.

Virginia

Farmers Wife Market
204 E. Main St
Remington, VA
540 439 4700
thefarmerswifemarket.com
Bulk foods, bakery, deli and catering in one place. Providing Amish style meals such as sandwiches, biscuits with gravy, homemade soups with homemade bread and fresh-made salads in season.

Wisconsin

Mom’s Amish Kitchen
Cascade St
Osceola, WI
Features Amish style dining.

Dorest Valley School Restaurant and Bakery
26147 State Hwy 71
Wilton, WI
608 435 6876
Old-fashioned meals and desserts.

CANADA

Anna Mae’s
4060 Perth Line 72
Millbank, Ontario
N0K 1L0
519 595 4407
annamaes.ca
Family owned and operated restaurant established in 1978 by Mennonite lady Anna Mae Wagler. They serve a large choice of family home-style meals and fresh baked desserts.

Schmidtsville Restaurant
3685 Nafziger Road
Wellesley, ON N0B 2T0
519 656 2430
Home style dining served and prepared by Amish. Traditional style meals and desserts available.

Taunte Maria’s Mennonite Restaurant
1724 Quebec Avenue #8
Saskatoon, SK S7K 1V6
306 343 3334
tauntemarias.com‎
This restaurant was established in 1985 by a Mennonite lady named Grace Miller. They serve a wide selection of traditional home-cooked dishes such as kommst borsch, summa borsch, cottage cheese Verenki, schinkenflesh, klupz and much more.

Del Rios Family Restaurant
644 Main Street
Winkler, MB R6W 1B7
204 325 5273
delriosfamilyrestaurant.com‎
Family style restaurant specializing in Mexican and Mennonite cuisine. Some of the Mennonite style favorites include homemade chicken noodle soup and cabbage borscht, gravy and sausage, cinnamon buns, and creamy pies.

MJ’s Kafé
408 Main Street
Steinbach, MB R5G 1Z3
204 326 2224
mjskafe.ca‎
Features Mennonite style cuisine along with American flavors.


Question on the Amish? Get answers to 300+ questions in 41 categories at the Amish FAQ.