Amish Restaurants – Indiana

Find Amish & PA Dutch food in Indiana

IN Amish RestaurantA directory of Indiana Amish Restaurants  Home to America’s 3rd-largest Amish population, Indiana hosts a number of Amish-style and Pennsylvania Dutch eateries.

Jump to:  Shipshewana Area Nappanee Southern Indiana (Daviess County)

Restaurants serving Amish food can be found in the northern communities of Nappanee and Elkhart-Lagrange Counties (Shipshewana), as well as in southern Indiana, especially in the sizeable Amish settlement in Daviess County.

Know of a good Indiana Amish restaurant we missed?  Share it in the comments below.

PA Dutch & Amish-style Restaurants – Indiana

Shipshewana & Northern Indiana

Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery
195 North Van Buren Street
Shipshewana, IN
260 768 4725‎
A broad choice of PA Dutch style meals along with American cuisine.

Das Dutchman Essenhaus
240 US 20
Middlebury, IN
574 825 9471‎
Restaurant and bakery serving tourists and the local community. An extensive selection of Amish home-style meals in the largest PA Dutch style restaurant in Indiana.


Miller’s Dutch Kitchen
700 North Tomahawk Trail
Nappanee, IN
574 773 9380‎
Specializes in PA Dutch cooking. Miller’s provides a wide choice of home-style made dishes, an all-you-can-eat buffet and desserts.

Amish Acres Historic
Farm & Heritage Resort

1600 West Market Street
Nappanee, IN
800 800 4942
Amish Acres restaurant is housed in a century-old barn and specializes in traditional Amish style cuisine.

Southern Indiana

Stoll’s Lakeview Restaurant
15519 U.S. 231
Loogootee, IN ‎
812 295 3299
Authentic Amish buffet restaurant located in Loogootee, IN. Some of the traditional PA Dutch flavors including fried chicken, roast beef or baked ham, made from scratch salads along with homemade soups served daily, mashed potatoes, gravy, corn, green beans, homemade noodles and dressing, fresh baked goods, desserts and much more.

Gasthof Amish Village
6747 E Gasthof Village Rd
Montgomery, IN
812 486 2600‎
Restaurant located at Gasthof Amish Village. Carries a variety of Amish style dishes for breakfast, lunch and dinner. They offer a broad selection of home-baked goods as well.

Essen Haus‎
100 North West Street
Odon, IN
812 636 2000‎
Family business, features old-fashioned Amish meals. Traditional Amish style breakfast, lunch and dinner and a big choice of desserts.

Schwartz Family Restaurant
6738 West Governors Trce
Eckerty, IN
812 338 9000‎
Family owned and operated business, specializing in Amish style country cooking. Daily specials, breakfast, lunch and dinner menu along with fresh baked desserts.

Stoll’s Country Inn
12188 W State Road 54
Linton, IN 47441
812 847 2477‎
Specializes in Amish and Mennonite home style cuisine. Restaurant features an extensive choice of menu items such as sliced roast beef, meatloaf and smoked sausage and kraut along with homemade noodles, mashed potatoes, vegetables, dressing and homemade white and wheat bread. In business since 1989.

Get the Amish in your inbox

Join 15,000 email subscribers. No spam. 100% free

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


    1. Missing an important one!!

      Knepp’s Country Cafe
      4630 U.S. 50,
      Washington, IN 47501
      (812) 486-3545

      Authentic Amish cooking with homemade breads, pies, and a full buffet and salad bar. One of the best.

    2. Celeste

      Amish restaurants - Indiana

      Das Nolt Family Dinner Haus
      Home-cooked, quality Amish meals, pastries,
      and pies. Buffet.
      12530 Cuba Rd.
      Grabill, IN
      (260) 466-4224
      Hours: Fri. 11am – 8pm
      Sat. 4 – 8pm (in summer months)

    3. Turn-key Restaurant for sale would make perfect Amish style facility!

      I am trying to find a way to connect with potential investors that may be interested in locating an Amish restaurant in the Crawfordsville, IN, area. I am a real estate broker with Davis Morrison Realty and I have a completely renovated 9,939 sq ft facility with 4 dining area, 2 open air patios with fireplace, chef’s kitchen, office, restrooms and more all on nearly 16A (partially tillable and wooded). Personal property available to make this restaurant completely turnkey for quick operations. I am interested in finding a publication to list this property in if anyone has any suggestions or know of any interested owner/investors. Please feel free to contact me at 765-225-4123 for further details. Property asking price: $899,900
      Lisa Taylor-Franke
      Davis Morrison Realty