The Amish: Contest Winners and Author Q-and-A Part 2

amish-kraybill-johnson-weiner-noltToday we have 3 winners of The Amish, the new book by Donald Kraybill, Karen Johnson-Weiner, and Steven Nolt. You’ll find the contest winners at the bottom of this post.

We also have the second part of the author Q-and-A (if you missed it, read Part 1 here). Part 2 below covers general questions on the Amish and is a sample of topics covered and expanded upon within the book.

The Amish Author Q-and-A (Part 2 – General Questions on the Amish)

What do Amish people do for a living?

In the past almost all Amish were farmers, but many Amish communities have experienced a dramatic occupational transformation in the past thirty years. Amish families still live in rural areas, but on average only about 30% of the households depend on farming for their primary income. Most are involved in various forms of small business, from manufacturing to construction, many of which they own and operate.

There are some 12,000 Amish businesses across North America. For the most part they are successful and profitable, despite limitations on technology. They benefit from the hard work of family labor, low overhead, a distinctive brand identity, and niche markets.

Speaking of technology, some think of the Amish as luddites or technophobes. Is this accurate?

Categorically no. Although all Amish groups regulate certain types of technology (no television, no internet access in schools or home, no ownership of motor vehicles) they selectively use technology including some that is state-of-the-art. They are careful to avoid technology that threatens the welfare of their community or that promotes individual autonomy at the expense of the group. The regulations on technology vary widely among the various Amish groups. Many Amish business owners adapt mainstream technology to make it fit within the rules of their church, for example, finding other power sources if their church forbids tapping into public utility electricity.

What is the Amish school system like and why don’t their children attend public schools?

Until the mid-20th century Amish children attended rural public schools. Parents feared that exposure to modern science, educational technology, and secular values in the public school would entice their youth to leave the Amish community. Although in a few communities Amish children still attend public school, most parents have developed their own one- or two-room private schools. Today more than 2,000 such schools, taught by Amish teachers educate Amish children through the eighth grade. Amish schools focus on reading and writing (in English) and basic arithmetic. Amish children do not attend high school or college.

Do the Amish accept modern medicine?

The Amish acceptance of modern medicine varies widely. Some of them have a family physician, seek standard medical treatment for illness, and participate as subjects in scientific studies of various diseases. Others primarily rely on traditional and homeopathic remedies and only seek medical care for serious emergencies.

Are Amish women treated like second-class citizens within their own community?

No. The Amish have a soft patriarchy in the sense that men typically represent the household to the outside world. However, in the family context women have considerable authority and freedom regarding family and household matters, and their work and their opinions matter. Although women may not serve as clergy, they are schoolteachers and owners of small businesses. They are able to vote on church matters.

Are the Amish pacifists? Do they hunt?

Yes, the Amish are conscientious objectors to war and reject the use of force (including initiating lawsuits) based on their interpretation of the teachings of Jesus. Many of them own guns and archery equipment to hunt for wildlife. They consider killing humans a sin but will kill animals for food.

As U.S. citizens, do the Amish vote and pay taxes?

Amish people pay all taxes (income, real estate, sales) except Social Security, which they consider a form of health insurance. They believe that members of the church have a duty to care for the physical and material needs of other members and thus they reject commercial and public insurance. Amish people are permitted to vote, however, the rate of voting varies from group to group and is generally low. They are forbidden by their church from holding public office.

Do the Amish use non-Amish institutions like banks, restaurants and grocery stores?

Yes. They have accounts in commercial banks, and purchase goods in local grocery stores as well as big box stores such as Walmart. Some of them eat occasionally at local restaurants, but most of them do not “eat out” on a regular basis. Amish entrepreneurs also operate many small retail stores that cater to their own people.

What exactly is Rumspringa?

Rumspringa is the time when Amish youth can “run around” and socialize with their peers away from the watchful eyes of parents. This typically occurs between the age of sixteen and when they marry, which is usually around 20-22 years of age. Rumspringa is a time to find a spouse and to decide if they want to join the Amish church and make a lifetime commitment to it. During this time youth live at home, but on weekends hang out with their friends. Most of them are not yet baptized church members, so they are not yet accountable to the rules of the church. In some communities rowdy groups engage in “worldly activities” which may include driving cars, using alcohol, and participating in the nightlife of public entertainment. In other communities these activities rarely happen during Rumspringa.

Contest Winners

Time for the winners.  I talled all the extra social media submissions you submitted and just drew three entries using  The winners of The Amish:

Rose (comment #27)

Chris (comment #97)

Sarah L. (Facebook share entry)

Congratulations Rose, Chris and Sarah.  Send your mailing address to me and I will forward it to Johns Hopkins so you can receive your copy of The Amish.

If you didn’t win, the book is available for purchase in hard copy or as a Kindle download at, or in many other venues.

Get the Amish in your inbox

Join 15,000 email subscribers. No spam. 100% free

    Similar Posts

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


    1. Thank you!

      I’m so excited to read this book! Thank you so much!

    2. Tom


      Congratulations to the winners. This is a very good book written by 3 great writers. I pre-ordered it from Amazon and could not wait until it arrived. The winners will really enjoy this book and if you did not win it is worth purchasing.
      Be sure to look at the photo credits as Eric has at least 1 picture in the book that I have found so far.

    3. Debbie H

      Congrats to the winners. Thanks Eric for the Q&A

    4. Alice Aber


      Congratulations to the winners!!! Thanks to the question and answers and was quite informing.

      Blessings, Alice

    5. Terry Berger

      Regarding the Soft Patriarchy

      Just to underscore the importance of women in plain society there is a saying that I grew up with and again I’m not sure if this carries to other communities as well. I often heard, “The man may wear the pants but it is his wife who makes them.” In my own home it wasn’t anything for my mom to be up on the roof helping shingle or to see dad in the kitchen helping mom during canning season. Work was much more of a shared responsibility. At least in the Brethren tradition I grew up in gender related work was much less ‘traditional’.


    6. Loretta


      Congrats to the lucky winners, I believe you all will enjoy this book. I don’t have it yet, hoping that I will soon. So glad that you all won 🙂

    7. Slightly-handled-Order-man

      the little things and ordnugs

      Hi, congrats to those who won the book.

      I have a practical question about the Amish, a mundaine thing;
      Do certain community ordnugs forbid things like sunscreens or
      is that a given that people ought to use it to protect their skin?

      I ask because I’ve been wearing my Amish style straw hat the last
      couple of days along with clothing that covers me from foot to neck
      (long sleeves ect) for a historical event I help out at, and still
      I get burned/tanned, and I thought to myself “I wonder what they, the Amish, do”


      1. Shom I haven’t thought about this before, but I don’t think sunscreen would be objectionable for most if not all Amish. However whether Amish use sunscreen is a different question. If I had to guess, probably not much if at all in the traditional groups especially (hats and long clothing pretty much eliminate the need).

        Might be a different story with Amish in Pinecraft though.

      2. A few weeks ago I spent the day shopping with my Amish friend in Green Lake County, WI. She needed to purchase Aloe Vera because she was burnt from playing volleyball the day before. She mentioned she forgot to apply the sunscreen so I assumed they do use it in that area. I noticed she also bought perfumed body spray. I was quite surprised with the perfumed body spray.

        1. She sounds like a younger lady.