The Amish & Crime

Stories about the Amish as victims – or perpetrators – of crime.

Amishman Arrested For Driving Buggy While Intoxicated

An Amishman was arrested for DUI in Kentucky after sideswiping a car with his buggy last week. The 34-year-old man was traveling with his wife and seven children, ages 9 months to 12 years old. He faces 10 felony counts as a result. The man first attempted to claim that one of his children was driving, but the children confirmed it was their father holding…

Amish & Mennonites Victims of 4 Major Financial Schemes Since 2008

The year 2015 brought news of an investment scam targeting Amish in multiple states. Amish-born Earl D. Miller promised investors double-digit returns, and many Amish people gave Miller their money. Miller eventually gathered over $50 million. Some of this was used to pay back earlier investors promised returns, in typical Ponzi fashion, before the scheme imploded. Amish being victimized by large-scale financial scammers is nothing new,…

Michigan Amishman Gets 15-25 Years For Sexual Assault

Michigan Amishman Gets 15-25 Years For Sexual Assault

From mlive.com: GLADWIN, MI — An Amish man will spend more than a decade in prison for sexually assaulting three girls over a several years. Gladwin County Circuit Judge Thomas R. Evans on Monday, Oct. 15, sentenced 53-year-old Ora F. Troyer to one term of 15 to 25 years in prison and two terms of 10 to 15 years. The three terms are to run…

Sam Mullet’s 11-Year Sentence Reaffirmed

Sam Mullet’s 11-Year Sentence Reaffirmed

Sam Mullet, leader of the Bergholz, Ohio group infamous for hair and beard-cutting attacks on Amish, made news again recently when he asked for early release due to alleged mistakes made by his attorney. Mullet lost his attempt for release Wednesday: An attorney for 72-year-old Samuel Mullet Sr. argues that Mullet’s previous lawyer made mistakes. U.S. District Judge Dan Polster disagreed Wednesday, concluding that those…

Amish Salve-Maker Denied Appeal, Will Remain In Prison

Amish Salve-Maker Denied Appeal, Will Remain In Prison

Samuel Girod was sentenced last summer to 6 years in prison for various charges relating to the manufacture and sale of herbal products, including a salve which the Kentucky Amish farmer claimed could be used to treat cancer, among other ailments. Girod was convicted for charges including “conspiring to impede the FDA; failing to register his facility with the agency; threatening a witness to try to…

Sam Mullet Asks For Release Due to Attorney Mistakes

Sam Mullet was sentenced in 2013 to 15 years in prison for orchestrating beard and hair-cutting attacks on Amish. Mullet later saw his sentence reduced to a little under 11 years. If you missed the story at the time, Mullet was the bishop of a breakaway Amish group which began following decidedly un-Amish practices, detailed in the book Renegade Amish. These included attacks by Mullet’s followers on…

Samuel Girod Sentenced To 6 Years In Prison

Amish salve-maker Samuel Girod received his sentence Friday: LEXINGTON, Ky. (WKYT) – A federal judge sentenced a Bath County Amish farmer to six years in prison on Friday morning. A federal jury handed down guilty verdicts against Samuel Girod in March for misbranding products. After serving six years, Girod will have three years of supervised release. He must also refrain from producing and manufacturing products…

Amish Bishop Charged For Failing To Report Abuse

An Amish bishop in Dauphin County, Pennsylvania is in the news for failing to report sexual abuse of two children in his church by another church member. From Lancaster Online: An Amish bishop in Dauphin County is facing charges after being accused of failing to report two cases of alleged sexual abuse of children. Christ M. Stoltzfus, 69, is charged with two misdemeanor counts of…

Kentucky Amish Farmer Goes On Trial Over Homemade Health Products

Kentucky Amish Farmer Goes On Trial Over Homemade Health Products

Samuel Girod’s federal trial began this week. The Kentucky Amish farmer made and sold several homemade products, some of which suggested bold curative properties, in a business running for over 20 years. These include a “black salve” called “To-Mor-Gone” (with a sales pamphlet claiming it to be “very good at removing tumors”), and a “Chickweed Salve” which had the words “Cures Cancer” on the container. This WKYT article summarizes…

Couple Who “Gifted” Daughter Were Not Representative Of The Amish

Couple Who “Gifted” Daughter Were Not Representative Of The Amish

There’s a good chance you’ve heard the story of a former Amish family who “gifted” one of their underage daughters to a man who provided them financial aid (if not, the details can be found here among many other places). Over the past several days this bizarre story has gone worldwide (I’ve seen it in Russian, Chinese, and Australian media). Part of the reason is the…