The Amish & Crime

Stories about the Amish as victims – or perpetrators – of crime.

Sam Mullet Asks For Release Due to Attorney Mistakes

Sam Mullet was sentenced in 2013 to 15 years in prison for orchestrating beard and hair-cutting attacks on Amish. Mullet later saw his sentence reduced to a little under 11 years. If you missed the story at the time, Mullet was the bishop of a breakaway Amish group which began following decidedly un-Amish practices, detailed in the book Renegade Amish. These included attacks by Mullet’s followers on…

Samuel Girod Sentenced To 6 Years In Prison

Amish salve-maker Samuel Girod received his sentence Friday: LEXINGTON, Ky. (WKYT) – A federal judge sentenced a Bath County Amish farmer to six years in prison on Friday morning. A federal jury handed down guilty verdicts against Samuel Girod in March for misbranding products. After serving six years, Girod will have three years of supervised release. He must also refrain from producing and manufacturing products…

Amish Bishop Charged For Failing To Report Abuse

An Amish bishop in Dauphin County, Pennsylvania is in the news for failing to report sexual abuse of two children in his church by another church member. From Lancaster Online: An Amish bishop in Dauphin County is facing charges after being accused of failing to report two cases of alleged sexual abuse of children. Christ M. Stoltzfus, 69, is charged with two misdemeanor counts of…

Kentucky Amish Farmer Goes On Trial Over Homemade Health Products

Kentucky Amish Farmer Goes On Trial Over Homemade Health Products

Samuel Girod’s federal trial began this week. The Kentucky Amish farmer made and sold several homemade products, some of which suggested bold curative properties, in a business running for over 20 years. These include a “black salve” called “To-Mor-Gone” (with a sales pamphlet claiming it to be “very good at removing tumors”), and a “Chickweed Salve” which had the words “Cures Cancer” on the container. This WKYT article summarizes…

Couple Who “Gifted” Daughter Were Not Representative Of The Amish

Couple Who “Gifted” Daughter Were Not Representative Of The Amish

There’s a good chance you’ve heard the story of a former Amish family who “gifted” one of their underage daughters to a man who provided them financial aid (if not, the details can be found here among many other places). Over the past several days this bizarre story has gone worldwide (I’ve seen it in Russian, Chinese, and Australian media). Part of the reason is the…

Indiana Amish Family Horse Killed In Drive-By Shooting

Indiana Amish Family Horse Killed In Drive-By Shooting

An Amish family in Lagrange County, Indiana is hoping for answers after their horse was killed in a drive-by shooting incident last week.  From WSBT.com: It was a regular morning for the Miller family as they were heading outside to do their chores– that is until one of the children noticed something unusual. “I was putting on my socks and all of a sudden I…

Amish Among Investors Who Lost $3.9M In Alleged Scam

News came last week of another financial scandal involving Amish investors as victims. According to the federal lawsuit, Earl D. Miller began recruiting investors in 2008 to join a number of investment vehicles, despite having no experience in fund management. The Goshen, Indiana resident is accused of “misrepresentations that Miller raised at least $3.9 million from at least 70 investors, but repeatedly lied to prospective investors.” According…

Gunshots Fired At Amish Homes In Wisconsin (UPDATED)

Gunshots Fired At Amish Homes In Wisconsin (UPDATED)

Over the past week, gunshots were fired at two Amish homes in the community in Eau Claire County, Wisconsin. There was also a third reported incident involving a school in the settlement. There’s not a lot of information in this article, but there are a few more details, including on a fragment of bullet found in between panes of glass in one home. Eau Claire…

Sam Mullet Sentence Reduced to 10 Years, 9 Months

Sam Mullet Sentence Reduced to 10 Years, 9 Months

Sam Mullet along with the seven remaining imprisoned members of the Bergholz community have just received shorter sentences for their roles in the 2011 beard-cutting attacks. From the report (no longer online): Mullet’s 15-year sentence was reduced to 10 years, nine months. Sentences for four men who received seven years were cut to five years. Sentences for three men who got five years were lowered to three…

Holmes County Area Drug Parties Challenge Authorities

A recent article in the Massillon Independent depicts the efforts of law enforcement in Holmes and neighboring Tuscarawas County to thwart large parties held regularly in the area. According to authorities, these parties, such as those held at a resort in Tuscarawas County, have a significant Amish youth presence. Drugs such as meth and cocaine are sold and used at them. From the article: Such parties are…