22 responses to What do Amish think about photography?
  • *
    Lin
    Comment on Doyle Yoder Photography (July 18th, 2012 at 08:10)

    Doyle Yoder Photography

    Doyle Yoder Photography, Inc. has wonderful photos of Amish Country. His photo catalog can be viewed at www.dypinc.com. Doyle has photos of Winter, Spring, Summer, and Autumn in Ohio, plus 219 photos from other states, plus Birds and Blooms, Miscellaneous, and Railroads. It’s a real treat for sore eyes.

    Erik, I used the “Amish America sitemap to View all posts” in the left sidebar, between “Most Commented Posts” and “Categories,” to find this post.

  • *
    Rose (AmishInWisconsin.com)
    Comment on What do Amish think about photography? (June 2nd, 2013 at 12:09)

    Thank you for this post Eric. As always, I now have a clearer understanding on this subject thanks to your knowledge. I attended an Amish auction yesterday and they did not seem to mind the photographs we took.

  • *
    Linda
    Comment on Donald Reese Photography (September 23rd, 2014 at 13:43)

    Donald Reese Photography

    Donald Reese Photography has quite a few photos in the Amish category, mostly from Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. You can remember his name better if you think of Reese’s candy!

    http://reesephoto.me/category/photography/amish/

  • *
    Mark – Holmes Co.
    Comment on What do Amish think about photography? (September 23rd, 2014 at 15:00)

    I was once stopped at a stop sign in town with my daughter with me on the buggy. A lady motioned with her camera and I figured she was asking if it would be okay to take our picture. I smiled as I shook my head no. Another woman with her told her friend “I never ask, I just take it,” and she did. The first lady is what we think of as a visitor — the second is what we think of as a tourist. :)

  • *
    Naomi Wilson
    Comment on What do Amish think about photography? (September 24th, 2014 at 09:59)

    Mark, my dad spent his working career as a gunsmith at Colonial Williamsburg, and I got to work there too, as I was growing up. It was often hard to remember to be polite to “tourists,” even when that was exactly what we were paid to do! And the horror stories were numerous, although I can’t remember any of them now.

  • *
    Mark – Holmes Co.
    Comment on What do Amish think about photography? (September 25th, 2014 at 07:57)

    I can imagine you have stories! Where I work we keep a notebook to write interesting tourist stories, questions, or comments in. Once it’s full, I think we should publish it. There are some winners in there! :)

    • *
      Comment on What do Amish think about photography? (March 8th, 2015 at 17:34)

      Naomi – wow, what a fascinating and unique upbringing :)
      Mark – I agree your book of stories would be wonderful. I’d read it.

      Our first “adopted” ex-Amish son Moses told me he got used to being stared at when Amish. He just took it in stride. (but, it’d probably bug me to be stared at).

  • *
    Naomi Wilson
    Comment on What do Amish think about photography? (September 25th, 2014 at 08:43)

    That sounds quite fun and interesting, and like a great gift for my dad and others!

  • *
    Jennifer
    Comment on Not the reason I thought (January 13th, 2015 at 17:56)

    Not the reason I thought

    This is interesting. I was always told that the Amish did not approve of having their photos taken or of their dolls having faces because of the verse in the bible Exodus 20:4 – Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image, or any likeness of any thing that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth.

    • *
      Comment on What do Amish think about photography? (January 14th, 2015 at 14:22)

      Yes it is a bit more complicated than that :) Amish have varying opinions on photography and discouraging self-pride is probably as much or more a relevant reason to avoid posing for photos as the Exodus verse. Some Amish don’t have many qualms about photos, I have posed with an Amish friend for photos before (with the understanding it’s not for publication). You can also find other photos of Amish fully aware of the camera and even saying “cheese”, so to speak, online. Most Amish don’t do that however.

  • *
    Comment on How did I miss this post? (March 8th, 2015 at 17:25)

    How did I miss this post?

    Wow, all these months on AmishAmerica, and I’m just now finding this. This dovetails with my experience. I may start pointing people to this page instead of hammering out a response every time that the subject comes up.

    I notice that this post originally debuted three years ago. I’m curious to know if you’ve seen any change in that amount of time.

    • *
      Comment on Examples of Amish on camera (March 9th, 2015 at 11:48)

      Examples of Amish on camera

      I’ve probably noticed more examples of Amish popping up on camera in the media.

      I don’t think that means things have necessarily changed from what’s written above, just either that I’ve simply noticed more, or in some cases those are Amish who are simply more comfortable in front of the lens, like the New Order Amish business owner who posed for the article on his store:

      http://amishamerica.com/amish-country-store-chatham-virginia/

      Or this one:

      http://www.lancastereaglegazette.com/article/20120707/LIFESTYLE/207070310/Amish-run-grocery-store-cutting-edge?odyssey=mod%7Cnewswell%7Ctext%7CFrontpage%7Cp

      Perhaps Amish are viewing photos for business purposes as less objectionable in general. We did a video on Amish businesses in conjunction with my business book release in 2010, and a number of Amish appeared and spoke on camera for that.

      However there are also examples of plainer groups allowing the camera, sometimes posing sometimes not, or not business-related, as in these two examples:

      http://fotovisura.com/user/MDvorak/view/amish

      http://host.madison.com/gallery/news/local/photos-amish-ice-harvest/collection_37ecdd50-d198-5806-b7c0-32cedf8ace41.html?comment_form=true#0

      It’s interesting how many examples you see that go against the conventional wisdom of “Amish object to photography”.

  • *
    Linda
    Comment on Dennis Hughes Amish Photographer, Amish Conference (March 24th, 2015 at 22:31)

    Dennis Hughes Amish Photographer, Amish Conference

    -Dennis Hughes, A local photographer donated 18,000 photos of the #Amish to Elizabethtown College! A 4:19 video interview is at:
    https://www.facebook.com/video.php?v=632381933534266&set=vb.396631953775933&type=2&theater

    -Some of Dennis Hughes’ Amish photos can be seen at
    http://www.lancastercountyamish.com/amish_photos.html

    -Some excerpts from an article, “Hughes donates collection of photographs on Amish life”:

    “One idea Hughes covered within his presentation is something that he has dealt with throughout his experience as a photographer of the Amish and Mennonite communities. After being asked a question about the faith’s permissions toward exposure to photographs or other media, Hughes decided that he did not have a conclusive answer about the correctness of the consenting Amish parties. Through his experience, he has generally found that most Amish people would not allow or prohibit him from taking their pictures, but rather left it up to him. A common response he would receive when asking for approval was “I must say no.” According to the belief system, modesty is very important to Hughes’s subjects, and despite these factors, the Amish would generally not take action to stop him. What he was doing was believed to be a sin, yet Hughes said that sin was “on me.” Thus, there had been few problems for him.

    Hughes’s donation will help Etown greatly in research and education regarding the Amish population, as well as expand on the established Ernest Hess collection. With the international 2016 Amish Conference coming up in June, an even larger audience will get a chance to share the sentimentality that Hughes had last week.

    As he clicked through the different pictures, Hughes seemed to have a story to tell about each image. His sense of humor could be seen upon stopping on a photograph of an Amish teenage boy who was sitting on a stump and facing away from the camera. While mostly dressed traditionally, it was quickly obvious that he was wearing only a single suspender. “I asked him, ‘why do you have one suspender?’” Hughes recalled. “He said, ‘to hold my pants up.’” Hughes noted he had learned from his time in the field that “it is all a matter of perception.”

    http://www.etownian.com/features/hughes-donates-collection-photographs-amish-life/

  • *
    Tolga
    Comment on Google Street View? (March 26th, 2017 at 15:16)

    Google Street View?

    Hi i was curious what would the Amish thaughts be on the photos taken by the Google Street View car? I’ve been “Touring” around places like Lancaster County and Holmes County with Google Street View and i have found multiple times where photos were taken of the Amish during their every day life. This was untill i came across one set of photo’s however.

    The set i am worried about begins like as the car is approaching an Amish man is mowing his lawn, the next few photos as it gets closer, he appears to be looking directly at the camera, as the car drives past he has stoped mowing and now completely looking at the car, and the last few frames as the car has driven past, he’s completely turned his body around watching the car drive off. My thaughts however were the last few photo’s as he seems to be posing for the camera.

    Now i doubt very much that these pictures will be seen by anybody in his community but if they were, what would happen to this man such as would it be considered he has broken the rules or would he be punished all because of Google’s incompetance. This modern era with camera’s everywhere (Dashcams, Google, Sattelite Imagery) worry’s me alot.

  • *
    Mark — Holmes Co.
    Comment on What do Amish think about photography? (March 27th, 2017 at 06:37)

    Tolga, that is very kind of you to be concerned, especially since so many people just take their photos and don’t seem to care if the person photographed minds it or not. (Sometimes it makes me think of zoo animals.)

    A few thoughts — it’s hard to tell (without me seeing it) what kind of Amish group the man belongs to and some groups allow photographs, some under certain circumstances, some merely discourage it, some forbid it, and there is always varying individual opinions, too. Was he posing or standing there in annoyance, amusement, or curiosity? In any case, it’s difficult to imagine any group punishing him under such a circumstance, even for the strictest groups. Most groups recognize the ridiculousness of trying to escape the camera in today’s world. “Posing” is more apt to be the idea of getting a formal portrait taken, in some cases even passport photos, or deliberately posing a photo opportunity.

    Another though is how many moderate to liberal Amish DO you Google earth at a library or business. If you were to visit our local library in Walnut Creek, there are almost always at least a few Amish there either looking things up or making on-line purchases. Though I haven’t used it myself, I’ve seen what others have found and got a kick out of seeing our home neighborhood through the eyes of Google.

    We live in changing times, even the Amish. Anymore we just assume our taxi driver will have GPS. We are used to looking at the screen when our driver backs up to double-check he’s not backing over anyone (or a pet), and we use Google for bus-schedules and advance ticket purchases or to check to see the hours etc. of a place we want to visit on a trip. Of course not all groups or individuals in our community do this, but it’s safe to say many do.

    • *
      Tolga
      Comment on Mark (March 27th, 2017 at 10:12)

      Mark

      Hi Mark, thanks for the reply. Judging by your name and the fact you told me you local to Walnut Creek im guessing your from Holmes County, well the photo which had me concerned i believe is in Holmes County, or possibly just on the outskirts(im not really sure how the USA works with counties and such). I wont post a link to the actual photo itself due to the man’s privacy but i will say the road is quite long in a North-South direction and the start of the road is slightly south east of a place called Fredericksburg and heads north.

      As for the pose you were asking about, i went back and took a real close look, and had a good think about the pose in the final set of pictures, he has his hands on his hips and it sort of seems like confusion possibly due to the car looking simmilar to this:

      https://www.google.com/streetview/images/understand/device-car.jpg

      Your correct when you say we are living in changing times. I guess none of us are really safe from being spied on with all these cameras around everywhere, every move we make being monitored on cctf, sattelite imagery, google etc. A funny thing is just looked up my work place, even my boss has been caught red handed on a cigarette break, where as if any of us tried to he’d throw the book at us.

      (Busted you Brucie)https://www.google.com.au/maps/@-33.8392341,150.9306078,3a,15y,324.56h,86.2t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sEoJ551nu0CdxceCZKn5dLA!2e0!5s20160501T000000!7i13312!8i6656

      • *
        Mark — Holmes Co.
        Comment on What do Amish think about photography? (March 28th, 2017 at 10:12)

        Hi, Tolga. Yes, I live in Holmes Co., Ohio. I’m pretty sure I know which road you are talking about. We know quite a few people living along that road (if it’s the same one) and I’ll have to figure the mapping system out to see what I can see. It would be funny if the man you were writing about would turn out to be someone we know? :)

        The image of Busted Brucie reminds me of the phrase “Be sure your sins will find you out.” :)

        • *
          Tolga
          Comment on Mark (March 30th, 2017 at 02:44)

          Mark

          Hi Mark, thanks again for the reply. Yes the road in question does appear to be full of Amish houses, with the odd couple of non Amish houses mixed inbetween(im guessing non Amish due to the fact they have cars parked on their driveways). There also appears to be two schools along the same stretch of road aswell, one seems to be hidden behind some bushes, however much further up(even past the man in the photo i mentioned’s home) there appears to be a single room school building on the western side of the road, which to me looks very quaint. Ive enjoyed learning about the Amish and i’ve found your reply’s quite interesting.

  • *
    Mark — Holmes Co.
    Comment on What do Amish think about photography? (March 30th, 2017 at 12:51)

    Hi Tolga,
    That has got to be the same road I’m thinking of. :) A car parked in the driveway could still be Amish — a non-Amish friend or relative visiting or a young boy or girl not yet baptized who has a license & a vehicle. But on the road I am thinking of, there are several Mennonite & Beachy homes as well.

    If it is indeed the same road, the “quaint” school on the west side is a Swartzentruber Amish school.

  • *
    Tolga
    Comment on Mark (March 30th, 2017 at 22:41)

    Mark

    Hi Mark, the quaint school i mentioned is a timber built school white in color, there also appears to be some timber utility shed built closer to the entrance and a set of play swings in the yard. The name is pretty blurry in the picture but it looks like it reads something like “Woodland School” or something simmilar i really cant make it out.

    Oh i also found a video on Youtube, somebody was driving along the road recording the surroundings and mentioned what he believes to be a 150 year old barn on somebody’s property which is quite amazing. I found this out basically the next day after i did my Google tour.

Leave a reply to What do Amish think about photography?

 

Resource List
Reliable information from one of the largest Amish sites on the web.

Join over 10,000 email subscribers to get:
Amish Community Info | Book Giveaways | Amish Writers & non-Amish Experts | More



100% Free | No Spam | Unsubscribe Anytime

«»