8 responses to Five Californias-full of Amish
  • *
    Comment on Five Californias-full of Amish (April 12th, 2008 at 20:14)

    It would be interesting to see 100 years into the future and see what is in store for the amish.

  • *
    Comment on Five Californias-full of Amish (April 13th, 2008 at 21:03)

    Could this nation even support 204 million Amish? I would imagine they would need a lot more land than would be available.

    And where could they emmigrate to? Europe has a declining population, but that vaccuum is most likely going to be filled by the nearby Muslims, Asians and Africans. Much of Africa is underpopulated, but I can’t imagine the Amish would last too long there (google: “white farmer” +Zimbabwe). Russia, perhaps?

  • *
    Comment on Five Californias-full of Amish (April 14th, 2008 at 18:11)

    I have watched the Mennonite families in our community increase exponentially. I think the Mennonites and the Amish are having more children than any other predominantly-white subgroup of the population.

  • *
    Comment on Five Californias-full of Amish (April 14th, 2008 at 18:33)

    This really doesn’t address what the “English” population would be doing; growth wise, during the same time periods, but you would have to assume some growth rate in those populations as well. I wonder what the Amish growth rate looks like contrasted to the general population?

    Also, two things come to mind in regards to Amish expanding into previously not-Amish territory: 1) I once heard that land around the Chesapeake Bay area is now so expensive that practically the only people that can afford to buy it and keep it as farmland are the Amish, a very interesting situation if it is true & 2) a few years ago there was quite a bit of talk about the American population re-locating closer to the coasts; so much so that many of the demographic planners were concerned that some of the Mid-Western states may eventually get to the point that the populations would become so low that infrastructure such as electrical grids, etc could no longer be maintained (on a cost effective basis). They claimed that the smaller towns and cities were drying up, and even some of the larger communities were in danger of shrinking dramatically. It seems to me that this vacuum (assuming it is real and not hype) could be partially filled by the Amish, as much of this area is Americas’ breadbasket. Sounds like a good fit for the “plain people”, no pun intended.

  • *
    Comment on Five Californias-full of Amish (April 18th, 2008 at 05:39)


    Well, don’t forget the haredim. 🙂

  • *
    Comment on Old Order Mennonites growing faster than Amish? (April 20th, 2008 at 07:26)

    Old Order Mennonites growing faster than Amish?

    Don’t quote me, but I believe I read one study that had the Old Order Mennonites as being slightly ahead of the Amish in terms of population growth. I don’t think it was by much. Though they allow electricity in the home, in some measures they are more conservative than your average Amish person. For example, the OOMs in Northern Indiana (Wakarusa/Napannee area) tend not to work in the RV factories which are so popular among Amish men.

    Oldkat interesting points you’ve made, there may be some truth to your first one, it sounds like I’ve heard similar comments made, true or not, about Lancaster County.

  • *
    Comment on Five Californias-full of Amish (March 27th, 2012 at 04:50)

    Interesting indeed to think of a future America filled with Amish and Old Order Mennonites!

    However, I think that this growth may be somewhat self-limiting. Amish sects tend to have splits and schisms and over time, and invariably some “Amish” groups trend towards more mainstream Christianity and away from Plain traditions.

    The neat thing about Amish growth is that it is spontaneous; there is no central Amish authority directing anyone to settle in a certain place or grow to a certain number of members. In 100 years, I predict the Amish will still be a small minority, but their ideas and ways will have an outsized impact on our society – for the better.

    • *
      Comment on Self-limiting Amish growth (March 27th, 2012 at 08:30)

      Self-limiting Amish growth

      That’s probably true Ed. If all those originally Amish had not been influenced by progressive movements say in the latter 1800s the Amish population would be a lot bigger today. Something like 2/3 joined or became more mainstream churches in that period.

Leave a reply to Five Californias-full of Amish


Resource List
Reliable information from one of the largest Amish sites on the web.

Join over 15,000 email subscribers to get:
Amish Community Info | Book Giveaways | Amish Writers & non-Amish Experts | More

Get email updates

100% Free | No Spam | Unsubscribe Anytime