Diversity among the Amish

Swartzentruber Amish

Swartzentruber Amish

The Swartzentruber Amish are among the most tradition-minded Old Order peoples The Swartzentruber Amish affiliation came about in Ohio in 1917.  Today Swartzentruber Amish are considered among the “lowest” of Amish affiliations. Swartzentruber communities can be found in over a dozen states, though their population is highest in Holmes County, Ohio, where they live side-by-side with more progressive Amish. Facts about the Swartzentruber Amish: Swartzentruber…

Andy Weaver Amish

Yesterday’s interview with Karen Johnson-Weiner on New York Amish examined, among other things, how diverse Amish groups have adapted to life in the state.  One of the groups Karen discusses in depth in her book is the Andy Weaver Amish. The Andy Weaver Amish are an affiliation which came about in the 1950s in Holmes County, Ohio, over the issue of social shunning. Andy Weaver…

New Order Amish

The New Order Amish in Amish society What distinguishes New Order Amish from Old Order Amish? New Order Amish make up only a small percentage of the total Amish population–roughly 3%. New Order Amish live in a number of states, with the largest group found in the Holmes County, Ohio settlement (around 18 church districts, or about 2,400 individuals). Visually, New Order Amish can often…

New to Amish America: The Amish Online Encyclopedia

I’ve been looking forward to this new addition to Amish America for a long time.  Various questions seem to recur on Amish topics.  I thought it might be nice to put together a resource to try to answer some of those questions. The Amish Online Encyclopedia (AOE) covers a variety of subjects including Amish culture, beliefs, the different Amish affiliations, occupations, education, transportation, and so…

|

An interview with “An Amish Paradox” authors Charles Hurst and David McConnell

I recently read a book I’d been looking forward to for a long time.  An Amish Paradox: Diversity and Change in the World’s Largest Amish Community is an in-depth look at the Amish settlement at Holmes County, Ohio, and one of the most interesting books on the Amish I have read. In Ohio last month I had the pleasure of meeting the book’s authors, Charles…

Feeling queasy over technology

At a talk I gave in Holmes County, at one point one of the Amish entrepreneurs on the 5-man panel expressed concerns over technology.  Paraphrasing, he spoke of worries over “kids having the PSP and the Game Boy and half of the boys having cars”.   Having been to a few Amish homes, I can say this is not far off in some communities, where both…

“Aaron Miller” on the beard, cell phone, and Ordnung

An Amish friend, whom we’ll call “Aaron Miller”, recently discussed aspects of Amish society with a college class. Aaron later wrote a follow-up letter to the class, in which he addressed a few issues raised during the discussion.  Aaron has kindly shared the letter, from which we’ll post a few excerpts on the blog.  You may remember Aaron, aka “Anonymous Amish Person” or “Mr. X”,…

The Top 10 Amish Settlements

The ten largest Amish settlements, by number of church districts, as of 2009: 10. Allen County, Indiana (Founded 1852; 19 church districts).  This Amish settlement located to the north of Fort Wayne is a Swiss-ethnicity community.  Open buggies are driven here;  the construction trade is popular.  Allen County Amish homes are often built of red brick, unlike those of most other Amish.  The three most…

Ira Wagler on South-End Lancaster County

Ira Wagler grew up in Canada and Iowa Amish communities.  I like to link to his posts now and again, because his writing is very good and he offers a particular insider’s insight thanks to his Amish background. In one recent post, Ira offered his interesting take on the Lancaster County Amish, and the north-south ‘divide’ in particular.  An excerpt: Homes are spotless, inside and…

|

The trouble with ‘the Amish’

A recent re-read of a piece by Steven Nolt in Mennonite Quarterly Review–‘Who are the Real Amish?  Rethinking Diversity and Identity among a Separate People’— made me recall a common dilemma when discussing our Plain neighbors. ‘The Amish’ is a moniker that tries to do more than it really can, which is blanket a group of people having quite diverse practices.  Saying “‘the Amish’ this”…