Snitz Pie: The Amish Church Meal Treat

Note: I wrote this way back in 2007 while living for a summer in the Lancaster County Amish community. Snitz pie was a wonderful discovery I made towards the end of my time there. If you’ve never had it, I highly recommend trying it.

It’s mainly seen in the Lancaster County Amish (and related churches). It used to mostly only be made by the Amish for church. But nowadays you see it for purchase in some shops. I’ve added a snitz pie recipe at the end.


The last family I sat down with while selling books here in Lancaster County on Saturday evening made sure I left with a special treat – a slice of snitz pie. It was a delicious, thick-crusted wedge of apple-buttery goodness and I devoured it at once. About ten times better than what I’ve been eating lately anyway!

Three Amish apple-based pies
The pies on the right and left are snitz. The one at top is regular apple pie. Baked by an Amish mother and daughter (they made around 40 pies total) for an upcoming church service meal.

“Sylvan” and “Rebecca” had church today at their home, and so all day yesterday and during the previous days they spent time weed-whacking, scrubbing, and generally readying the home for a huge influx of guests.

Sylvan mentioned that they have a pretty large church district and so were expecting at least a couple hundred people. Snitz pie, which Rebecca said is made from dried apples, is one of the things they Amish eat at the Sunday meal, after service.

List of church utensils
Utensils list for an Amish church meal

Here’s a recipe I found, which I cannot say is exactly what Sylvan and Rebecca gave me, but maybe worth a try – if it turns out half as good it’ll still be delicious.

Snitz Pie Recipe

  • 1 qt. dried apple slices
  • 1 1/4 cup sugar
  • pinch of salt
  • 1/2 tsp. cinnamon
  • 3 drops lemon extract
  • Double Pie Crust

  1. Cover dried apples with water and soak overnight. Next day cook apples with water they were soaked in until soft, over low heat.
  2. Preheat oven to 425° F.
  3. Put apples through a ricer along with the juice they were cooked in. Add sugar, salt, cinnamon and lemon extract. Put in unbaked pie crust and add top crust.
  4. Bake at 425 degrees for 15 minutes, then at 375 degrees for 35 minutes or until done.

If you enjoyed this, check out my list of five favorite Amish foods (Snitz pie is on it!)

 

Get the Amish in your inbox

Join 15,000 email subscribers. No spam. 100% free

 
 
 

Similar Posts

  • An Amish Beekeeper

    I left a couple of photos out of last week’s Bowling Green, Missouri Amish collection. Here are shots of an Amish beekeeper’s facilities, and the happy end-product (courtesy of Beth Russo, thank you Beth).  First, the hives: These hives are located on the Hilty farm, known as Hilty’s Bee Yard.  In addition to regular pure honey, Hilty’s sell Raspberry-flavored Honey (see below), Buckwheat Honey, and…

  • Goot Essa Cheese Basket Giveaway Winner

    Yesterday evening, helped by my mother and brother, I enjoyed the “Down Home” gift basket, which arrived from Goot Essa last week. The basket came well-packed with insulation on all six sides, and four cooling packs. It also came with two cards. One has a photo of the cheese shop. On the reverse side it tells the Goot Essa story: The other card offered four…

  • Amish Mystery Supper: 13 Food Riddles

    Amish youth at Belle Center, Ohio (and elsewhere) may take part in a fun social event called a “Mystery Supper”.  Mark Curtis shares how this unusual meal works (thanks to Don Curtis for relaying the details): The youth come in and sit down for supper.  At their place is a plate and a list of numbered blanks. The blanks must be completely filled out in…

  • Pennsylvania Dutch Cuisine

    William Woys Weaver is a food historian who has written extensively on Pennsylvania Dutch food and culture.  He’s written a new book called As American As Shoofly Pie: The Foodlore and Fakelore of Pennsylvania Dutch Cuisine.  From an NPR article on the subject: News flash: Whoopie pies are not indigenous Pennsylvania Dutch food, no matter what the tourist traps say. Nor are the seafood bisque, chili, roast…

  • 3 Amish Bread Spreads

    A reader in Illinois shares a photo of 3 spreads given by an Amish neighbor, along with a loaf of bread and a thank-you note.  I have eaten 2 of these 3 (tasty).  Do you know what they are, and when they’re usually eaten?  Ever had some yourself? Update: Below, a larger photo of the note with reference to the spreads: The peanut butter (right) and…

  • How to Eat a Meal in an Amish Home (2 Ways)

    How can you arrange a meal in an Amish home? We’ve covered this topic on this site before on numerous occasions – with a lot of good comments from people sharing their experiences. Amish restaurants (or “Amish-style” restaurants) are a more accessible option, but for those who want to put in a bit more effort, a meal in an Amish home can be a memorable…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

8 Comments

  1. Yum. I’m envious. There is nothing better than a homemade pie – Snitz, Shoofly, or any kind….sounds like you hit the culinary jackpot!

  2. Thanks, Kevin. I imagine Lovina knows all about snitz pie. It’s my new number one by far.

  3. Mary Johnson

    One of the fond memories of my child hood was the “half moon pies” made with dried apples. I want to try to make them like my mother always did, especially for food stands at public auctions.

  4. Linda Lewis

    Just love Snitz pie and so easy to make. We buy bags of dried apples when we are in Bird-in-Hand,PA 2-3 times a year so I can make one whenever I want. We like them better than regular apple pie.

  5. Alice Aber

    Erik, did this recipe come from “The Amish Cook” or “The Amish Cook Anniversary Book”? I have both here and will have to go look to see. I have read them both from cover to cover but can’t remember what recipes are in them off the top of my head. Love all the stories in them. 🙂

  6. Lissy

    How do u dry apples?

    1. Geo

      Dried apples

      My favorite pocket snack. Dried apple slices. Good 4 pie too.
      Peel, core slice, dip in lemon juice if you want them to stay white, & place between two layers of old window screen & out in sunshine till they feel leathery. Seal up tightly & they seem to keep forever. I’ve never thrown any out. Dry them in a kitchen oven if it can be kept 110 degrees or so. To do a lot, a peel and core machine is super handy.

    2. Darlene Janel Cleary Harrold

      Dried Apples

      My grandmother and I would slice them and put them on white sheets or an old screen door and lay on top of old car or on the well house. If she used sheets we woukd pick out a real sunny part of the yard or behind house or next to garden and sometimes the boys would help make temporary post to tie four corners of sheet to and let the sun do the rest. Me and Grandma would come back around noon and check the apples. When it got close to dark we would come get them and bring them in house put in back room until morning and then take them right back out until they were dried and wrinkled. Then we would put them in jars and screw lids on. She would always date them and put the kind of apples they were.