Amish Controversies

Should Amish horses wear reflectors?

WGAL has a story, viewable above, featuring an interview with a man named Jason McClune. McClune’s sister suffered a serious brain injury when an Amish family’s horse got loose and hit a van she was traveling in, head-on. In the video McClune suggests that if the horse were wearing a reflective vest, it would have prevented the accident. We’ve discussed reflectors on buggies many times….

Suzanne Woods Fisher on Turning the Other Cheek

Suzanne Woods Fisher shares a guest post today in promotion of her new book The Letters.  As Suzanne explains below, for this book she drew on the story of Monroe Beachy, an Ohio Amish investment manager who pleaded guilty to mail fraud and is currently serving six and a half years in federal prison. This reminded me of another recent, related news item.  It’s kind…

Hospital Fights Amish Parents Over Daughter’s Chemo

From an Associated Press report: An Ohio hospital is fighting to force a 10-year-old Amish girl with leukemia to resume chemotherapy after her parents decided to stop the treatments. Akron Children’s Hospital is appealing a judge’s decision that blocked an attorney who’s also a registered nurse from taking over limited guardianship and making medical decisions for the girl. The hospital believes the girl will die without chemotherapy…

Drug & Alcohol Concerns for Ohio Amish

Drug & Alcohol Concerns for Ohio Amish

From WKBN: Approximately 200 Amish residents in Trumbull County gathered at the Mesopotamia fire station Monday evening for an open forum to discuss drug issues relating to heroin and methamphetamine. The meeting was called at the request of bishops within the Amish community, who reached out to police for help. Our station was asked not to show video from inside the meeting, but two police…

Child neglect after Amish baby’s life-saving heart surgery?

From the Watertown Daily Times: CANTON — An Amish couple is waiting to find out if child neglect charges against them will be dropped following a closed-door conference Thursday in Family Court. The couple, Annie L. and Levi M. Shetler, were charged last year after they refused open-heart surgery for their newborn daughter, Sarah, because they said the operation goes against the tenets of their…

Amish Buggy Decals

A reader shares: It is not uncommon to see buggies in the NE Indiana community with stickers on their SMV triangles.  I have seen Jayco stickers, KZ RV stickers, logos of fish, deer, horses, and a few religious bumper stickers.  And it’s not just the youth either.  I have seen several married people with stickers on their buggies. The youth are more likely to have…

Amish outhouse compromise?

Just out in the Columbus Dispatch, news on a possible compromise over the outhouse issue in the Amish community in Hardin County, Ohio: KENTON, Ohio — A truce has been reached, at least for now, between the Amish of Hardin County and health officials. The two sides have been at odds over rules for wells and outhouses at new Amish homes. With a clock ticking…

Fracking fades in Amish Ohio?

Energy companies are apparently losing enthusiasm for oil drilling in Ohio’s Utica Shale.  Oil in the Utica has proven more difficult than expected to extract, according to this article from Bloomberg: U.S. drillers that set up rigs amid the rolling farmland of eastern Ohio on projections underground shale held $500 billion of oil are packing up. Four of the biggest stakeholders in untapped deposits known…

Should we leave Amish and their outhouses alone?

Should we leave Amish and their outhouses alone?

Amish in Hardin County, Ohio are embroiled in an outhouse controversy that’s been percolating for the past year (more details here). Amish are balking at requirements that new homes have a “proper well”, paid waste removal, and septic system. Common practice in this community is to spread outhouse waste on the fields. Health and environmental concerns are the reasons given for enforcement. Interestingly, old homes…

Fracking Amish Country

Fracking is slowly entering the Amish community at New Wilmington, Pennsylvania, located an hour north of Pittsburgh. The community lies above the Marcellus Shale, an underground rock formation stretching across a half-dozen states which contains vast supplies of natural gas. Fracking, in a nutshell, works by drilling into rock formations, and then injecting large amounts of water mixed with chemicals and sand to fracture the…