Amish readers respond to Amish Grace; Amish Grace in Japan

‘It sure is a hard emotional read.  To see forgiveness layed out (sic) in such clinical terms while for us it is just a gut feeling…I was glad to see how you stressed that we also are human and struggle with this issue on a daily basis.

The thought came to mind that this generation can not claim credit for our attitude on forgiveness beings it was the result of our [heritage] but we surely can be blamed if it is not passed on to succeeding generations.  Thanks much.’ -Pennsylvania Amishman writing to Donald Kraybill on Amish Grace

Amish Grace Japan Japanese cover

The second anniversary of Nickel Mines approaches, and no doubt there will be at least a spattering of news stories commemorating the day.  Most will likely recall the lesson of forgiveness that eventually trumped the initial shock-horror story of the shooting itself.

The events of that early-autumn Monday morning spawned no less than three books on the crime and its aftermath.  The forgiveness element of the story was covered most in-depth in Amish Grace: How Forgiveness Transcended Tragedy.

As the authors of Amish Grace point out, forgiveness became the primary storyline following the initial tragedy.

Yet as Diane Zimmerman Umble and David Weaver-Zercher examine in The Amish and the Media, a secondary storyline also emerged in the days following the event–that of the media’s coverage of the Amish.

‘Conscious that the Amish community was wary of, and even disturbed by, the media’s presence in Nickel Mines’, Umble and Weaver-Zercher write, ‘some media outlets took the opportunity to turn their lenses on themselves.’

Turning the lenses inward resulted in criticism of some outlets for prying too deeply into the Amish community at a time of extreme grief.

Amish Grace is hardly what one would call a ‘typical media piece’–it is rather a measured, well-researched book-length examination by three of the most respected scholars of Amish society, one that explores the Amish act of forgiveness with a deep awareness of,and respect for, Amish social mores and values.

Yet because of that, it actually turns out to be more revealing than the media’s pieces following the events, many of which were hastily assembled by reporters with only rudimentary knowledge of Amish society.

As Amish Grace probes deeper, it reveals more to the public on how Amish society functions, exposing more of the ‘guts’ of the Amish to the outside world than clumsy photographers and hurried newsmen really ever could.

So what do the Amish themselves think about Amish Grace?

Amish Grace Nickel Mines road sign

Donald Kraybill, who co-authored the book with Weaver-Zercher and Steven Nolt, has kindly shared some correspondence from Amish readers.  Opinion will never be unanimous, but most signs show a strongly positive response from those Amish who have read the book.

In a July interview with Amish America, Kraybill mentioned receiving more than 10 calls and notes from Amish readers, including a call from a father–one who lost a daughter in the event–who wished to order 10 copies of the book for friends.

In addition to the quote which opened this post, here is a sampling of other Amish-penned comments from letters Professor Kraybill has received:

From a Pennsylvania Amishman:  ‘Just a note to tell you that I really appreciated the book.  I think you guys did a really good job.  It is really authentic.  Thanks a lot!’

An Illinois Amish bishop, who wrote that ‘Amish Grace accurately described Amish beliefs’, commented on the Lord’s Prayer that ‘we think we should live those words, not just repeat them in a mindless manner.’

An Ohio bishop wrote that ‘the more I think on the 10.02.06 incident, the more I realize how central forgiveness is to our faith.  And why the Lord’s Prayer is so important to the Amish.  Thanks for [a] nicely done book.’

A Pennsylvania Amishman close to the victims’ families writes that ‘your work was and is well respected by the victim[‘s] familys (sic), and all those I’ve been in contact with who were directly involved with the Nickle Mines incident.  This work has actual value on healing within the Nickle Mines Community, and that was our goal.’

The story spreads


Amish Grace was released approximately one year ago and has gone on to sell 60,000 copies in hardcover.

Professor Kraybill shares that the book has gone into wide usage in numerous college classrooms and in church groups around the country.

In promoting the book, the profits of which were donated to the Mennonite Central Committee, authors Kraybill, Weaver-Zercher, and Nolt did nearly 80 presentations across the country over a 10-month period.

The book has found international appeal as well, with a version available in Japanese, and translations currently being done into French, German, and Korean.

Get the Amish in your inbox

Join 15,000 email subscribers. No spam. 100% free

    Similar Posts

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


    1. Emma

      Yes, this is a great book! Very respectful and well researched. I talked about it with Cons. Menno. friends and the book made them reflect on forgiveness (and Gelassenheit) in their own life.
      Yes, indeed a great book for everyone!
      Thanks a lot for your blog, Eric.

    2. Emma, and thank you for reading the blog. Glad you like Amish Grace as well. I actually avoided reading it for awhile as I did not want to go back into the story given its heavy nature. But when I finally did read it I was glad for it. An insightful and thought-provoking examination of forgiveness.

    3. I am reading it right now. Actually I could have read it in 2 hours but life seems to be getting in the way so I am slowly getting through it.

      The anniversary is only a few short days away. Let’s remember the families in prayer.


    4. Marcia

      My library does not have Amish Grace – (I have been a little leery of the book given the subject matter) While shopping the other day, I stopped at a bookstore and the clerk checked the computer and said, “Oh, we only have one copy. Chances are it isn’t here.” My first thought was, “Whew.” As the clerk looked where the computer said it was located, I began hoping it was there as I know there is lots to learn from the book, even though it will be an emotional read, (as some of you have commented). “Nope, the book isn’t here, sorry.” I thanked the clerk and began to walk out of the store when I heard this voice call out, “Wait! Here it is! It was filed in the wrong place!” I will begin reading Amish Grace as soon as I finish House Calls and Hitching Posts (about a doctor who treated the Amish).

    5. Susan

      “Amish Grace” was a very different book and experience than the one I thought it would be. It is not ABOUT the Amish, so much as it uses their story to talk about the human experience of struggling with forgiveness. It’s really a book for everyone, and a book to be read slowly and learned from.

    6. Susan glad you found it valuable, I did as well. The authors have another book upcoming, called The Amish Way, on Amish spirituality. We’ll be having more on the blog about it soon