47 responses to Amish soap

  • Sharon
    Comment on Amish soap (October 3rd, 2011 at 07:05)


    Have always wondered about this!! Thanks for sharing. Question for anyone — How does one go about adding “scents” to these soaps, or is that not done, because of different beliefs? Also, what is meant by “dirty” lard? And, does it “sit” somewhere, until it is hardened and then cut into bars, or what?

    I am learning so much about this area of the U.S.!! This website is a great place, and learning something new each day! I look forward each morning, to see what else Amish America has to offer!
    Thanks, Erik and everyone! Sharon

    Amish soap

    • Christina
      Comment on Amish soap (October 3rd, 2011 at 13:17)

      Dirty lard

      By “dirty lard” they mean unrendered pig fat. To render the lard, you chop up your pig fat and put it in a pot with some water so it doesn’t scorch and melt it. The bits that don’t render are the cracklins. Those need to be strained out and can be eaten.

      I believe if you used beef fat it would be the same process for rendering, I don’t know what those by-products are called though.

    • Comment on Amish soap (October 3rd, 2011 at 15:51)

      Homemade soap

      The process of making cold processed soap is more complicated then it sounds, at least until you get experienced at it. If you want to make your own, just search “homemade soap recipes” on-line and you’ll find everything you’ll need to know.

  • Dana
    Comment on Amish soap (October 3rd, 2011 at 07:27)

    Thank Erik for posting recipe for home made soap, I believe they don’t care much about scent, it has to wash off dirt. But some lavender oil would be nice.

  • Lee Ann
    Comment on Amish soap (October 3rd, 2011 at 07:40)

    Amish women love to put lavender oil in their soaps for themselves and the little ones. The men prefer to have plain soap.

    The soaps the Amish continue to make remind me of the old soaps an older lady made that lived near us growing up. She refused to buy store bought soap and about twice a year made her own and stored it in the basement.

  • Katie Troyer
    Comment on Amish soap (October 3rd, 2011 at 08:59)

    Most of their soap is laundry soap. They either put the whole bar of soap in the wash tub until the water is soapy and then take the bar out or shave slivers off the bar and throw those into the hot water. The same bars of soap are also used as dish soap.

    Asking about clean lard, they butcher their own hogs, render the hogfat into lard and then have to clean the lard from bits of whatever is in the rendered lard. I don’t know how the lard is cleaned as we never butchered pigs.

    Amish soap

  • Forest
    Comment on Amish soap (October 3rd, 2011 at 09:47)

    Just a note, be very careful with the lye, not to get it on your skin or in your eyes.

  • jackie
    Comment on Amish soap (October 3rd, 2011 at 09:58)

    My Husband and I make our own soap. We use pretty much the same recipe. But our soap never turns out white it is always a tanish color. Any ideas? Could it be the cast iron pot we use? Erik do you know what kind of pot that soap was made in. I dont think you can use certain metals. But I dont know as we always use cast iron and wood utensils.

    • Robin
      Comment on Amish soap (January 3rd, 2012 at 11:42)

      Less than white soap.

      Your soap may not be white because your lye is still “hot”. I know that sounds strange but believe is or not because lye is an acid it in considered caustically “hot” and can continue to generate heat and a burning effect to the other ingredients. You may want to try letting you lye and water sit a little longer and making it the last ingredient you all to the mix.

      • Arlene Oldfield
        Comment on Amish soap (December 1st, 2012 at 14:57)

        Lye Soap

        No it is the temperature my Grandmother use to make what we call hot or cold water lye soap.The cold was off white and the hot was brown in color,It sure does bring back wonderful memories of her.She has been gone to heaven since 1977.

    • Calleen Troyer
      Comment on Amish soap (May 26th, 2012 at 00:21)


      Today I learned from an Amish gal not far from the secert in the soap is stirring it until it gels, in the hot sun. I could not get my soap to really clean my laundry the other secert to clean things is rain water or flitered water. Learn something new everyday!

      • Lotta
        Comment on Amish soap (November 21st, 2013 at 10:37)


        You mention “secert” twice. English is not my daily language, and I have never seen that word before, so I looked it up, but it wasn’t listed in the Cambridge Dictionaries. Did you mean “secret”?

  • Comment on Amish soap (October 3rd, 2011 at 11:26)

    Making soap

    I’m not a soap expert – but only make soap in a well ventiliated place – outdoors preferably. Alway sprinkle the lye into the water and NEVER the other way around. Fat can be rendered by boiling it in an equal amount of water until it is melted, letting it cool, and then taking off the fat. Jackie, you will get nicer results if you use an enamelled kettle.

    The longer the soap sits, the better it will be.

    Amish soap

    • Jackie
      Comment on Amish soap (October 3rd, 2011 at 14:07)

      our lye soap is very good on the skin. its not real strong. We have friends beg us to make more. They use it for excema, acne etc, And absolutley love it. Even my best friend who could be compared to a Barbie doll fashion queen loves it. We make ours outside over a fire in an old cast iron kettle.
      Magdalena, I may try a smaller batch in an enamel pot. Thanks for the idea.

    • Lissa Holder
      Comment on Amish soap (October 3rd, 2011 at 20:48)

      Hi I was wondering, you can by beef lard in a bucket or by the pound ?. I used to live across the street from a Mexican family that used it alot. Especially, In their tortillas. I love to make soap, but have never used this recipe. I would like to try it. I don’t think I could do the rendering part though. ~Lissa

      • Jackie
        Comment on Amish soap (October 4th, 2011 at 07:58)

        Yes you can buy lard in a bucket. I have seen it at walmart. Maybe tallow too I am not sure. And I think you find it in the hispanic section.

  • Comment on Amish soap (October 3rd, 2011 at 11:35)

    I think they shave off of the bar of soap for the dishwater. My mother used to do that when we were low on money and my father hadn’t gotten paid yet. She’d go to the store and by several bars of Ivory soap and shave off into the hot dishwater. Then I could wash the dishes.

    I also read that in an Amish fiction story when one of the female characters shaved of pieces from the block of soap into the dishwater.

    Amish soap

    • Lotta
      Comment on Amish soap (November 21st, 2013 at 10:53)

      Childhood memories...

      Your mom shaved off soap. I remember mine had a metal wire thingie that had a handle and a cage at the end. You pushed the handle parts together, and the “cage” opened and you put a bar of soap in. Then you could pull that back and forth in your dishwater until it was soapy enough to do the dishes… That basic soap is still for sale in the stores, just as it was back then and still can be used for anything.

      I remember I was so envious, as all my friends got all those nice soaps and bath foams, and all I got was that, as my parents had heard I should only use that because of my eczema and psoriasis (and it was pretty good advice, except for the fact that we used way too much soap. Especially kids with eczema, should use as little soap as possible! Today they can easily avoid it altogether, as there are alternatives, cleansing lotions/oils!).

      Amish soap

  • Melissa
    Comment on Amish soap (October 3rd, 2011 at 12:20)

    I’ve made laundry detergent for my family of 6 for the last three years. (I usually have to make it about twice a year.) I definately don’t use this recipe though. I wouldn’t even know where to buy/get lard or lye here in the city. If I knew, I’d be willing to try it. Although I can’t imagine it would be very kind to sensitive skin.

    Thanks Eric for all you post for un Englishers. I’m really enjoying your site!

    Amish soap

  • Christina
    Comment on Amish soap (October 3rd, 2011 at 13:22)

    Soap making book

    There is a wonderful book called “Soap: Making It, Enjoying It” by Ann Bramson. The author is very thorough and explains everything–even a little soap history in the beginning.

    Please be careful when using lye!

  • Bonne Campbell
    Comment on Amish soap (October 3rd, 2011 at 15:47)

    This recipe will give a non superfatted soap. aka: laundry soap Ck out recipes by running them through a soap calculator like soapcalc.com Most soaps used for skin have a superfat of 4-6%. That’s 4-6% more fats/oils than it takes for the lye to saponify the fats/oils used in a recipe. IMO, vegan soaps don’t compare to ones that use animal oils like lard. Lard especially is nice because it is close to natural human oils in chemistry. Coconut oil in a soap recipe will give nice lathering properties. Always carefully WEIGH ingredients for a soap recipe using a scale accurate to 10ths of an ounce for best results. A lye heavy soap is dangerous to use.

    Amish soap

  • Shawn
    Comment on Amish soap (October 3rd, 2011 at 16:33)


    Can someone please tell me where to get lye and pig fat? Do I go to the butcher? Online?

    • Peggy Mooneyhan
      Comment on Amish soap (May 11th, 2012 at 15:00)

      Where To Buy Lard

      You can buy lard in the grocery store it’s near the canola oils. It is called ARMOUR will usually be in a white bucket that says LARD for a 2.5 bucket it will run around $5.49 Walmart carries it as well in the same area..Kroger’s carries. Good Luck I make my soaps all the time my recipe is:
      5 cups of distilled water 100 degrees
      12 oz Lye 100 degrees
      5 lbs and 10 oz of lard
      make soap as usual

  • Tracy
    Comment on Amish soap (October 3rd, 2011 at 16:57)

    Amish soap

    Melissa, what do you do to make the laundry soap.?

  • Bonne Campbell
    Comment on Amish soap (October 3rd, 2011 at 17:49)

    Lye can often be found at Ace Hardware stores or Lowes. At Ace it’s Rooto Household Lye and Lowes it’s Roebic drain cleaner. Must be 100% Sodium Hydroxide, no fillers. Read up on soapmaking first!!~safety etc. Join a soapmaking forum like craftserver.com Keep pets and kids away and limit distractions. Lye has become more difficult to find because it’s used in the making of Methamphetamines. Lard is at any grocery store, by the pail or the 1 lb brick.

    Amish soap

  • Comment on Amish soap (October 3rd, 2011 at 22:31)

    Amish soap

    I just love homemade soaps. This is an interesting looking soap. It reminded me a bit of “divinity”…this white chocolate almond bark candy that my grandmother used to make.

  • annasher
    Comment on Amish soap (October 7th, 2011 at 12:02)

    there is no such thing as “fine” lotions and hand soaps at wal-mart.

    • Lotta
      Comment on Amish soap (November 21st, 2013 at 11:13)

      You couldn’t be more correct, actually there is barely any actual (a.k.a. real) soap to be found in a modern supermarket. There are only different kinds of chemical detergents, which are called “soap” today only because the public knows and are used to that word. But if there is one thing it in general definitely is NOT, and that is SOAP, because it has not gone through any saponification process… But, of course, there are certain exceptions (e.g. some old products still available, personally I’m not familiar with the American brands, only Norwegian)…

      Just to make that clear, I don’t mean to in any way imply that there is anything wrong with detergents, only that they are different. Personally I think natural soaps have some advantages, while for some things some modern products for sure have advantages (e.g. pH-low “soaps” and modern cleansing oils/lotions) over soap for certain needs (e.g. for intimate use and for special needs skin, as with skin diseases like Atopic Dermatitis/Eczema where there is a defective skin barrier that causes certain challenges/problems).

      Amish soap

  • Shawn
    Comment on Amish soap (October 7th, 2011 at 12:05)

    Hand Lotion...

    An Amish woman sold me some wonderful hand lotion yesterday that actually works! I’ve tried just about everything…even “fine” lotions and it all made my hands worse…bleeding and cracked. She’s an angel.

  • Melissa
    Comment on Amish soap (October 7th, 2011 at 17:40)

    My soap...

    Katie (and others)–I use the recipe the Duggar family has on their website. It’s relatively quick and easy and it works in HE washers. http://www.duggarfamily.com/content/duggar_recipes

    I’ve made both powdered and liquid detergent. The powder is easier to store, but had to be made more often than the liquid.

  • Susan
    Comment on Amish soap (November 29th, 2011 at 01:31)

    Rendering fat

    Be careful when rendering fat from hogs. It can catch fire very easily and has caught many homes and people on fire.

  • Alan
    Comment on Amish soap (February 13th, 2012 at 13:48)

    Amish Soap is Awesome!

    I haven’t ventured to try to make my own soap – lye is scary and pig fat burning homes and people…yikes! Anyway I found a site that sells Amish soap! Wow! it’s www.amishsoap.wordpress.com. I got some and it’s awesome…looks white and colored – it’s scent is just clean. I just thought you all might like to know. I’m working on getting on a few sites to help encourage me to make soap, but until then!

    Amish soap

  • Stephanie Rollins
    Comment on Amish soap (November 19th, 2012 at 14:35)


    Lard: :) It is what my grandmother still makes her biscuits with and fries her chicken in. She buys in in those big white buckets that you only see little old ladies put in their shopping carts. Oddly enough, she stays so thin. Go figure.

  • Comment on Amish soap (September 15th, 2013 at 08:54)

    Lard makes white soap

    That is why it is so white, the lard is the only oil in that recipe. Using vegetable oils like olive oil makes a more off white creamy color and some green oils make actual green soap (grapeseed, avocado).

  • Lotta
    Comment on Amish soap (November 21st, 2013 at 10:21)



    Great to post recipes like that, but a soap recipe that after all involves the potentially very hazardous lye, should involve more information about which precautions to take and not just that, very important information that the soap MUST NOT be used right away, it MUST be cured first (most say a minimum of 3 weeks, preferably 4 weeks or even longer – it gets milder as it ages as the neutralization process goes on. Fresh soap will burn skin! See some say online they never sell soap until it is at least 3-4 weeks old).

    If you e.g. want to make soap with your kids for presents etc, this is NOT the way, as this is a long process. Then you need to use already made and cured soap base you can buy quite reasonably, melt it and add all kinds of fun things to make pretty soaps. Also, if you make bottles of liquid soap from it, it takes very little base for a pint of soap! I add colors, canola oil to “overfat” it, which is great for the skin and also essential oils. For kitchen soaps, to wash your hands after handling meat or fish, I use lemon/orange oil and finely ground coffee, takes that smell right out!!! Liquid soaps aren’t like commercial liquid soaps (those aren’t really soap, but a detergent), after a while you may get stiff soap at the bottom. Just put it in hot water for a while, or a little trip in the microwave, shake it and it’s ready again. I prefer the liquid soap, when making soap became popular some years back, everybody made bars of soaps. I very soon remembered why we quit using those, they are messy, residue on the sink, dirty bars of soap after others who didn’t rinse it off after use etc. YUCK! But everybody loved my liquid varieties, put them on pretty bottles with a pump, very practical. All you do, is to heat the amount you need in water, when the water boils, you can add soap in small pieces. Stir until everything is dissolved, then add your oils/scents and color, when mixed, pour into bottles. Very quick. Kids can decorate the bottles, e.g. with pretty cut outs with contact paper on top, make cute labels, maybe stuff little plastic toys inside the soap bottles (actually great for when you shake the bottle to keep it from stiffening, helps in mixing) etc. etc. Nice thing to do e.g. now before Christmas… Maybe something you could do to give a little something to people you know about who doesn’t have much family who gives them something for Christmas (or other holiday this time of the year)? Would sure warm a heart! Caring about others is much what Christmas should be about in this day and age where everything is so commercialized and stress becomes no. 1 instead of joy for so many (while others are just lonely and sad, that is of course as tough as it gets when it’s holiday time)…

    Here is a portion from the Wikipedia article on lye about the hazardous reactions that may happen:


    In common with other corrosives, the major safety concern with lye is its potentially destructive effects on living tissues (e.g., skin, flesh, and the cornea). Solutions containing it can cause chemical burns, permanent injuries, scarring, and blindness—immediately upon contact. Lye may be harmful or even fatal if swallowed; ingestion can cause esophageal stricture. Moreover, solvation of dry solid lye is highly exothermic; the resulting heat may cause additional burns, or, ignite flammables.

    The reaction between sodium hydroxide and a few metals is also hazardous. Aluminium reacts with lye to produce hydrogen gases. Since hydrogen is flammable, mixing a large quantity of lye (e.g., sodium hydroxide) and aluminum in a closed container is dangerous—especially when the system is at a high temperature, which speeds up the reaction. In addition to aluminum, lye may also react with magnesium; galvanized zinc; tin; chromium; brass; and, bronze—producing hydrogen gas.

    Amish soap

Leave a reply to Amish soap