Over 200 Amish Have Taught in Mexico Since 2000

Have you ever heard about the Amish in Mexico? It’s quite a remarkable story. No, there are no Mexican Amish communities (at least not anymore). But thanks to their outreach to a group of spiritual kin, the Amish have had a regular presence in Mexico for the last two decades.

Old Colony Mennonites are an Anabaptist group with some cultural similarities to Amish, including Plain clothing and a German dialect. They live predominantly in Mexico and other Latin American nations.

Old Colony Mennonites originally came to Canada from Ukraine in the 1870s, but in the 1920s migrated to Mexico due to public schooling requirements.

They are close spiritual cousins to Amish and Mennonites, but unlike most of their religious kin in North America, they have suffered due to a weak educational system, exacerbated by their relative isolation and fear of outside influences.

Specifically they have faced serious problems with literacy and mathematics. Many have failed to recognize the importance of education, with some parents even neglecting to send their children to school on a regular basis.

The colonies in turn have had a lack of qualified teachers since their schools have been producing such poorly-educated people.

Old Colony bishop Diedrich Peters explains this self-perpetuating problem in the book Called To Mexico: Bringing hope and literacy to the Old Colony Mennonites:

It causes concern for the church as to how our schools will eventually end up. It seems as though we are approaching a time when our own colonies can no longer provide their own teachers. Which is not surprising, for no one feels equipped for the job. Of a truth, such weak schools do have a hard time producing real teachers.

Then if someone does dare to accept a teaching position, it is often because the village neighbors keep trying to persuade him and he is poor. Without an interest in the school, without any inclination to it, without knowledge or training, with experience in teaching, and without self-discipline and practice, many a teacher is conducting school solely by routine and habit. Therefore weak schools are always getting weaker. (pp. 90-91)

The low overall level of education has had negative effects not only on their economic prospects, but also on the spiritual life of their communities, due to not being able to read and comprehend the Bible.

As Peters notes, “How can they search the Scriptures who can neither read nor understand them? They can hardly understand even when the Word is read aloud to them” (p. 91).

Help from the Amish

Facilitated by Mennonite Central Committee, Amish learned of this situation in the mid-1990s. Thanks to the efforts of some motivated individuals, they began helping by sending Amish teachers south to teach Old Colony children.

Though they were not welcomed by all, the program has grown and seen successes in the ensuing years. Amish from at least a half-dozen states have participated as teachers, or in supportive roles as house parents or house sisters.

This might be the best example of an international mission program you’ll find among the Amish (who tend not to do a lot of international mission work, at least not work that involves international travel, though there are exceptions).

Rebecca Miller, member of an Amish church in Ohio, wrote about the background of the Old Colony people and this remarkable project in a 2016 post (Rebecca later went to Mexico herself to teach).

You can also find it documented in other writing produced by the Amish, including the book Called to Mexico referenced above.

Photos from Called To Mexico, a book comprised of the writings of Amish teachers and others involved in the program

Mennonite World Review gives an update on the program in a new article:

Beginning with a 1995 visit by eight Old Order Amish to Old Colony Mennonites in Mexico, Mennonite Central Committee helped the two groups explore how to support each other.

“We sensed that at first the Old Colony people were hesitant about us coming,” said Leroy Stoltzfus, a longtime MCC worker, recalling that first trip. “They were wondering if they could trust us. Our Amish group saw their strengths and their needs, and we resolved that we would help as God made it possible.”

Twenty years later, Amish schoolteachers have a steady presence in Old Colony schools. More than 200 have served in this way.

Colony students who learned from Amish teachers are now moving into teaching positions them­selves and have implemented Amish teaching practices.

The Amish have proved well suited to help Old Colony Mennonites raise their educational standards while remaining a separated people.

Similarities between Old Colony Mennonites and Old Order Amish became fertile soil from which the Old Order Amish teacher program would flourish.

The two things that jumped out at me here are the number of participants – over 200 teachers in the program’s roughly 19 years – and the fact that students have begun teaching using Amish teaching practices. This will help assure the long-term success of this program.

The Amish were a good fit for this role, in large part because they were a good example – a “people apart” who had built a successful parochial education structure, which allowed their children to become both good church members, and productive members of society.

Amish have historical and cultural similarities, and respect for Old Colony Mennonite belief, but clearly there must be a level of trust there that these are not “conversion” missions, but rather done in a spirit of brotherly love. No doubt it had to take some courage on the part of the Mennonites to open up to outside help.

I’ll wrap up by sharing this excerpt from the close of Rebecca’s 2016 post:

As of 2015 there were Amish teachers in seven different colonies in Mexico and one in Texas.

Some of the teachers are very dedicated to this project and have been teaching there for many years. The schools are running smoothly and the children are eager to learn.

The challenge now is to provide good reading material, as they have a great hunger to read. There are no mailboxes, no road signs, and no road names or numbers, as no one could read them. They have no mottoes or calendars on the walls, and there are no recipe books. They memorize all their recipes.

What a blessing it is to see these innocent children growing up and now being able to read and understand the Bible’s teaching. They can learn right from wrong and live a clean God-fearing life, because they can read Jesus’s words and follow them.

I’ve read stories of children being able to teach their parents to read. They also have Evening School for the adults now and English classes in the summer. Let us do our duty and pray for all involved, so that things may be furthered for the Kingdom.

Get the Amish in your inbox

Join 15,000 email subscribers. No spam. 100% free

    Join the Amish America Patreon for bonus videos & more!

    Similar Posts

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    10 Comments

    1. Dawn Gregory

      I am really interested in this issue being an ex certified language arts teacher. By ex I mean I did not get my certificate renewed because I did not have another teaching position. If you could send me information on the issue and anything pertinate to it.
      Mrs. Dawn M. Gregory
      3463A Spoolmill Road
      Vernon, Florida 32462

      8503264896

      1. Dawn if you’re interested I think the Called to Mexico book I mentioned could be a really good resource to give you a picture of what the colonies are/were like and the experience of the teachers and others involved.

        It doesn’t seem to be available on Amazon, don’t know about elsewhere online, but I know Amish book stores sell it, I would think Raber’s would have it stocked. Here’s some contact info on that store:

        https://amishamerica.com/amish-publications-addresses-order-subscription-info/

      2. Al in Ky

        Dawn — Erik’s suggestion of contacting Raber’s Bookstore is good, because they might have the book. Another possibility would be Gospel Book Store in Berlin, Ohio which advertises in The Budget newspaper every week. Their advertisement always includes the note: “Looking for any specific book?
        Contact us by phone or mail, we will find it!” Address/phone: Gospel Book Store P. O. Box 320 Berlin, Ohio 44610 Phone: 330-893-2523
        Gospel Book Store stocks many Amish and Mennonite books.

        Erik — Thanks for including this post. I regularly read in The Budget in letters from Amish communities in various states reports from schoolteachers from their communities who are currently in Mexico teaching. It was interesting to learn more about this in your post on the subject.

    2. Nancy

      Amish teach in Mexico

      I subscribe to Die Botschaft and often read the letters sent in by the young Amish women who come from Lancaster County, PA and teach in Mexico. It is so very interesting to read of their trials and successes with the children there, and their travels in the area in their leisure time, as well as their interaction with the Mexican families. They seem to be very well received, and certainly have an exciting adventure to remember when they finally come back to the U.S. God bless their work and those who support this mission.

    3. Interesting

      Eric, just curious what language do they speak? Do they speak the Pennsylvania Dutch?
      Jason

      1. Jason the German dialect they speak is not Pennsylvania Dutch but Plautsdietsch which is a Low German dialect. I was asking someone about this in PA in December and it sounds like the teachers at least in that case use High German to teach the students. However the Called to Mexico book also lists around 15 English teachers who have spent time in the colonies from 2009-2011 (book was published in 2011), so there’s been some English instruction going on as well.

        https://gameo.org/index.php?title=Dialect_Literature_and_Speech,_Low_German

    4. George

      Over 200 Amish have taught in Mexico since 2000

      May the Lord bless them all!

    5. George j

      A real need

      “…no mailboxes, no road signs, and no road names or numbers, as no one could read them. They have no mottoes or calendars on the walls, and there are no recipe books.”

      Reading this nearly brought me to tears. I’m sure many readers would like to help and would appreciate more information.

    6. amishgirlRebecca

      been there-done that

      Wow! I was so surprised to see this on here. I came home last week having spent an all too short school term there.But, glad to be home! We had school from 1st of August to 1st of April. Yes, we teach High German. In the summer English teachers go down for 6 weeks to teach English as a second Language to (mostly) adults and teens at 6 different locations. A lot of their own schools have come a long way since 2000 and are operating totally on their own. Today we are mostly working in newer colonies. Yes, there are great needs, but by far the greatest needs aren’t monetary. And, we do work with many concerned people and things are definitely looking up.

    7. Isabelle Faubert

      Studies

      Hi all. I am interested to teach English as a second language in Mexico to Mennonite communities. I have taught English as a second language here in Quebec and i am interested to have a new experience.

      Thank you

      Isabelle