Holmes County: 10 Amish-Style Restaurants For A Great Meal

If you’re spending time in the Holmes County Amish community and looking for a good place to eat, you’ve got plenty of good options. The area is known for hearty, homestyle cooking—think broasted chicken, real mashed potatoes, fresh-baked pies, and plenty of comfort food made from scratch.

Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a seasoned traveler, these establishments – from hearty buffets to Amish-run bakeries – provide a genuine taste of the region’s culinary offerings. And don’t be surprised if you see Amish folks both working behind the counter – or sitting down to eat. These are their go-to spots too.

Here are 10 PA Dutch & Amish-style restaurants worth visiting for an authentic taste of Holmes County:

1. Der Dutchman – Walnut Creek, OH

Der Dutchman in Walnut Creek has been serving traditional Amish kitchen cooking for over 40 years. Known for its broasted chicken, real mashed potatoes, and homemade pies, the restaurant offers a warm, family-friendly atmosphere with picturesque views of the surrounding countryside.

• Style: Buffet & menu
• Best For: Classic Amish dishes in a scenic setting
• Website: dhgroup.com/restaurants/der-dutchman-walnut-creek-oh/
• Address: 4967 Walnut Street, Walnut Creek, OH 44687
• Phone: (330) 893-2981

2. Dutch Valley Restaurant – Sugarcreek, OH

Located in the charming village of Sugarcreek, Dutch Valley Restaurant offers a hearty menu featuring roast beef, mashed potatoes, and Amish noodles. The restaurant is part of a larger complex that includes a bakery and gift shop, making it a perfect stop for both dining and shopping.

• Style: Buffet & menu
• Best For: Family meals with shopping opportunities
• Website: dhgroup.com/restaurants/dutch-valley-sugarcreek-oh/
• Address: 1343 Old Route 39, Sugarcreek, OH 44681
• Phone: (330) 852-4627

3. Mrs. Yoder’s Kitchen – Mount Hope, OH

Situated in Mount Hope, Mrs. Yoder’s Kitchen is renowned for its authentic Amish cooking, including a famous buffet featuring crispy fried chicken. The restaurant’s welcoming atmosphere and hearty meals have made it a staple in the community. Located near the popular Mt. Hope Auction in a heavily-Amish area, expect to see Amish diners enjoying meals here too.

• Style: Buffet & menu
• Best For: Traditional Amish comfort food
• Website: mrsyoderskitchen.com
• Address: 8101 State Route 241, Mount Hope, OH 44660
• Phone: (330) 674-0922

4. Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant – Berlin, OH

Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant, located in Berlin, offers a nostalgic dining experience with its classic diner-style setting. Known for its hot roast beef sandwiches and wide selection of homemade pies, it’s a favorite among both locals and visitors seeking traditional fare. You can also get a tasty Trail Bologna & Swiss sandwich here, made from a famous local lunchmeat.

• Style: Traditional menu
• Best For: Classic diner experience with Amish favorites
• Website: boydandwurthmann.com
• Address: 4819 East Main Street, Berlin, OH 44610
• Phone: (330) 893-3287

5. Dutch Kitchen – Dalton, OH

Dutch Kitchen offers a warm, family-friendly atmosphere where guests can enjoy traditional Amish and Mennonite recipes. Diners enjoy breakfast, lunch, and dinner buffets. The restaurant also features a bakery with homemade pies, breads, and cookies, as well as banquet facilities and catering services for various events. This restaurant is located in neighboring Wayne County, on the north side of the Amish settlement.

• Style: Buffet & menu

• Best For: Family-style dining with authentic Amish and Mennonite dishes

• Website: dutchkitchen.net

• Address: 14278 Lincoln Way E, Dalton, OH 44618

• Phone: (330) 683-0530

6. Berlin Farmstead Restaurant – Berlin, OH

Just off the main street in Berlin, Berlin Farmstead Restaurant offers a delicious hot buffet and salad bar, along with menu options featuring freshly made dinner rolls and pies. The central location in Berlin – the “heart” of Amish Country – and its ample parking make it a favorite among locals and tourists alike.

• Style: Buffet & menu
• Best For: Convenient dining near Berlin’s shops
• Website: dhgroup.com/restaurants/berlin-farmstead-berlin-oh/
• Address: 4757 Township Road 366, Berlin, OH 44610
• Phone: (330) 893-4600

7. The Amish Door Restaurant – Wilmot, OH

The Amish Door Restaurant in Wilmot offers a “Grand Buffet” featuring roast beef, broasted chicken, and homemade bread. It’s also known for its Brown Bag Apple Pie, an overfilled apple delight. The establishment is part of a larger village that includes a bakery, inn, and gift shop.

• Style: Buffet & menu
• Best For: All-in-one Amish dining and shopping experience
• Website: amishdoor.com
• Address: 1210 Winesburg Street, Wilmot, OH 44689
• Phone: (330) 359-5464

8. Kauffman’s Country Bakery – Millersburg, OH

Located near Berlin, Kauffman’s is a well-known bakery offering fresh pies, breads, cookies, and bulk goods. With a cozy café and ice cream shop, it’s a great stop for snacks, breakfast, or picking up treats to go.

• Style: Bakery & café

• Best For: Fresh baked goods and grab-and-go bites

• Website: kauffmanscountrybakery.com

• Address: 4357 US-62, Millersburg, OH 44654

• Phone: (330) 893-2129

9. Des Dutch Essenhaus – Shreve, OH

Des Dutch Essenhaus is a family-owned Amish-style restaurant in the heart of Shreve, a small town nearer the edge of the Amish settlement. Known for its hearty comfort food and welcoming atmosphere, the restaurant offers breakfast, lunch, and dinner, featuring favorites like broasted chicken, roast beef, an array of homemade pies, and a well-stocked soup and salad bar.

• Style: Traditional Amish-style menu with buffet options

• Best For: Homestyle meals and a cozy dining experience

• Website: desdutchessenhaus.com

• Address: 176 N Market Street, Shreve, OH 44676

• Phone: (330) 567-2212

10. Hershberger’s Farm & Bakery – Millersburg, OH

Hershberger’s Farm & Bakery is a popular Amish-owned destination best known for its fresh-baked goods—including fry pies, donuts, breads, and pies made daily. While primarily a bakery and farm store, it also features a food trailer offering burgers and sandwiches, like the locally loved “Hershburger.” The site includes a petting zoo and seasonal produce, making it a great stop for families.

• Style: Amish bakery with casual food trailer dining

• Best For: Fresh Amish-baked goods with sandwich and burger options

• Website: hershbergers-farm-and-bakery.foodjoyy.com

• Address: 5452 State Route 557, Millersburg, OH 44654

• Phone: (330) 674-6096

Final Thoughts

Whether you’re after a full buffet or a quick bakery stop, this list covers a solid mix of well-established Holmes County area favorites. Most restaurants listed here offer classic Amish cooking—roast beef, noodles, fresh bread, and homemade pies—typically served in a casual, no-fuss setting.

They’re popular for a reason—good food, generous portions, friendly service, and a sense of place you won’t find just anywhere. If you’re spending time in Holmes County and want to experience local cooking done right, odds are you’ll do well with any of these spots.

Have you tried any of these places? Share your favorite dishes or experiences in the comments below!

See also:

• Lancaster County: 10 Amish-Style Restaurants For Your Next Visit
• Northern Indiana: 10 Amish Country Restaurants Not To Miss

~article compiled with AI assistance~

Get the Amish in your inbox

Join 15,000 email subscribers. No spam. 100% free

 

 

 

Subscribe