Northern Indiana: 10 Amish Country Restaurants Not To Miss
Northern Indiana – Elkhart and LaGrange Counties (along with nearby Nappanee) – is home to one of the largest Amish communities in the United States.
The area’s rich cultural heritage – with its heart in the town of Shipshewana – is reflected in its culinary offerings, with numerous restaurants serving traditional Amish and Pennsylvania Dutch cooking.
From hearty buffets to cozy family diner-style venues, these establishments provide authentic homestyle dishes that delights locals and visitors alike.
Here are 10 Amish-style restaurants worth visiting for an authentic taste of Northern Indiana Amish Country.
1. Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery – Shipshewana, IN
Located in the heart of Shipshewana, the Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery offers a delightful dining experience with its Amish-style cooking and over 25 varieties of pies. Guests can choose between buffet, family-style, or menu dining options, all served in a cozy atmosphere that reflects the area’s heritage.
The attached bakery tempts visitors with fresh bread, cookies, and other baked treats, making it a must-stop for dessert lovers. Live entertainment and musical performances are also hosted regularly in the adjacent Blue Gate Theatre.
- Style: Buffet, family-style, and menu
- Best For: Traditional Amish dishes and homemade pies
- Website: thebluegate.com/shipshewana/blue-gate-restaurant/
- Address: 105 E Middlebury St, Shipshewana, IN 46565
- Phone: (260) 768-4725
2. Das Dutchman Essenhaus – Middlebury, IN
As Indiana’s largest restaurant, Das Dutchman Essenhaus in Middlebury has been serving authentic Amish-style meals since 1971. Guests can enjoy family-style, buffet, or menu dining options, featuring dishes like broasted chicken, mashed potatoes with homemade gravy, and made-from-scratch pies.
Beyond the restaurant, the Essenhaus grounds include a bakery, inn, and quaint shops, perfect for a full-day visit. Car shows and seasonal festivals frequently take place, offering entertainment for all ages.
- Style: Family-style, buffet, and menu
- Best For: Large groups and traditional Amish fare
- Website: essenhaus.com/restaurant
- Address: 240 US-20, Middlebury, IN 46540
- Phone: (574) 825-9471
3. Tiffany’s Restaurant – Topeka, IN
Tiffany’s Restaurant in Topeka offers a cozy dining experience with a menu that includes classic Amish dishes. Known for its friendly service and homestyle cooking, it’s a favorite among locals (including the Amish) seeking comfort food in a welcoming environment. The portions are generous, and breakfast is especially popular with regulars.
- Style: Traditional menu
- Best For: Homestyle Amish meals
- Website: tiffanystopeka.com
- Address: 123 Main St, Topeka, IN 46571
- Phone: (260) 593-2988
4. Dutch Village Restaurant – Nappanee, IN
Dutch Village Restaurant is a favorite local spot offering hearty Amish-style meals in a warm, family-friendly setting. Known for its all-you-can-eat breakfast buffet, the restaurant features a variety of homestyle dishes and freshly baked pies. Guests can also enjoy a well-stocked salad bar and homemade bread.
- Style: Buffet and menu dining
- Best For: All-you-can-eat comfort food and homemade pies
- Website: facebook.com/dutchvillagerestaurant
- Address: 700 N Tomahawk Trail, Nappanee, IN 46550
- Phone: (574) 773-2828
5. Shipshewana Auction Restaurant – Shipshewana, IN
Located within the famous Shipshewana Auction & Flea Market, the Shipshewana Auction Restaurant offers a variety of sandwiches, salads, and comfort food. The casual setting and quick service make it ideal for a midday meal – and favorite of flea market shoppers and auction-goers alike. Their breakfast options are especially popular with early shoppers.
- Style: Traditional menu
- Best For: Quick and hearty meals during flea market visits
- Website: shipshewanatradingplace.com/restaurant/
- Address: 345 S Van Buren St, Shipshewana, IN 46565
- Phone: (260) 768-4129
6. Rise ‘n Roll Bakery & Deli – Middlebury, IN
Rise ‘n Roll Bakery & Deli in Middlebury is not a restaurant per se – but actually a beloved Amish-style bakery famous for its irresistible donuts—especially the signature cinnamon caramel variety. The deli also offers a range of freshly made sandwiches, soups, and salads, perfect for a quick and satisfying lunch.
Known for its clean, cheerful setting and friendly service, it’s a must-stop for travelers and locals alike. The shelves are also stocked with jams, jellies, and baked goods to take home.
- Style: Bakery and deli with casual counter service
- Best For: Famous donuts, quick lunches, and take-home treats
- Website: risenroll.com
- Address: 1065 N 1150 W, Middlebury, IN 46540
- Phone: (574) 825-4032
7. Village Inn Restaurant – Middlebury, IN
Located in Middlebury, the Village Inn Restaurant offers a cozy dining experience with a menu full of Amish favorites. Known for its friendly service and delicious meals, it’s a great spot for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. The homemade soups and daily specials are always crowd-pleasers. Dating to 1947, it’s long been a local staple.
- Style: Traditional menu
- Best For: Comfort food in a relaxed setting
- Website: thevillageinnmiddlebury.com
- Address: 107 S Main St, Middlebury, IN 46540
- Phone: (574) 825-2043
8. The Carriage House – Topeka, IN
The Carriage House in Topeka is an Amish “home meal” experience with a delightful menu featuring Amish-style dishes in a charming setting. Meals are served family-style and include Amish classics like baked chicken, meatloaf, noodles and gravy, Amish peanut butter spread, and an assortment of pies. Note: For groups only (12-150 people); reservations required.
- Style: Traditional menu
- Best For: Charming atmosphere and classic dishes
- Website: visitelkhartcounty.com/listing/the-carriage-house/226/
- Address: 5280 N 675 W, Topeka, IN 46571
- Phone: (260) 593-2988
9. Howie’s Six Mile Restaurant – LaGrange, IN
Howie’s Six Mile Restaurant situated on the highway between Shipshewana and LaGrange is a cozy, no-frills spot offering delicious Amish-style breakfasts and comfort food classics. It’s a favorite among locals for its hearty portions, freshly brewed coffee, and all-day breakfast.
- Style: Traditional menu
- Best For: Country-style breakfasts and casual, homestyle meals
- Website: N/A
- Address: 6725 N 675 W, LaGrange, IN 46761
- Phone: (260) 463-3241
10. Corn Crib Café – Shipshewana, IN
The Corn Crib Café in Shipshewana offers a selection of burgers, sandwiches, and Amish-style dishes like breakfast haystacks and pie. Known for its friendly service and delicious meals, it’s a great spot for a casual dining experience. Regulars love their daily specials and seasonal pies. It makes for a convenient stop for breakfast or lunch while exploring downtown.
- Style: Traditional menu
- Best For: Casual dining with homestyle meals
- Website: corncribcafe.com
- Address: 225 N Harrison St, Shipshewana, IN 46565
- Phone: (260) 768-7750
Final Thoughts
Northern Indiana’s Amish Country offers a range of dining options that reflect the area’s Amish and PA Dutch traditions and cultural heritage. Whether you’re in the mood for an all-you-can-eat buffet or a diner-style or family restaurant meal, these eateries provide authentic dining experiences that are sure to satisfy.
Have you visited any of these restaurants? Share your experiences and favorite dishes in the comments below!
See also:
- Holmes County: 10 Amish-Style Restaurants For A Great Meal
- Lancaster County: 10 Amish-Style Restaurants For Your Next Visit
~article compiled with AI assistance~
Amish Restraunts
My family and I have visited the Das Essenhouse many times through the years, and have never been disappointed, Excellant Food, and wonderful service, a very pleasant experience, you wont be sorry! Heads up folks they are a very busy restraunt!