The Amish & Crime

Stories about the Amish as victims – or perpetrators – of crime.

Fourth Man Arrested In Amish Home Invasion…And It’s An Amish Taxi Driver

Fourth Man Arrested In Amish Home Invasion…And It’s An Amish Taxi Driver

A man whom the Amish trusted – and paid – to drive them places was actually working against them. While he operated as an Amish taxi driver, his side occupation was allegedly helping criminals target some of those very same Amish homes for burglary. That’s according to new reports and allegations about a fourth man arrested in connection with the Geauga County, Ohio home invasion and assault case. From…

Four Years & $40,000: Twin Sister Sentenced For Crash Which Took Two Amish Girls’ Lives (Updated: Samantha Apologizes)

Four Years & $40,000: Twin Sister Sentenced For Crash Which Took Two Amish Girls’ Lives (Updated: Samantha Apologizes)

Samantha Jo Petersen’s sentence was delivered earlier today. Samantha pleaded guilty in July for her role in a September 2023 crash which killed two Amish girls in Fillmore County, Minnesota. Samantha was driving an SUV which rear-ended the buggy the girls were traveling in along with two other siblings. Irma Miller (11) and Wilma Miller (7) lost their lives that morning, while on their daily…

Caught: Two More Arrested In Amish Robbery & Assault Case (Ohio)

Caught: Two More Arrested In Amish Robbery & Assault Case (Ohio)

Looks like they got the rest of them. At yesterday’s press conference on the brutal home invasion and assault of an Amish man and his eight-year-old son, we learned that one of three suspects – a man named Bradford James Hosler – had been arrested. Geauga County, Ohio Sheriff Scott Hildenbrand stated then that “I feel very confident that within the next couple days the…

Amish Man & Young Son Assaulted, Tasered & Robbed In Brutal Home Invasion (Ohio)

Amish Man & Young Son Assaulted, Tasered & Robbed In Brutal Home Invasion (Ohio)

In a crime described as “appalling”, an Amish man and his son were assaulted by three assailants last Thursday, and the home robbed. The perpetrators threatened to kill the victims, and even attempted to abduct the eight-year-old boy. This happened in Middlefield Township in the Geauga County, Ohio Amish settlement. A blurb on this incident was released earlier today. The Geauga County Sheriff’s Department just…

Trial For Man Who Hit “Multiple” Amish Children Riding Bikes, Killing A 10-Year-Old Boy

Trial For Man Who Hit “Multiple” Amish Children Riding Bikes, Killing A 10-Year-Old Boy

This is one of the more gut-wrenching incidents you’ll come across leading to a young Amish person’s death. It happened last December. A 29-year-old Vicksburg, Michigan man drove his pickup into a group of Amish children who were headed to the local schoolhouse. It was said he “didn’t see the children.” From WZZM 13: Investigators say a group of four kids were riding their bikes…

Judge May Throw Out Samuel Hochstetler’s Confession In Murder Of Amish Woman Rosanna Kinsinger

Judge May Throw Out Samuel Hochstetler’s Confession In Murder Of Amish Woman Rosanna Kinsinger

This was not really reported on much at the time, but Samuel Hochstetler – charged with the murder of Amish woman Rosanna Kinsinger, who was found dead in her Ohio home in March – was back in court in late September. And apparently his legal team argued for his confession of the killing to be ruled inadmissible in the trial. This is being reported on…

Amish Mother Ruth Miller Denied Bail, Will Remain In Jail. But: Judge Leaves Door Open For Review

Amish Mother Ruth Miller Denied Bail, Will Remain In Jail. But: Judge Leaves Door Open For Review

Amish mother Ruth Miller, charged with aggravated murder in the death of her four-year-old son Vincen Miller along with related charges, had a bail hearing today at Tuscarawas County Common Pleas Court in New Philadelphia, Ohio. I had a chance to listen to parts of the hearing, which lasted nearly four hours. You can view the proceedings in full at the linked video at bottom….

Man Attempts To Abduct 9-Year-Old Amish Boy; Boy Escapes, Abductor Still At Large (UPDATE: Vehicle Photo Released)

Man Attempts To Abduct 9-Year-Old Amish Boy; Boy Escapes, Abductor Still At Large (UPDATE: Vehicle Photo Released)

This stomach-turning story is just appearing on news feeds. Yesterday, a young Amish boy apparently escaped an abduction attempt in Juniata County, Pennsylvania. The alleged abductor is still at large. More from ABC 27: JUNIATA COUNTY, Pa. (WHTM) — A boy in Juniata County was able to get away from a man who forced him into a vehicle on Tuesday, Pennsylvania State Police say. State…

Amish & Mennonite Investors Lose Big Yet Again – This Time, In Alleged $770 Million ATM Ponzi Scheme

Amish & Mennonite Investors Lose Big Yet Again – This Time, In Alleged $770 Million ATM Ponzi Scheme

It’s looking like Amish and Mennonite investors are once again victims in a big investment fraud case. It was reported last week that Lancaster County, PA businessman Daryl Heller is being charged by the US Department of Justice with multiple counts of fraud – for his role in an ATM investment operation being described as a Ponzi scheme. From the report at Reuters: A Pennsylvania man…

Amish Mother Ruth Miller Pleads Not Guilty By Reason Of Insanity (UPDATE: Attorney Speaks, Citing “Mental Defect”)

Amish Mother Ruth Miller Pleads Not Guilty By Reason Of Insanity (UPDATE: Attorney Speaks, Citing “Mental Defect”)

Holmes County, Ohio Amish mother Ruth Miller had her arraignment this afternoon in Tuscarawas Common Pleas Court. Miller is charged with aggravated murder, among other charges, in the death of her four-year-old son Vincen Miller at Atwood Lake. There are a couple of pieces of news emerging from the events of the day – the main one being that, as expected, Miller has pleaded not…