16 Things I Never Expected To See While Taking Photos In Amish Country

Blue water slide on a backyard pond with Amish buggies parked by a red barn near Shipshewana, Indiana
A water slide, a pond and buggies parked by the barn at an Amish home near Shipshewana, Indiana. All photos this post by Don Burke.

Don Burke is back today with a look at the more surprising sides of Amish Country – after 16+ years of visiting dozens of Amish settlements across America.

Maybe you’ve seen similar scenes while visiting Amish communities and wondered, “What’s going on there?” Don might just have an explanation for what you saw…


June 14, 2010 – That was the day that I first set foot in Amish country, that I had my first Amish buggy ride, and that I first met and even had a full conversation with an Amish person.

As we (my wife and I) have explained elsewhere, I was initially just along as the chauffeur and the half-interested photographer – but all that would change over the coming days, months and years.

And in the almost-17 years since then, I’ve covered a lot of ground – not just in the number of Amish places I have visited, but more so in all that I’ve observed and experienced. And beginning as a total newbie, I have certainly encountered my share of the unexpected along the way. This post is to share some of the most notable of those surprises with you.

Please note that in the stories shared below, some of the Amish visits I made with my wife and others I explored on my own. This explains the jumping back-and-forth between “I” and “we” from story to story.

So, in no particular order, here are some stories and pictures of my most notable unexpected encounters from my adventures into the Amish world.

1. Very First Amish Picture

Amish sisters with a visitor in a buggy after a buggy ride in Holmes County, Ohio
Holmes County, Ohio (2010)

Speaking of June 14, 2010, our first Amish buggy ride (when this picture was taken), was conducted by the very capable Sarah and her little sister. While the opportunity for such a ride was exciting, one of the most unexpected parts of that experience was when we returned to Sarah’s home.

Her father met us as we came up the driveway, and some of his first words to us were, “Would you like to take a picture of my daughters?” This absolutely shattered what we had been told before that all Amish avoid having their picture taken.

So, ever since that very first day and when that question was the very first words from the very first Amish man I ever spoke with…, I pretty well know that anyone who makes a blanket criticism like, “The Amish don’t want their picture taken,” well, they obviously don’t speak for all Amish.

2. The Amish and Walmart Accommodations

Walmart parking lot in Millersburg, Ohio with a covered buggy shelter at the side of the store
Millersburg, Holmes County, Ohio (2010)
Covered buggy parking with a horse and buggy and wheelbarrow at a Walmart in Holmes County, Ohio
Millersburg, Holmes County, Ohio (2010)

Before leaving Millersburg (Holmes Co.) the morning after our first buggy ride (above), we needed to make a Walmart stop.

And what we saw to the (right) side of the store was certainly unexpected – a semi-enclosed covered parking area for the Amish and their buggies. (The accompanying wheelbarrows with shovels seem to indicate an expectation that each owner would self-service any deposits their horses happened to make while waiting.)

3. Amish Driving Cars?

Pickup truck parked beside a barn at an Amish home in Shipshewana, Indiana
Shipshewana, Indiana (2014)

While out seeing the sights around Shipshewana we happened across a home place that was clearly Amish. (Not many English have a church bench wagon parked beside their barn in full view of passing traffic.)

But what really caught my attention was the 4×4 extended-cab pickup parked in the driveway. At first we just wrote it off as possibly someone visiting the family. But as we were describing it to our host later, she explained that it very well could have belonged to an Amish teen who was old enough to get a driver’s license but had not yet joined the church.

We later experienced something very similar as we were staying with some Amish friends in Mt. Hope (Holmes Co.), OH, and discovered a car in the driveway they had just purchased for one of their children who was in that same age bracket.

Car parked in the driveway of an Amish home in Mount Hope, Ohio
Mount Hope, Holmes County, Ohio (2016)

4. The Cookstove Moved to an Outdoor Porch during the Summer Months

Cookstove set up on the back porch of an Amish home in the Spickard-Princeton, Missouri settlement
Spickard-Princeton, Missouri (2014)

In the final tally, this falls under the category of smart thinking – but you only get to that point after first wrestling with the question of what’s wrong with this picture? I’ve seen this occur in at least three Amish communities (Summersville and Spickard-Princeton, MO, and Ethridge, TN).

Amish home with a cookstove on the porch in Ethridge, Tennessee
Ethridge, Tennessee (2016)

Specifically, it is the occasional Amish family that moves the kitchen cookstove outside to the porch (either front or back) during the hot summer months. When you live in a house without air conditioning and little or no fans, who wants to add the heat from a cookstove to the breezeless stuffiness of a house already baking in the summer sun?

Closer view of a cookstove on the porch of an Amish home in Ethridge, Tennessee
Ethridge, Tennessee (2016)

At least out on the porch the heat isn’t trapped in a confined space, plus there is the chance of catching a passing breeze. So yeah, it makes sense…, once you get over the initial shock of it.

5. Tractor-Driving Amish

I was on a road trip and realized that by adding a few miles I could make a passing visit through a few Kansas and Oklahoma Amish settlements. I had seen tractors used by some Amish (Holmes Co.) for incidental farm-related chores.

But I wasn’t prepared for what I saw as I drove into Garnett, KS – where I discovered my very first group of Amish who drive tractors as their default daily transportation. (I later encountered similar tractor-driving communities in West Plains and Mountain Grove, MO, as well.)

Amish tractor parked in a shed beside buggies in Garnett, Kansas
Garnett, Kansas (2015)
Amish tractor pulling an enclosed trailer in Garnett, Kansas
Garnett, Kansas (2015)

And here apparently it wasn’t just the farmers who used them, but everyone, regardless of their occupation. I have heard that this community still uses horse and buggy transportation for Sunday church attendance, but otherwise it appears tractors are the means of travel.

Tractor and buggy parked in a shed at an Amish home in West Plains, Missouri
West Plains, Missouri (2016)
Amish man driving a tractor in Mountain Grove, Missouri
Mountain Grove, Missouri (2016)

During the cooler months the tractors are even fitted with skirts to direct warm air from the engine back to the open-air tractor seat area. And some are fitted with carriers attached to the back hitch, which function much like the bed of a pickup.

Amish tractor pulling a trailer in Mountain Grove, Missouri
Mountain Grove, Missouri (2016)

6. Home Places

Okay, the Amish are people, and people (as a rule) live in houses – nothing unexpected about that. And over my many visits to Amish country I’ve seen a wide variety of homes and properties where the Amish live. But what I found unexpected was a couple of the more extreme examples on that spectrum.

Pond with a water slide and a red barn with buggies at an Amish home near Shipshewana, Indiana
Shipshewana, Indiana (2014)
Red barn with buggies and a basketball hoop at an Amish home near Shipshewana, Indiana
Shipshewana, Indiana (2014)

The first picture is from Shipshewana. While this image doesn’t show the house itself so well, it does show part of what seems to be a very large and fancy swimming area with quite the eye-catching barn in the background.

Sure, I know the Amish have pools and barns, but for a people known for distancing themselves from the fancy, I was not expecting quite this level of eye-appeal from their immediate surroundings.

Plain Swiss Amish home with laundry hanging on the porch in Seymour, Missouri
Seymour, Missouri (2014)

The second home place, located in Seymour, reflected to a great degree that community as a whole. Lancaster Co. is known for large farms that are well kept, and other communities sport well maintained homes with equally maintained flower gardens and yards. But this looked quite the opposite – and even looked as if it may have been intentionally so.

I found out later that this is a Swiss Amish group (reportedly the largest in the US) which can tend towards stricter, more austere living. Others mentioned that some communities (like this?) wear their appearance of near-poverty as a supposed sign of being spiritually and not worldly minded.

But whatever the reason, after seeing many other maintained Amish homes, this was a bit of a surprise.

7. Three-Tab Shingles Used for House Siding

Amish house covered in shingle siding with a windmill in Seymour, Missouri
Seymour, Missouri (2014)
Porch of an Amish home with three-tab shingles used as siding in Seymour, Missouri
Seymour, Missouri (2014)

While on the subject of houses, there is another characteristic of certain Amish dwellings I was not expecting to see.

Most notably found in the just-mentioned Seymour settlement, and to a lesser extent in the Parsons, KS, community, what I found so surprising was their use of three-tab (roofing) shingles – and even rolled roofing – to cover the sides of their houses and other buildings. And even years later I still find this quite odd.

Three-tab roofing shingles used as house siding on an Amish home in Seymour, Missouri
Seymour, Missouri (2014)
Rolled roofing and shingles covering the walls of an Amish home in Seymour, Missouri
Seymour, Missouri (2014)

And as a secondary unexpected item, in researching this I just discovered one reason behind the similarity between these two communities: According to online sources, the Swiss Amish settlement in Parsons is actually a 2006 daughter community of Seymour.

8. Cold Storage

Having toured through an Amish house early in my exploration into the Amish, I knew that at least some used propane or other gas-powered refrigerators. But it never occurred to me that there might be other options – until I discovered these.

Foam-insulated ice house beside an Amish home in Clark, Missouri
Ice house – Clark, Missouri (2014)
Concrete ice house behind the garden of an Amish home in the Anabel-Tenmile, Missouri settlement
Ice house – Anabel-Tenmile, Missouri (2014)

Ice Houses have a long history, at least in the cooler latitudes. But in my mind they were relics of a bygone era, along with vacuum tubes and the vintage penny-farthing bicycle.

But apparently it is not, at least among the Amish, as I have surprisingly seen them in at least the three communities of Clark, Anabel-Tenmile and Greentop-Queen City, MO.

Concrete ice house with a wooden door in the Anabel-Tenmile, Missouri Amish settlement
Ice house – Anabel-Tenmile, Missouri (2014)
Block ice house beside an Amish home in the Greentop-Queen City, Missouri settlement
Ice house – Greentop-Queen City, Missouri (2014)

Refrigeration Stations were the greater surprise. I’ve seen what appear to be such stations in Seymour, Clark and Kahoka, MO; Parsons, KS; plus hints of something similar in Shipshewana, IN, and Mt. Hope (Holmes Co.), OH.

The way I understand it, the small building, the refrigeration units within it, and the public-grid electricity to power them are all bought or provided by the English.

Block refrigeration station with outdoor compressor units in the Clark, Missouri Amish community
Refrigeration station – Clark, Missouri (2014)
Refrigeration station building marked Station 1 in the snow at Kahoka, Missouri
Refrigeration station – Kahoka, Missouri (2015)

Then (if their Ordnung allows), the Amish are able to rent refrigerated space from the English owners. At times neighbors might go in together and divide up an allotted space between them.

Refrigeration station building used by Amish families in Parsons, Kansas
Refrigeration station – Parsons, Kansas (2015)
Block refrigeration station on a dirt road in Seymour, Missouri
Refrigeration station – Seymour, Missouri (2014)

However, I speculate that the Seymour community may be structured slightly differently, because at least some refrigeration is not strictly for personal use.

Milk production among the Amish here seems fairly common, as evidenced by the number of milk pails I’ve seen transported around the community. And since milk needs to be kept cool until picked up by milk trucks, it is brought to such a station – sometimes called a milk station or milk house.

So I speculate that the milk companies may foot the bill to provide the refrigeration to keep their milk cool.

9. Milk Carriers

Amish buggy with a box attached to the back for carrying milk in Seymour, Missouri
Seymour, Missouri (2014)

Before moving on, while milk containers in Seymour were seen transported by various wagons and even hand carts, this unique approach to moving milk (pictured here delivered to a milk/refrigeration station) is a specialized box attached to the back of an Amish buggy. Didn’t exactly see that one coming.

10. An Outdoor Water Heater

Wood-burning outdoor water heater beside an Amish building in Seymour, Missouri
Wood-burning water heater – Seymour, Missouri (2014)
Outdoor water heater and milk tank behind an Amish home in Clark, Missouri
Wood-burning water heater – Clark, Missouri (2014)

In our grandmothers’ or great-grandmothers’ day they would heat smaller quantities of water on the kitchen stove. Larger volumes of water would possibly be heated in the fireplace or over an outdoor fire.

Stainless steel wood-burning water heater beside a bulk milk tank in Clark, Missouri
Wood-burning water heater – Clark, Missouri (2014)

Well, lacking modern water heaters, it seems at least some Amish are still connected with warming water in the great outdoors – but with a modern twist.

Outdoor water heater on the porch of an Amish home in Ethridge, Tennessee
Wood-burning water heater – Ethridge, Tennessee (2016)

In at least four communities (Clark, Seymour and Spickard-Princeton, MO; Ethridge, TN) I’ve seen a giant kettle, resembling an oversized stock pot, designed for this purpose – with an enclosed area for water to be warmed, plus a built-in chamber underneath for burning wood.

Stainless steel wood-burning water heater on an Amish porch in Ethridge, Tennessee
Wood-burning water heater – Ethridge, Tennessee (2016)
Gas-burning outdoor water heater in a snowy Amish farmyard in Kahoka, Missouri
Gas-burning water heater – Kahoka, Missouri (2015)

In two other settlements (Kahoka and La Plata, MO) I’ve seen similar apparatuses, but which appear to burn some form of gas (e.g., propane or natural gas).

Stainless steel gas-burning water heater beside an Amish home in Kahoka, Missouri
Gas-burning water heater – Kahoka, Missouri (2015)
Gas-burning outdoor water heater at an Amish home in La Plata, Missouri
Gas-burning water heater – La Plata, Missouri (2014)

11. Breaker Box and (Covered) Light Switch Boxes

Mary, a personal friend as well as guide for individual and group tours through her Amish home, had a new house built about a decade ago. On a subsequent visit to Jamesport we were invited to see her new place.

This may be the first Amish home (which of course are not hooked up to the electric grid) that I have seen with an electric breaker box.

Electric breaker box in an Amish home in Jamesport, Missouri
Jamesport, Missouri (2018)

And also surprising were the installed electrical boxes for light switches and outlets (although they were covered).

It appears that anticipating that she or her family may one day sell the house or have it used by non-Amish family or friends, during construction they had the house fully wired to make it easier to convert later.

Covered light switch box beside a door in an Amish home in Jamesport, Missouri
Jamesport, Missouri (2018)

12. An Amish Business with Electric Lights, an Operating Air Conditioner, Electric Machinery, and Electric Office Equipment

While on the subject of the Amish and electricity…. In 2014 I decided to take a couple days and make a road trip to Amish communities in the neighboring states of Illinois and Kentucky.

With little more than the names of towns with Amish settlements and a full tank of gas, I set off and soon found myself in Ava, IL. Fumbling my way through the community I soon noticed a business named Millers specializing in homestyle jellies, and thought that sounded like it could be Amish so I decided to stop.

Millers Country Crafts sign for homestyle jams and jellies in Ava, Illinois
Ava, Illinois (2014)

But driving up the driveway I noticed an air conditioner unit positioned against the outside wall.

Air conditioner unit outside the New Order Amish business Millers Country Crafts in Ava, Illinois
Ava, Illinois (2014)

And after stepping indoors the surprise grew as I also noticed lights, production equipment and office machines – all driven by power-grid electricity. Surely I had guessed wrong – there was no way this could be Amish. But as I talked with the owners I found out they were indeed Amish – New Order Amish!

Electric lights and production equipment inside a New Order Amish jelly business in Ava, Illinois
Ava, Illinois (2014)
Office with an electric typewriter at a New Order Amish business in Ava, Illinois
Ava, Illinois (2014)

So, one stop with three elements I did not anticipate: Amish with AC, my first (and very pleasant) encounter with New Order Amish, and a very tasty third surprise: Elderberry jelly (one of many flavors made there) is really good!

13. Amish Teens Drag Racing

Two Amish buggies side by side on a curving road after Thanksgiving church in Clark, Missouri
Clark, Missouri (2014)
Two Amish buggies racing side by side toward a red barn in Clark, Missouri
Clark, Missouri (2014)

Here’s an experience that underscores the fact that, unsurprisingly, people will just be people, often regardless of their culture.

Yes, I was once a teenager. And just in case my mom happens to read this, I won’t go on record about any risky driving I may or may not have done at that age – but I certainly had ~friends~ who did. So I am not at all surprised when I see two teen boys drag racing their vehicles down the highway.

But when that race occurs between Amish teens, in buggies, when leaving Thanksgiving Day church service – it may be a jolt about our common humanness, but it’s an unexpected jolt nonetheless.

14. Amish with a Fishing Boat

Aluminum fishing boat on a trailer in front of an Amish buggy near Shipshewana, Indiana
Shipshewana, Indiana (2014)

This one is also a bit of a jolt, coming from an initial sense that two worlds you are familiar with don’t connect together – only to quickly realize they do.

Maybe it’s because I’ve always connected fishing with being laid back, and even at times laziness, that it seems so counter to the industriousness we associate with the Amish. And yet, even the most industrious person needs to take a break from it all from time to time.

Fishing boat on a wagon beside a garden on an Amish farm in Ethridge, Tennessee
Ethridge, Tennessee (2016)

15. Ghost Town School

Abandoned Crockett Community Center school building in a former Amish settlement at Rector, Arkansas
Rector, Arkansas (2014)

This picture and its story were also included in my post about favorite Amish pictures. But as much as it is a favorite, it was equally as much a surprise.

When you pull into a place expecting to discover a new-to-you Amish community but only discover no one lives there any more – yep, that’s an unexpected find for sure!

Another view of the abandoned school in the former Amish community at Rector, Arkansas
Rector, Arkansas (2014)

16. Disco Ball in an Amish Store

Boxed rotating disco balls on a shelf in an Amish variety store in Berne, Indiana
Berne, Indiana (2014)

Sometimes it’s the simplest of things that, although not all that impacting in the grand scheme of things, catch us the most unexpectedly – and make the bigger splash for it.

We were visiting in the conservative-leaning Swiss community of Berne, in a small-ish variety store run by an Amish woman who had an air of being quite conservative even among her peers. Lo and behold if I didn’t unexpectedly find among her merchandise a toy version of that which symbolizes a whole world of anything but conservatism.

Maybe my mind is just too imaginative, but the thoughts of Mrs. Straight-Lace Shop-Keeper and the equally strict Mr. Shop-Keeper pulling the blinds at closing time, setting up the disco glitter ball and cranking the volume all the way up on their not-bishop-approved transistor radio, and boogying down to, You Should Be Dancing, Yeah! – it was all just a bit too much for me and my imagination!

More from Don

 

Get the Amish in your inbox

Join 15,000 email subscribers. No spam. 100% free

 
 
 

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

2 Comments

  1. Denise

    Amish Surprises

    My favorite unusual item is the water slide into the pond. They even have a pool ladder. What fun on a hot summer day. Thanks, Don.

    1. Thanks Denise, so glad you enjoyed it.