Mom Of 3 Killed On Cruise Ship Had Fled A New York Amish Community As A Teen

Split image of Susan Watford smiling in a dark top and hoop earrings beside a white Amish farmhouse with a black buggy parked on the lawn in New York
Susan Watford, a mother of 3 killed aboard a cruise ship out of Galveston, Texas, had fled a New York Amish community as a teen. Right: file photo of an Amish home in New York, not her family’s. Images: GoFundMe; CP Thornton/flickr

You have likely already heard about the young mother killed aboard a cruise ship that sailed out of Galveston, Texas earlier this month. It made national news and has been covered widely. It’s a disturbing story, and the woman’s husband has been charged with her murder.

One of the attention-getting aspects of the case is the woman’s origin. According to reports, she grew up Amish before leaving in her teenage years. Susan Watford, 31, a mother of three, was raised in an Amish community in New York, and ran away from home as a young teen.

Briefly, in case you aren’t up to speed on the details: a man named Jason Leon Watford, 48, of Tyler, Texas, faces a federal murder charge in her death aboard the MSC Seascape on the night of November 8. From the Associated Press:

A cruise ship passenger accused of killing his wife after the vessel set off from Texas told authorities that he struck her in their cabin and strangled her after an argument caused him to “snap,” according to an FBI affidavit made public Tuesday.

A child was in the cabin and was found unharmed. According to the Houston Chronicle, the couple had boarded with their 1-year-old daughter, who is now in foster care. The Galveston County medical examiner gave Susan Watford’s cause of death as blunt force trauma.

On Monday, Jason Watford waived his right to a probable cause hearing, according to the Galveston Daily News. Watford remains in federal custody. Prosecutors told the court he faces a possible sentence of life in prison or death if convicted. The case now heads to a federal grand jury.

Susan Watford’s Amish Background

Susan Watford’s original surname was very likely Wengerd. She left her home community at a rather young age, especially for an Amish girl. You more typically hear about this happening, when it does, in the later teen years. From the Houston Chronicle:

Watford’s friends and family said she grew up in an Amish community in New York and ran away when she was 13 or 14 years old.

She boarded a U-Haul headed for Missouri and eventually settled into a foster home through a Christian program called Coyote Hill Foster Care Ministries, based in the small town of Harrisburg.

A former foster parent, Charlie Marshman, told the Chronicle she started her studies at Coyote Hill from an eighth-grade level and earned her GED in six months. “She was just an incredible human,” he said. “Like she would help anybody and everybody. And she was so smart. So, so smart.”

Accounts of her age at leaving differ slightly. Her adoptive mother, Dorothy Mast, told KPRC that she adopted Susan after she left the Amish community at 15. Mast is also a surname common among the Amish.

The Daily Mail gives her birth name as Susan Wengred, very likely the common Amish surname Wengerd. The Daily Mail spoke with Christian Yoder, an adoptive cousin who has known her since she arrived in Missouri.

Now, the Daily Mail has a tendency to sensationalize, but this is an on-the-record quote from a named family member. He said that as a teenager, Susan told him about growing up in an Amish community in New York and why she left:

‘She grew up in a very abusive home, that’s what she was running away from… her dad did not treat her very well when she was growing up,’ he said.

‘But she never escaped it… it’s what ended up killing her.’

No report I’ve seen has named the New York community she came from.

Abuse In Her Adult Life

Looking at the different accounts out there, abuse sadly seems to have remained a part of her life – including her own guilty plea over injuries caused to her own children.

From Missouri, Watford eventually moved to Texas, where she was raising three children, ages 1, 9 and 14, according to the Chronicle. She worked as a warehouse team lead at Target and earned a business degree through Colorado Technical University’s online program.

However, her life in Texas included her own trouble with the law. The Chronicle found that a Susan Watford was charged in Smith County with injury to a child, though county officials denied its request for the case records.

The Daily Mail, citing charging documents, reports that one of her children called police in February 2023 to report that she had hit him with an extension cord. According to the affidavit, she admitted to a Child Protective Services investigator that she had hit her two older children “approximately 25-30 times,” and “both children showed extensive bruising, and they had open wounds as well.”

She was charged in March 2024 with two counts of felony injury to a child and pleaded guilty to one, later receiving a sentence of 10 years of probation and 600 hours of community service.

Her family disputes that she was responsible. Yoder told the Daily Mail it “makes a lot more sense that she was covering for someone else.”

Jason Watford’s own record goes back decades. According to People, he was convicted of attempted murder in Illinois in 1996 and sentenced to 10 years in prison.

In September 2024, he was arrested at the couple’s Tyler home after an argument about money. According to the Chronicle, he charged at her and forcibly grabbed her by the wrist, and she used a Taser on him to get away. Both of them told law enforcement that he had been abusive in the past.

He pleaded guilty to assault of a family member and was placed on probation. He completed that in February 2026, about nine months before the cruise, according to the Galveston Daily News. Susan’s mother told KPRC that her daughter had decided to give him another chance:

Two years ago, she survived a domestic violence incident involving her husband, Jason. Rather than walking away, Susan committed to studying domestic violence and narcissistic abuse, and was giving Jason another chance.

“As she told me, ‘Mama, he did everything the court said he had to do. He took his anger management classes. He did his counseling. He did his community service,'” Mast recalled.

Susan hoped the cruise would either repair the marriage or help her move toward a divorce. Mast had asked her not to go. That is a haunting thought no doubt for those who knew her.

A very sad story and one which seems to have a through-line leading to a tragic end for this young woman. Jason Watford remains in federal custody as prosecutors prepare to take the case to a grand jury.

 

Get the Amish in your inbox

Join 15,000 email subscribers. No spam. 100% free

 
 
 

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *