Amish Cook Gloria Yoder On The Hochstetler Shooting

Last week we learned the tragic story of Jonathan and Wilma Hochstetler, a Mennonite couple shot in a late-night robbery in Indianapolis, with Wilma losing her life. Jonathan happens to be a cousin to Amish Cook columnist Gloria Yoder – the oldest cousin of 47 on her father’s side, as she describes him. In this week’s column, Gloria gives more details on the shooting, Jonathan’s condition, and Wilma’s funeral.

First, more details on what actually happened:

As the day wore on, we gathered bits of information. Along with their 6-year-old son, Jonathan and his wife were in Indianapolis, working on fixing trailer lights across the street from a filling station when two armed men stepped up and asked for their money, which Jonathan handed over.

According to surveillance cameras nearby, the robbers each shot at the couple, as Jonathan and Wilma raised their hands in surrender. Wilma was instantly killed. Jonathan recalls crying out to God to at least spare one of them for the sake of their four children.

Young Braden later reported that he jumped out of the truck after the shooting and went over to Mom, asking if she was OK; when she could not respond, he tried to get Dad to respond, who was only semi-conscious. After about 20 minutes, with great efforts due to his injuries and blood loss, Jonathan made his way to the pickup and asked little Braden to give him the phone and dialed 911 to ask for help.

An unexplained detail:

Jonathan reports having called the police, but according to his phone, there never was an actual phone call made. Did God make that connection when Jonathan was physically not able to make the simple call?

On Jonathan’s condition:

Now today, eight days later, Jonathan came home from the hospital. He suffered various neck injuries, including three fractured vertebrae, which they fused. Despite it all, he seems to be healing faster than the doctor expected him to, for which we praise God. Tomorrow and the day after will be visitation and funeral for Wilma.

Jonathan’s forgiveness:

My constant cry to God is that He can do his profound work in each of our hearts during this traumatic time. Only God can heal broken hearts, and although Jonathan is completely crushed and devastated, he does not hold it against the robbers for shooting his wife.

Jonathan has forgiven them, which must truly be only because of the power of Jesus! His heartfelt longing is not for them to receive a harsh punishment, but that they can fall before the Lord in repentance and be saved. His testimony of having forgiven those who killed the love of his life, challenges me to love and forgive, no matter what.

The funeral:

OK, this is Saturday afternoon now. We just got back from the funeral. In the funeral sermon we were challenged to deeply search our hearts and our willingness to completely follow what is taught in the Bible, so that when our life on earth has ended, that our soul can be Jesus, forever free and at rest.

There were 1,100 people attending the funeral. It was saddening to see those dear young girls, ages 9, 12, and 16, and young Braden with no mother. My heart felt crushed anew as I looked at a picture they had posted of Jonathan and Wilma at a little table enjoying a date together. Never again will it happen.

The funeral, which was held September 26th, was made available online. You can view it here:

And this from Gloria:

Family, friends — all are in shock — yet God is undeniably bigger than it all. God certainly does not ask us to understand it all, yet we see the trace of his hand through it all.

The column in full.

WTHR also reports on the story, with comments from Jonathan after being released from the hospital last week.

“It grazed my spine,” Jonathan said, sitting in a wheelchair and wearing a neck brace after being discharged from the hospital. “I should be paralyzed. I should be dead. I believe it’s a miracle, a miracle from God. I just thank God for that.”

Jonathan and Wilma Hochstetler were working on a broken-down trailer a week ago at a roofing jobsite at 37th Street and High School Road on the west side of Indianapolis when they were robbed by two men with guns.

“Next thing that I know, my wife is falling beside me,” Jonathan said, his voice trembling.

He believes he could identify at least one of the shooters. The family says the incident was captured on video by a security video. Indianapolis Metropolitan Police have released no suspect information.

“Not that them being jailed or in prison for a long time is going to change anything for me or Wilma or my family, but they’re going to do this again,” Jonathan said.

Jonathan left Eskenazi one week after he was shot. He underwent surgery to fuse three vertebrae in his neck. Another surgery repaired his jaw and mouth. He was on a feeding tube for several days but now can swallow soft foods. Doctors expect a full recovery.

Jonathan is going home to Bloomfield just in time for his wife’s funeral.

“I took her for granted way too many times,” Jonathan said. “She was a wonderful wife. She was an amazing soulmate.”

The family is offering a $50,000 reward:

Now, the family is offering a reward of $50,000 for “information leading to the arrest and prosecution of the perpetrator or perpetrators in the murder of Wilma Hochstetler.”

For more details on the reward and updates from the family, visit their Facebook page.

If you have information to report, call the Indianapolis Homicide Division at 317-327-3475. To report information anonymously, contact Crime Stoppers at 317-262-TIPS.

Finally, Jonathan’s father Sam had these comments for the Indianapolis Star, on his 6-year-old grandson who witnessed the shooting:

“He said ‘I wish they didn’t shoot my mommy’ as soon as he got home,” Sam Hochstetler said. “(But I think) he is still oblivious to what happened.”

“My heart just burns for my son,” Sam Hochstetler said. “He got shot, and he knows his wife is dead.”

Get the Amish in your inbox

Join 15,000 email subscribers. No spam. 100% free

    Similar Posts

    Leave a Reply to Mary L Cook Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


    1. Mary L Cook

      So very very sorry for your loss. May God wrap his arms around the family and comfort them. Strengthen them to honor the memory of the mother. May God make a noise in the gunmen heart to confess and turn themselves in.

    2. Geo


      The ability to forgive such evil truly surpasses all understanding. I could not do it myself. I’d have to leave it to God’s grace to forgive them. Being only human, I could not.

    3. Lowell Shaw

      Our sympathies

      Our sympathies are with you and your family at this time. A terrible loss for the children, husband and all those she touched and would have.
      – Lowell and Lucille Shaw

    4. Jean Pierre

      Bien chers tous

      I am deeply moved and constantly listen to the hymns recorded on the video
      As a neighbor of the Hochstetter ancestors’ farm in Alsace, I send my most sincere condolences to the family and the community once again painfully struck.

      Where sin abounds, grace abounds

      I shudder when I invoke the fidelity of God, this God who acts and who does not forget any of his promises

      May his love, his peace and his joy embrace those who are in pain.

      God forgives but he will never hold the guilty, even repentant, to be innocent.

      Translation FR/USA Googel

    5. Martha Cable

      What happened to an eye for an eye? These beings who wantonly murdered and tried to murder both are truly demons who belong in hell. They WILL do it again as they have no conscious or morals, so why should they be shown forgiveness and mercy? That they took a life matters not one iota to them.

    6. Paul J Miller

      Permission to cite article for information

      I would like permission to quote or summarize part of your October 1 news reports of the Jonathan Hochstetler shooting, Indianapolis, Ind., in a brief article in an upcoming issue of the Jacob Hochstetler Family Association Newsletter. Please reply at your earliest convenience.

      Paul J. Miller, Editor
      Jacob Hochstetler Family Association Newsletter
      618 S Vine St
      Orrville, OH 44667
      ph: 330-683-0596