Ex-Amish Army Veteran Recalls His Excommunication A Half-Century Ago

“You’re supposed to defend yourself if you’ve been aggressed upon.”

That’s what Ora Hochstetler, now 82, says in his own defense, a half-century after his excommunication from the Amish church.

He likens it to a famous battle from Scripture:

“Kind of like David and Goliath. I don’t believe in just going out and boom, kill somebody, but if I’m aggressed upon, I believe in defending myself.”

Ora served in Germany as an army medic in the early 1960s, after being drafted at age 25, as reported in a profile in the Warren, OH Tribune Chronicle. This was followed by several more years in the reserves.

He mainly helped people coming in with injuries – “work[ing] on anything life threatening to prevent the soldier from dying.”

Hochstetler said others from his area served, including his younger brother.

However, he was the only one excommunicated (placed in the Bann), since he was the only one of the group that had been baptized at the time.

Amish eventually had alternative service programs that they could opt into rather than entering the military, such as service in urban hospitals as orderlies.

However it’s likely that these did not become a viable option until later (the Amish Steering Committee, which represented Amish interests in this matter, was not organized until 1966), meaning Hochstetler likely did not have an alternative service option as readily available to him.

Hochstetler eventually decided returning to the Amish was not for him:

If he wanted to, Hochstetler could’ve gone back to his Amish ways and worked his way back into the community. He consulted with a pastor about what to do and was told that “it doesn’t matter what they say. It’s between you and God. When the day comes, you stand before the Lord.”

Hochstetler said the hierarchy consisted of Old Order Amish and when he was married in 1965 and settled into his home, he decided to not go back to his community. He was baptized into a new faith and said he became free.

Hochstetler wishes his family saw things differently but doesn’t regret serving his country:

To this day, Hochstetler said he wishes his family could see the sacrifices he and the other soldiers made for this country. He also wishes everyone could see how important the soldiers’ sacrifices are.

“Enjoy your freedom and respect those that defend that freedom. I would go again if I was younger, but I’m a little past the age now,” he said.

Read more on the Amish and non-resistance and military conscription.

Get the Amish in your inbox

Join 15,000 email subscribers. No spam. 100% free

    Similar Posts

    Leave a Reply to Geo Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


    1. Joseph Costa

      Ex-Amish Army Veteran.

      Jesus does not judge you nor should anyone else. Thank You for your service to this country. The Amish lost not you. Jesus says for man not to judge. And sorry those in the Amish Community did that, so its their loss. Jesus loves you and let no one tell you different.

    2. andreas Ost

      slew not kill

      David did NOT KILL Goliath, he slew him. slay/slew meant take a life of an ox, chicken, enemy,convicted felon. all okay with G-d & scripture. In KJ English “kill” meant to murder (that word was not in language then), to take a like illegally &/or unjustly. One has to always keep in mind , that word meanings have changed & think thusly. Currently we do not murder chickens or enemies.

    3. Geo

      slayed a slew

      I wonder just how big was this Goliath guy and was he a one of a kind mutant or one of a race of giants? If Goliath had family and friends, David must of slayed the whole slew because there ain’t no more. Just sayin.

    4. Good Man

      Although I am not Amish and have a son who served 7 years in the USMC in Iraq I feel this fellow served both his nation & his creator by his sacrifices. God Bless him for many more days. Dan Gadd

    5. Debbie

      A Good Man

      God bless this soldier, and I’d like to thank him for his service.

    6. Al in Ky

      Thanks for including the links to “Amish and non-resistance” and “military conscription”. It was helpful to read those articles, as well as the newspaper article from the Warren, OH Tribune Chronicle to better understand this situation.

      1. Glad those were useful, Al. I’d also recommend Marc Olshan’s chapter on the National Amish Steering Committee in The Amish and the State, for those interested.