Goot Essa: Buy Amish Cheese Direct Online

Goot Essa is an Amish business in Centre County, PA that sells 19 types of cheeses. Though this is a traditional Amish dairy – and not in the Lancaster County area – they’ve built a nice reach into some upscale markets. Prior to the lockdown, they were selling their offerings to hundreds of East Coast restaurants, upscale food shops, and wineries, reports the Centre Daily Times.

The business actually sells the cheeses made from the milk of five Amish farms – one traditional cow dairy, three sheep dairies, and one producing goat’s milk. Their story as they tell it, in brief:

Goot Essa began in 2001 with a group of Amish dairy farmers who worked together to produce high quality cheese with some of their milk. We have chosen to work our fields in the traditional way. Our goal is to offer products made from the freshest, highest quality, all natural ingredients. We want you to experience food straight from the farm.

The Esh family farm. Image via Goot Essa

But the lockdown accompanying the virus immediately disrupted their business. Founder John Esh Jr. quickly realized he had to find a new approach:

“It was like someone hit a switch and things changed rapidly. Restaurants were forced to shut down. Wineries were forced to shut down,” he said. Within a few weeks, he and his family knew they needed to adapt and pivot their business focus. “At that point, we were like, OK, let’s come up with a plan that will keep the business afloat, thinking that, by August, surely things would be back to normal.”

That new approach was to open an online retail store to sell directly to individual customers. Esh did not make the move without thought:

“We try to stay with what has worked for us in the past,” Esh said of the Amish community. “And to be moving into the direction of the electronic world is a big move for us, and it’s not something that we take lightly.”

Still, Esh is not going to be handling the web part himself, and is taking an approach common with Amish businesses with an online presence – using a non-Amish person to manage it:

Even with the website taking orders, Esh does not own a computer or use the website directly. Instead, he works with a web manager who acts as an intermediary between the online customers and Goot Essa. Esh crafts the site’s messaging and Goot Essa’s new monthly e-letters and marketing, but leaves the tech work to the web manager, who is not a member of the Amish community.

If you’re curious what this online presence looks like, you can visit the Goot Essa site here. They have a pretty nice looking site with attractive design.

Esh says he has since been getting some of his restaurant and winery business back. But I won’t be surprised if they do well on this new model of selling as well. Not all Amish are positioned in a market and church background which would permit this kind of pivot, but for Esh and his fellow farmers it worked…and they might come out ahead of the game in the end.

Business aside, the cheese itself looks delicious, and I also like the packaging and naming. I also favor the fact that John Esh Jr. is involved in the site’s messaging and the newsletters and marketing, rather than just handing all that off to a third party. That’s going to give you some kind of “Amish touch”, and add to the story behind the product, and I think can only add to the enjoyment of eating the cheese. I also liked this detail from the website:

We do not ship on Thursday, Friday or Saturday unless delivery can be guaranteed within 2 days. We are insistent on this, as we do not want our cheese to sit in a heated building for an extra day or two, losing quality during that time.

So if you want to buy cheese directly from Amish, but can’t get to a community, this is one way to consider doing that online. They sell a few other food items too. I haven’t tasted the cheese yet, but am looking forward to doing so, and if any of you have or will, I hope you’ll let us know what you think.

Get the Amish in your inbox

Join 15,000 email subscribers. No spam. 100% free

    Similar Posts

    Leave a Reply to Robert Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


    1. Alex Knisely

      There's always an end-run around what you KNOW God wants

      Jews hiring Christians to turn on their Sabbath heating, Amishmen hiring English to interface with the computer.

      What an easily bamboozled God these people serve.

      1. Deborah Royce

        Suggestion and info wanted

        What rennet do you use? Also do you have rennetless cheese? If not, please consider. There’s a very small market presently offering it. Ty for your kind consideration.

    2. Robert

      Our God

      And Our God has you to judge and complain!! Get you own house in order.

      1. Geo

        dueling Gods

        “My superstition is better than yours”, (a line from a Simpsons episode).

    3. Maureen

      Cheese lover

      Thank you for making these cheeses. I look forward to trying them.
      I love cheese. I expect they will be delicious because they are straight from the farm.

      God bless you

      1. Agree, they look great. I am a big fan of cheese too. I’d most like to try that cheddar, never had the woodsmoked variety.

    4. Robert


      I would also like to try the Cheddar but not sure if I would like it smoked.

    5. Maureen

      my my my.. cheese

      Absolutely delicious!
      My taste buds will be blessed for a bit.
      I must believe Gods Hand is in this someway.

      Thank you