Amish Communities in Virginia
The number of Amish communities in Virginia has tripled in that time. Amish from other states have moved in to create growing settlements, drawn by more affordable land. As of 2023, there are around a dozen Amish locations in Virginia, with nearly 2,000 Amish living in the state.
Amish in Virginia: Locations
After relatively limited settlement in the 1990s and 2000s, Amish interest in Virginia picked up, with eight communities added since 2013. Here’s a look at several of the more established Amish settlements in VA.
Pearisburg (Giles County)
The oldest Amish community in Virginia is found in Giles County near the town of Pearisburg, founded in 1993. Giles County is a mountainous county lying in the Appalachian range of southwest Virginia. As of 2008, this settlement consisted of 2 church districts but has since declined to 1.
Charlotte County saw its first Amish arrivals a few years after Pearisburg, in 1997. The Charlotte County VA Amish group has Lancaster County roots, and likewise drives the recognizable charcoal grey-topped buggies. The community is located outside the county seat of Charlotte Court House.
Amish families in Charlotte County operate small businesses, including at least one sawmill, along with dairy farms. Homes and farms are sparsely scattered about the hills and rolling terrain of Charlotte County. Unless you are looking for them, it is difficult to notice that there is an Amish settlement here.
Similar to Lancaster County, the Dover settlement has experienced significant land pressures due to the nearby city of Dover and its expanding population. The Delaware Amish settlement has lost significant numbers of Amish, with roughly 50 families leaving the community for a total of 16 states in 2010. One of those destinations is the small Halifax County community.
The Halifax County Amish were just a small group as of 2011. A handful of homes, perhaps no more than a dozen households comprise this community of one congregation.
Judging by the look of the homes and land, the area has a more prosperous appearance than the one at Charlotte County, which are a plainer group. This likely reflects the fact that land prices in that area of Delaware have been quite high and those Amish who have sold and moved likely made out well.
Among the Halifax County Amish you’ll also find a number of entrepreneurs, including a shed builder, hickory rocker maker, a furniture business (read more about VA Amish furniture), and quilts.
Other Amish settlements in VA
As of 2008, a fourth Virginia Amish settlement was found in Lee County, near the towns of Rose Hill and Jonesville. It appears this community later went extinct, though a second community was started in the same general area in 2020.
The settlement at Farmville was started by Amish from Lancaster County in 2016. It has rapidly attracted Amish from that community, and has grown to four churches in size as of 2023, becoming the third-largest community in the state. The Northern Neck region of Richmond County saw a similarly-fast-growing community started in 2019.
Other Amish communities were settled in locations including Burke’s Garden (marking the second Amish community in this remote area, following a prior failed settlement), Monterey in Highland County, and two separate communities in Pittsylvania County.
Historical Amish settlement in Virginia
A handful of Amish settlements existed in VA beginning in the late 1800s up to the mid-20th century.
The settlement at Midland in Fauquier County, founded 1892, lay in close proximity to Washington DC, about 50 miles away. Thanks to a railway line that ran through the settlement, the Amish here were able to market their dairy and produce in Washington.
Historian David Luthy reports they also took “excursions”, paying an 80-cent round-trip fare to travel into the city to view the historical sites.
This settlement grew fairly quickly, with at least 27 different households here over it’s near-decade in existence, but went extinct quickly as well, for unexplained reasons. By 1901, the last Amish had left (The Amish in America: Settlements that Failed 1840-1960, David Luthy pp. 471-475).
A “coastal” Amish settlement was found near Kempsville, in Princess Anne County. This community lay near Norfolk, were the Amish did business and sold products such as sausage and produce, and was referred to by the name of that city. A train connected this community with Virginia Beach, allowing the Amish ample chances to visit the ocean.
This community grew slowly and in close proximity to a more progressive Amish-Mennonite group. Most Amish in this community were dairy farmers, and grew oats, wheat, and corn, as well as crops of clover.
The Norfolk community adopted tractors in the 1910s, and eventually electricity, with the tractor becoming a means of road transport. Since many of the settlers originated in Somerset County, PA, which had meetinghouses, they were soon built in Princess Anne County as well.
Eventually, most members of this community pushed for acceptance of the automobile. Some of the church leadership and a minority of the members in turn moved to form a community at Stuarts Draft in the Shenandoah Valley. Those remaining affiliated with the Beachy Amish. Due to urbanization from Norfolk and Virginia Beach, most traces of Amish settlement in Princess Anne County have been eradicated (Settlements that Failed, pp. 475-483)
The Stuarts Draft settlement founded by the Norfolk group lasted from 1942 until 1981, when it disbanded. Some families in this community also joined the Beachy Amish movement, with others moving to Tennessee (see GAMEO, “Virginia (USA)” ).
Other failed Virginia Amish settlements include a community at Portsmouth, lasting from 1927 to 1945 (Settlements that Failed, pp. 483-486).
Mennonites in Virginia
Amish have made attempts to settle in Virginia dating back to the late 1800s. Recent interest in the state has rapidly expanded Virginia’s Amish population. Virginia’s closeness to communities in states like Pennsylvania and Delaware make it an attractive destination for those seeking more space and less expensive land. Virginia’s overall Amish population still remains low however, in comparison to states like Pennsylvania or Ohio.
Virginia is also home to significant Mennonite communities, including Old Order Mennonites, Conservative Mennonites, as well as Beachy Amish. One such plain Mennonite community is found in the same Northern Neck area as the Amish community mentioned above is located.
- “Amish Population 2022” Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Elizabethtown College https://groups.etown.edu/amishstudies/statistics/population-2022/
- “Amish Population in the United States by State, County, and Settlement, 2022” – Annual population figures compiled by Edsel Burdge, Jr., Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Elizabethtown College, in cooperation with Joseph F. Donnermeyer, School of Environment and Natural Resources, The Ohio State University, and with assistance from David Luthy, Heritage Historical Library, Aylmer, Ontario.
- The Amish in America: Settlements that Failed, 1840-1960, David Luthy
- The New American Almanac, Raber’s Bookstore (Baltic, Ohio), Ben J. Raber
- GAMEO: “Virginia (USA)”
- “The Old Order Amish Community at Stuarts Draft, Virginia”, Moses Beachy