Amish Toy Shop (Conewango Valley, NY)

Raber Family Toy Shop
11363 Pope Rd
Randolph, NY 14772-9681

Have a look inside an Amish toy shop courtesy of Tom. This store is located in New York’s Conewango Valley, and as you can see below features a wide-array of Amish-made wooden toys.

Amish Toys NY
A road sign points the way to an Amish toy shop in Conewango Valley (NY)


Amish Toy Shop
Amish Toy Shop, New York


Amish Wooden Toys
Amish craftsmen create a wide variety of wooden toys

I enjoy seeing the creativity that goes into some of these products. It makes me wonder what is the story behind each design.  A lot of course are classics.  Which do the Amish use themselves, which come about due to customer feedback and requests?

Amish Made Sling Shots
Look out, Amish-made sling shots


Wooden Amish-made Toy Buggy
Amish buggy, all-wood variety


Amish Made Wooden Apples
These apples look nearly real enough to eat

Toymaking is one of those fairy tale professions which captures the imagination.  And “Amish toymaker” is a double whammy in that department.  It seems like an Amish toymaker character would do well in fiction.

Amish Toy Truck
This toy truck will soon drive out the door


Amish Toy Horse Swing
Take a ride on an Amish-made horse swing


Amish Toy Store
Get your ducks, rabbits, penguins on-a-stick

Where to find the store:

Raber Family Toy Shop
11363 Pope Rd
Randolph, NY 14772-9681

Get the Amish in your inbox

Join 15,000 email subscribers. No spam. 100% free

    Similar Posts

    Leave a Reply to Bob Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


    1. SharonR

      Amish Toy Shop

      How interesting! Love the hand crafted and homemade items! These are truly “Made in the USA”! Much more durable than “plastic” things that are mass produced imported from foreign countries!!
      Hats off to all of our local craftsmen!

    2. Nic

      Amish made toys

      In the picture with the ‘Apple note holder’, there are items just below the apples with mason/canning jars upside down, & with a small ribbon, as part of the item … what are they? Just curious if it is some type of bee/bird feeder-we use them in our starter hives for the bees. Thanks.

      1. Barbara Libengood

        I think they are candy or bubblegum dispensers. Push a button and get a few M&Ms or other small candies. My husband had one in his store for customers.

      2. Tom

        They are M and M dispensers.

      3. Roberta Klooster

        Wooden toy with jar inverted

        Hi Nic,
        No – those are candy dispensers! We had one for a while when we had young grandchildren. They do well with jelly beans or M&M’s and dispense a several candies when you pull the “tab” (not sure what to call it) out. It’s fun. Trouble is my husband ate most oft he candy. ha ha.

      4. Donna Phillips

        candy dispenser

        I purchased the smaller of the two. I keep it filled with peanut m&ms. We go every year from Florida to NY. The Toy Store was our first stop. Their daughter Katie and husband have a wood turning business. Beautiful bowls. 3 bowls, one for me one for each sister from the same piece of wood! Also beautiful birdhouses. We have eaten with Dan and Sarah in their home. Homemade wood stove baked bologna! Dan died last year! Son Store keeps it going now. Lots of games!!!

    3. Amy Jo

      Amish Toy Shop

      Great post Erik! Many years ago my husband made the candy dispenser (like the ones you can see on the self just below the apple note-holders). Not the fancy knob but the same idea. We put M&M’s in in when the family(ies) come to visit. It is a huge hit with the grandkids (and their parents)… and we are asked about it if it is not out for them to use! They always look forward to it. The big kids/adults want the sweet but the liitle ones also love to operate it and watch how the candy ‘magically’ comes out the little shute!

    4. Lin

      Notice the prices are simply on the even dollar or 25 cents – no 99 cents to complicate the figuring and change-making.

      In photos 3 & 6, we used to have a “bubble gum machine” like that. We filled the glass jar with marbles and turned the knob to dispense them. But the glass top broke.

      1. Tom

        The prices have the sales tax already included. so you pay the price and walk out with the item.

    5. Oh, I love it! And such reasonable prices.

    6. How fun – I don’t think I’ve ever seen an Amish toy store OR pictures from one! That was a fun post ~

    7. Lee Ann

      Would love to get that horse swing! Those toys would last a lifetime. I still have a wooden airplane one of my kids got when they were little. Wooden toys are alot better than plastic for sure.

      Wish there was an Amish toy store near me and I would be in there shopping.

      1. Margie Winters

        Ordering another wooden horse swing

        I bought a wooden horse swing very similar to the one in the picture, while visiting family in the Nashville, Tennessee area. My relatives shipped it to me. My two grandsons have enjoyed it a lot. It however got broken, might have been by our lawn mower. I would like to buy another one to replace the first one.

        Would it be possible for someone to send me an estimate of the cost of the swing, as well as the shipping cost, and the estimated shipping time?

        Thank you for your help, and I look forward to hearing from you.

        Margie Winters

    8. Naomi

      Oh, I just want to eat that place up! Thanks for the post.

    9. Carolyn B

      Loved the buggy and 18-wheeler truck. My Barbies would have been wheeled all over the house if I’d had that buggy or my brother that truck.
      Thanks to Tom & Erik.

    10. Theresa

      I have had the pleasure of going to this toy shop several times. It is one of my favorite Amish places to take the kids. They love riding on the wooden horse swing!

      Tom, do you know the family that runs this shop? They are very nice. I am surprised they let you take pictures inside. They have a sign on the door that says no photos. Of course, that means no photos of the Amish themselves but I have always been shy to pull out my camera in this area whenever there are people anywhere near by.

      Thanks for sharing the photos. My daughter was thrilled to see pictures of this shop. It is like visiting again!

      1. Tom

        Yes I know the family that owns the toy shop and I have a collection of “big boy toys” that they make. There is sign by the door and I think that it says “no pictures of Amish people”. I always ask if it is OK if I take pictures and most of the time the answer is Yes. I am sure you have seen the mouse trap toy and the disappearing coin toy. It is a fun place.

    11. OldKat

      Thanks Tom. Interesting place.

    12. Theresa

      Tom yes we have enjoyed all their trick toys ánd brain teasers. Years ago the older gentleman had my husband and I tied up in a rope trick that we had to try to get out of. Good thing my hubby is good at puzzles! Always fun to visit there and see their new offerings! Thanks again for the pictures!

      1. Donna Phillips

        tied up

        Did Dan ever “measure” you? He laid a 6 foot length of twine on the counter. Told me to make a circle of how Round I thought I was. Held it to me, said Nope, too much!. Now hold the very end of twine. He pulled his thumb down, “now stop me when you think that’s how tall you are”. I stopped him at 4 ft 6 I thought. He looked at the length thoughtfully and said ” lay down on that bench”. He was going to see how close I was. ” Nope too short, hold it in your mouth”. I did! He said to everyone in the store, ” this is the first Florida Sucker I caught all day”! And there I lay with a string in my mouth! God bless them all!

    13. Bob


      Nice Tom – I live about 4 miles from the toy shop – where are you?

    14. George

      Since you know the family that owns the shop – do they have a catalog?
      I think a lot of us would like to purchase a toy or two…
      Christmas is not far away.

    15. George

      I’m sorry, I meant to say Tom, not Theresa…

      1. Tom

        I don’t think that they have a catalog. I will be in the settlement over Memorial Day weekend, please email me at and give me an idea of items you would be interested in. I will email you pictures and prices.

    16. nelson

      Stoney Creek Toyworks

      a very nice toy shop with all kinds of wooden toys is found close to Topeka , Indiana.
      Lamar and Ruby Arlene Miller
      7305 S 1200 W
      Millersburg Indiana 46543

      write to them for a brochure…

      1. sherry


        Tom, do you have address that i can write to this toy shop i would love to ge the horse and buggy and few other toys? thank you Sherry

        1. Bob

          Toy Store

          Hi Sherry – this Bob White and I live about 3 mile from the toy store.
          It’s owned by Dan Raber and family.
          11363 Pope Rd
          Randolph, NY 14772-9681

    17. Margie Winters

      Wood horse swing

      Please send me the information where I can buy the pictured Amish wooden horse swing.

    18. ShipshewanaIndiana

      Great pictures Tom! Thanks for sharing.

    19. Gretchen Latowsky

      Purchasing the apple note holders

      How can I purchase the apple note holders?

    20. Sandy Thorkildsen

      looking for information on the wooden horse swing

      I would like to purchase the wooden horse swing on this web site. I need some information on the price and can you ship to Illinois and what that cost would also be.

      Thank you.

      1. Contact info for the Amish toy shop

        Sandy and others looking to buy from this store, we don’t sell their products via this site, but a reader higher up the thread shared contact info. I am assuming this is correct:

        It’s owned by Dan Raber and family.
        11363 Pope Rd
        Randolph, NY 14772-9681

        Don’t have a contact number, it’s a plain Amish community so very well may not be one. But if you want to try contacting them the old-fashioned way, you might write a letter.

        1. Bob White

          Live Nearby

          As mentioned before, I live nearby the toy store April – Nov and may be able to pick up some items for someone on the list that is interested and send. Contact me at if interested.

        2. Sandy

          Horse swing

          Thank you so much Erik. I like the old fashioned way of doing things. I will contact them via US mail.


    21. Lorraine


      Since we live about 2 hours away, can you tell me the hours and Days the store is open.

    22. Troy Hendrickson


      Please confirm if you accept Visa or Mastercard payment for an email order and private collection.



    23. toy shop

      is this business still open? I just saw its article. I am looking for wooden toys like a dancing dan or running doll. I also like those apple note holders. lots of nice things.

    24. Paulette

      Hours of operation

      Can you please tell me your hours of operation?

    25. Debbie

      Rocking horse

      I’m looking to purchase a rocking horse for a first birthday party.
      Do you have any? I need by 2/16/24.