Amish Markets – Indiana

Amish Markets in the Hoosier State

IN Amish Market

Indiana is home to over 40,000 Amish. A number of market locations sell Amish products around the state, from those in the southern Indiana Amish community of Daviess County, to the Fort Wayne-area communities of Adams and Allen counties, to the heavily-Amish regions of northern Indiana around Nappanee and Shipshewana.

View full Amish Market Directory.

Amish Markets in Indiana

Northern Indiana  Fort Wayne Area  Southern Indiana

Know of a good IN Amish market? Let us know in the comments section.

Northern Indiana

Grandma’s Pantry
Behind Subway on SR 19
107 Keystone Drive
Wakarusa, IN
Amish store with homemade foods, meats and deli, located in the Nappanee Amish settlement.

Blue Gate Bakery
195 North Van Buren Street
Shipshewana, IN
Amish made fresh pies, cookies, bars, homemade bread and much more.

Fort Wayne Area

Downtown Auburn Farmers Market
P.O. Box 6122
Auburn, IN
Provides local products including Amish Graber Farms’ fresh certified organic produce. Market open in season between June and October.

Barr Street Market
Corner Wayne and Barr Streets
Fort Wayne, IN
Open Saturdays 9am – 1pm
July 7th – September 15th
Large selection of local grown products including organic produce from Amish-owned Graber’s farm.

Decatur Market
231 East Monroe Street
Decatur, IN
Open Thursday 3:30pm – 6:30pm
June 6th – October 24th
Organic produce from Graber’s farm available.  Located near the Adams County Amish settlement.

Salomon Farm Market
817 DuPont Road
between Coldwater and Lima Rd.
Fort Wayne, IN
Open Wednesdays, 5pm-8pm
June 19th- September 26th
Organic Amish grown products among a large assortment of non-Amish items.

Miller Poultry
9622 West 350 North
Orland, IN
Small family-owned company, provides poultry raised by Amish families in small flocks.

Southern Indiana

Dutch Pantry
13014 N 1100 E
Odon, IN 47562
Amish-run business, provides homemade products such as bulk foods, deli meats, cheeses, sandwiches, candies, jar goods, baked goods and crafts.

Gasthof Amish Village
6747 E Gasthof Village Rd
Montgomery, IN
Gasthof Amish Village is located in Southern Indiana. In the 92-acre village you will find a restaurant, antiques, gift shop and hotel. Gasthof’s buffet offers authentic food made by Amish women. The gift shop features Amish produce, crafts and food.

Fruits photo: USDAgov/flickr

Get the Amish in your inbox

Join 15,000 email subscribers. No spam. 100% free

    Leave a Reply to Michelle Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


    1. Joe Owen

      Market Master

      Looking for Venders, @ Daleville Farmers Market, every Saturday until Oct.25, 2014; must comply with Delaware County board of Health. Please call me @ home 765-378-5221 or cell 765-425-1196 or stop in @ Daleville, Indiana Town Hall.

      Need Garden Plants, flowers, early veg. and anything home grown or made, and just come and help make this a successful market. Looking forward too hearing from you.

    2. Spice Shop In Grabill IN

      Hi! Just found this site a few weeks ago and have been making my way through it. I’m Amish but seems I’m learning things I didn’t know!

      Grabill, IN doesn’t seem to have the small, home-based businesses that a lot of communities do but I thought I would invite you all to my shop called The Spice Shack. We specialize in bulk seasonings, medicinal/culinary herbs, loose-leaf teas, baking ingredients, and just recently started adding assorted kitchen accessories.

      If you are in the area, stop by the shop and say HI!

    3. Hillary McCarty

      Looking for Amish Produce

      Hi there! I just moved to evansville IN from Fort Wayne, (Allen County) I’ve been buying my produce from an Amish Market on Doty Rd. in Allen County for 20 + years and am struggling to find anything like it here in Southern IN. I am willing to drive an hour or more if necessary to find an Amish grown produce. If there are any you know of my kids and I would really appreciate the info on them!
      Hillary McCarty

      1. Hillary, if you’re in Evansville, you’re only about an hour from the largest Amish community in southern Indiana – Daviess County area. Home to almost 5,000 Amish, quite a bit larger than Allen County. Nice area. I bet you’d find what you need there. The Amish live more or less between the towns of Odon and Montgomery.

        There are also other communities that might be closer to you in southern Indiana, though not as large.

        Happy produce hunting!

      2. Al in Ky

        Hillary — Erik posted a good suggestion and I’ll provide another. In Daviess County there is a very good Amish produce auction (I’ve been there many times). I believe auctions are held beginning in April and last until the end of October each year. The peak months for produce are June through mid-September (not much produce available in April and early May). Their address is 9084 E. 550 N., Montgomery, Indiana, with their phone number being 812-486-2445. You may call that number beginning in April to get the auction schedule. It is held two to three days each week.
        The first part of the auction features “large lots” which are bought mainly by stores, produce stands, etc. who do re-sale, but
        during the last part of the auction “small lots” are sold, where you can buy smaller amounts suitable for home use. There are probably smaller produce stands in that area; just ask around at one of the Amish stores in Daviess Co. and they likely can direct you.
        The produce auction barn is across the road from Dinky’s Auction, a large auction barn that has auctions beginning at 6 p.m. almost every Friday year-round. During the summer months, they also sell a lot of Amish-grown produce in small lots. I have bought much very good produce at Dinky’s at very reasonable prices.

    4. Chrissy

      16 oz square mason jars for sale

      We have a truck load of 16 oz square mason jars for sale. There are 65,000 jars on the truck load. Asking price $6000 for all. It comes to about 9 cents per jar (before deliver charge). If you are interested please let me know.

    5. Greh French

      Looking for scrapple

      Grew up in eastern PA eating fried scrapple wigh apple butter. Live in the Indianapolis area and want to buy some but can’t find it.

    6. Grace

      Friends/ pen pals

      Hello, I am looking for a Amish family with the last name Stoltzfus. I am friends with two of the daughters and I am having trouble contacting them. Of course I could do it by letter, which I have always done but for some reason my last one did not make it at there home. If there is a faster way to come in contact with them, please let me know.

    7. Sabrina Stephenson

      Searching & Learning

      Hi, I am located in Indianapolis, just minutes from center of downtown, and have been looking for an Amish place to purchase meat, produce and other goods. It seems every place I’ve found is 2 to 3 hour drive. Does anyone have any suggestions on places closer to buy produce, cheese, baked goods and stock up on Amish meat? Any suggestions would be helpful! Thanks I’m advance!!!!

      1. Susan Robinson

        Indiana Amish market

        Try Wilson’s on US 31 near Arcadia. They have everything!!

    8. Susan Robinson

      Indiana Amish market

      WOW! You didn’t list the best one in the state! Fountain Acres Foods in Fountain City Indiana is amazing!

    9. Richard Van Gorp

      Fountain Acres

      Our favorite Amish store is near Richmond, IN. Fountain Acres, Fountain City, IN