23 responses to Amish Scout Land on Prince Edward Island
  • *
    Comment on Amish Scout Land on Prince Edward Island (October 20th, 2014 at 06:39)

    Interesting! I wonder what community in Ontario they are from? I have not seen anything in The Budget or Die Botschaft about this.

    • *
      Comment on Amish Scout Land on Prince Edward Island (October 21st, 2014 at 10:25)

      Good question Mark, maybe we’ll hear more if there’s a follow-up article.

      • *
        Peter Blackwell
        Comment on Amish in PEI (January 25th, 2016 at 12:29)

        Amish in PEI

        Several parcels of land near Cardigan in Kings County PEI, have been purchased by two Amish communities from Ontario, the communities are from Norwich and Millbank. Here is the link. I also heard mention of them coming at the feed store.


  • *
    Comment on O Amish Canada... (October 20th, 2014 at 06:57)

    O Amish Canada...

    I have no idea, but I’ll be watching the comments keenly for updates.

    This is a cool way to start the week.

  • *
    Katie Troyer
    Comment on Amish Scout Land on Prince Edward Island (October 20th, 2014 at 07:19)

    If I am not mistaken a few Aylmer Ontario Amish had looked at land on PEI many years ago.

  • *
    Osiah Horst
    Comment on PEI and Amish (October 20th, 2014 at 08:51)

    PEI and Amish

    Thirty five years ago my father, Isaac R. Horst, said he would have liked to investigate PEI. At the time I was scouting out Eastern Ontario so placed a phone call to someone in PEI. The answer I got then was “If you are interested in starting a settlement in PEI, keep it quiet until you are buying! Farmland is quite limited so prices would increase rapidly.”

    The Orthodox Mennonites, a group of ultra conservative Mennonites from Gorrie, Ontario, who are often mistaken for Amish,were actively checking out settlement possibilities in Quebec several years ago. The political climate did not suit most of them so a few were also investigating PEI at the same time. The Orthodox Mennonites have now started a settlement at Douglas, Ontario, not far from our community, just west of Ottawa.

    • *
      Comment on Amish and land prices (October 21st, 2014 at 10:20)

      Amish and land prices

      Interesting story Osiah. It must be limited if that was a concern. I can see the benefit of Amish or Mennonites arranging multiple transactions at once and without a lot of fanfare, especially if a number of families are known to be moving.

      In a sense they are at a disadvantage in the market, if it is known by sellers that Amish want to live near other Amish, and in fact have to live within a certain limited range if they want to be a part of a given church or settlement. However that might be offset if those selling the land had an active interest in getting an Amish settlement started in their community. The effect on land prices of Amish or Mennonites moving into an area would make an interesting study; there might even have been something done on this already which I’m not recalling right now.

      • *
        Ed from NY
        Comment on Amish Scout Land on Prince Edward Island (October 26th, 2014 at 14:33)

        The ultra-orthodox Jews, who must live within walking distance of a synagogue, have similar real estate issues. They prefer to dwell in urban settings. But as anyone who’se been around Lakewood, NJ, or Kiryas Joel, NY, or a number of neighborhoods in Brooklyn, NY, knows, once Haredim Jews start to move in, real estate prices zoom upwards. For the Amish, I imagine the trend might be even more pronounced, because urban real estate can be made more denser much easierr than rural real estate.

        So I wouldn’t broadcast too much that the Amish might be looking to buy real estate on a small island. On the other hand, i have thought that buying land near an Amish settkement would be a wise investment choice. As would buying urban real estate in an newly created eruv.

        • *
          Comment on More details on potential Amish PEI migrants (October 27th, 2014 at 12:38)

          More details on potential Amish PEI migrants

          Nice example Ed. I did not know that they needed to be walking distance from a synagogue.

          Another Canadian news outlet has done a short story on this group, giving more details:


          Two families from the conservative religious group in a settlement near Stratford, Ont., went to Prince Edward Island last week to check out farmland on the east coast, where land is 10 times cheaper than here.

          “It’s night and day. Land prices here are $15,000 to $20,000 an acre. That’s unaffordable for a mixed-use farm operation,” said Tony Wallbank, the Princeton, Ont. man who drove the two families to P.E.I.

          In P.E.I., farmland goes $1,500 to $2,500 an acre, he said.

          “There’s good weather, lots of small farms, laid-back people. The Amish couldn’t believe how friendly everyone there was,” he said.

          Scoping out the land is the start of what could be a two-year process to move several families from Southwestern Ontario to the Maritimes, Wallbank said.

  • *
    Comment on Amish Scout Land on Prince Edward Island (October 20th, 2014 at 10:27)

    I’m glad they are scouting out new territory. Too many Americans have become too mean.

  • *
    Juanita Cook
    Comment on Amish Scout Land on Prince Edward Island (October 20th, 2014 at 10:39)

    I hope they can find what they are looking for at an affordable price. Land is so overpriced everywhere these days. Wish them the best.

  • *
    Comment on Amish Come Back to British Columbia! (October 20th, 2014 at 18:19)

    Amish Come Back to British Columbia!

    Please come back. There is lots of great farming land in the Slocan Valley and lots of places for sale. Weather is good and the valley is fertile – perfect for family operated organic farms. I know no Amish will actually read this but I’m putting the word out: Slocan Valley, British Columbia. We want you here. (Well, me, really, I’m being selfish).

    • *
      Comment on Amish return to British Columbia? (October 21st, 2014 at 10:24)

      Amish return to British Columbia?

      Jennifer you never know! 🙂 I think one of the main issues with British Columbia not being viable was the sheer distance from other Amish communities, especially at the time (late 1960s) when there weren’t even any of the current Amish settlements in Montana in existence.

      If I had to guess, I would guess BC will see Amish again, eventually–it just might not be in our lifetimes.

  • *
    Kentucky Lady 717
    Comment on Amish Scout Land on Prince Edward Island (October 20th, 2014 at 18:22)

    Don’t feel bad Erik, neither do I except I hear it’s a beautiful place…….and good for them……I think it’s really cold there tho especially right now…….
    I hate cold weather…it is 58 here and my furnace has gotten a work out today……just can’t stand it cold…..

  • *
    Kentucky Lady 717
    Comment on Amish Scout Land on Prince Edward Island (October 21st, 2014 at 11:39)

    Very interesting,I have a friend who lives in Ontario, will give her a call and ask her if she knows…….
    I love Canada…..I could live there, no problem :)it is totally different from the US…..after you get there, seems a big relief to be there, seems much safer than some of the other places I have lived in the states……don’t get me wrong I LOVE THE USA……but Ontario is just wonderful……another country and so close to us……used to go a lot when I lived in Mich. just cross over the border and you were there…..my friend and I went over and spent the day once and just drove around and looked at the country……
    We took the Ferry over, had my car on the ferry and drove all over……went to some Indian Reservation…..now can’t remember just where that was…..we stopped and had a picnic lunch beside the water, was a wonderful day……memories,memories eh? 🙂

    Will have to call my friend who lives there and ask her…..never really heard her mention the Amish that much tho…..

    • *
      Comment on Amish Scout Land on Prince Edward Island (October 21st, 2014 at 14:39)

      Because of your reply I feel a little humbled into knowing a little bit of how the Amish must feel about English people visiting and being awestruck by the day-to-day lives and “differences” of their place in the world and their choices. I have volunteered in my local tourism industry for a long time and I have met lots of Americans who have told me “I love your area, I love Canada” and I’m like “So do I”, so I do get where your coming from, Kentucky Lady 717, I am thrilled you enjoyed where you where. I wondered when I first read your reply if you had actually gone to Manitoulan Island and visited there, there was an Indian Reservation last I knew (I can’t remember myself if was on the Island or not, I was like 11 and I don’t remember, I just remember a flock of native girls staring at me) and a provincially famous ferry service called the “Chi Chi Mon” (or Chee Chee Man depending on what you look at).
      Come back soon, there is lots to see and do in Ontario, including visiting Old Order communities.

      • *
        Comment on Amish Scout Land on Prince Edward Island (October 21st, 2014 at 16:28)

        Thank you Slightly-Handled-Order-Man…..I would love to and look forward one day coming back…..too cold right now to think about traveling……I just want the comfort of my warm home…..not much traveling out of me in the winter 🙂
        Last time my sister & I went to visit my friend who lives there, she took us to a few of the Casinos….(not really my favorite place to go tho) but we had a nice visit…….I worked with her in Detroit and we became good friends, not going on …..not exactly sure but way over 20 yrs……..she still ushers at the Cleary (I think that is the name of it )so have you been there ?
        We both ushered at the FOX in Detroit a couple of times for me, not sure if she worked more or not…..I didn’t really care to be an usher…..I’d rather go and see the performers…..saw Tom Jones there,and an ELVIS impersonator…..boy did I enjoy that one :)loved Elvis…… so take care….TTYL

      • *
        Comment on Canada's different from the US - no its not (sometimes). (October 22nd, 2014 at 19:40)

        Canada's different from the US - no its not (sometimes).

        Amish America readership may or may not be knowledgeable of the tragedy that happened in Ottawa, Canada, involving the Parliament building and the National War Memorial on Wednesday, October 22, 2014, but I thought I’d say that this sort of event is not limited to the United States, in fact it does happen here in Canada, I don’t know why it happened, I am not going to rush to judgment of the now identified suspect, as a consumer of media and a proud Canadian I am going to sleep on it.
        I am not going to give away my exact location, but I know where the slain soldier came from, I know the city of Hamilton as I was born and raised there. I know the building, “The James Street Armories” (there is a longer name to the building, involving an officer’s name, but most people know it by referring to the street it is located on) his regiment was stationed out of, I’ve had friends who have served with various units out of that same building, and have had friends host pre-wedding parties in the storied facility.
        Its heart rending a Canadian to see this happen, it hurts so bad as a person who has a family history of military service (current and past), and as person who grew up in the same city as the slain, heart aches
        This evening, to the statement “Canada is so much different than Canada” sadly, I must say sometimes, because of the actions of horribly misguided and deranged individuals it can be no different (and it has happened before, innocents have been shot dead, countless women die, police officers fall victim to vengeful people) than the USA or any other country.
        I am sorry about the downer, I’m sorry I’ve gotten off topic (the Amish in PEI) I am saddened about this day’s events. Sorry, this is a might to serious for me as “SHOM”, but I wanted to share this somewhere.
        There are days when events takes down boarders and strips away faiths and we all should show solidarity with the fallen as human beings.

  • *
    marie b
    Comment on amish scout land on p.e.i. (October 25th, 2014 at 22:12)

    amish scout land on p.e.i.

    I have Amish and Mennonite friends that live in the St.Jacobs Ontario Amish country, (about 1hr from Toronto) and they have visited that area often. They said they thought it was really beautiful, and enjoy the peacefulness of the area. Maybe they have family members scouting out the area, for cheaper farm land. I know that it is very expensive here and when land goes up for sale, it bought up quickly and not always by and Amish or Mennonite families. I find it sad when I see all these farmlands turning in to residential or commercial development. I enjoy traveling those back roads and stopping at the farm stands, and getting to the know the people of those areas.

  • *
    Comment on Pluses and minuses of moving to PEI (October 29th, 2014 at 16:08)

    Pluses and minuses of moving to PEI

    Another follow-up article about this potential move. The gentleman helping them reports on the visit positively, however says none of the group that visited plans to move, citing the 22 hour drive as an issue. He plans to bring another group of Amish in a couple of weeks (for whatever it’s worth, commenters on this article, a number of whom sound like PEI locals, seem mixed-positive and negative about the idea):


    Wallbank has tried moving some communities to Northern Ontario where the land is cheaper but the terrain is rugged and not conducive to mixed farming, he said.

    “This past spring they couldn’t even grow oats which is a pretty basic crop. You can grow oats almost anywhere but up there the crops were no good at all so that was discouraging to the Amish I took there.”

    There are many reasons why Amish would thrive on P.E.I.

    The soil is excellent, the growing season is longer than Northern Ontario and the land prices are cheaper, said Wallbank.

    On Oct. 14, Wallbank and a group of Amish from Millbank Ontario made the 22-hour drive to check out P.E.I., mainly the eastern part of the Island.

    The Amish noticed Route 3 and Route 4 had paved shoulders wide enough for a buggy to go down, he said.

    “There is little chance that there would be a collision. It’s a safer environment than what it is here in Ontario.”

    Islanders made the Amish women feel very much at home and the Amish men were impressed by the courtesy of the people and the pleasant humour of Islanders, he said.

  • Another pro-Amish voice on Prince Edward Island

    Seems like people are excited about getting the Amish to PEI. Following two recent articles, today brought an editorial urging residents to welcome the Amish:


    It’s unusual that the P.E.I. government isn’t playing a more active role trying to convince the Amish to relocate here. The group traditionally shuns using public health care, prefers to pay their own way with prescription drugs and hospital care and looks after their elderly in their own homes. All the Amish need is a little encouragement to help three to five families get settled and then more would follow.

    Besides putting land back into production and providing a population boost to the province, the Amish are a peace-loving community which would stabilize agriculture and the population base in Kings County. Amish use organic farming methods and avoid pesticides. Their environmental footprint is very light.

    Residents in southern Kings and Queens counties remember the arrival of many Dutch and Belgium farmers who came to the area in the 1960s to grow tobacco. They were a welcome addition to the Island community and the Amish would be as well.

  • *
    Comment on Amish PEI move update (February 19th, 2015 at 11:43)

    Amish PEI move update

    Just another update on the highly anticipated, maybe-yes maybe-no possible Amish move to Prince Edward Island 😉

    In a new report, a local real estate agent suggests a move is “imminent”, and that “There are still a few hurdles to overcome, but if all goes according to plan, the Amish families would be living on PEI before the 2016 cropping season.”

    However the next quote seems to suggest that nothing is solidified yet:

    “We’re really hoping we’ll get a sale or two in the spring and get the ball rolling,” Mr Oliver said.

    There have been several trips back and forth, and the article states that Amish plan to visit PEI again in May. Land prices compared to Ontario seem to be the big draw. The communities in question are Millbank and Norwich.

    There are some hurdles specific to PEI but also sounds like there are English people motivated to help it happen, including potential sellers of land and, according to an English person assisting the Amish, local government.

    Here’s the article:


Leave a reply to Amish Scout Land on Prince Edward Island


Resource List
Reliable information from one of the largest Amish sites on the web.

Join over 15,000 email subscribers to get:
Amish Community Info | Book Giveaways | Amish Writers & non-Amish Experts | More

Get email updates

100% Free | No Spam | Unsubscribe Anytime